Building on her long-term scholarly preoccupation with the entanglements of history, religion, and architecture, Kishwar Rizvi examines in The Transnational Mosque key projects sponsored by the governments of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the UAE. Each of the first four chapters is devoted to the efforts of one of those governments. The overt use of religion by the leadership in these countries serves to extend influence in the political sphere, to claim the leadership of Islam within and outside their territories, and, to a lesser degree, to mark their rising economic power.
Governments will commission “transnational” mosques in order to monumentalize their ambitions. They may build the structures within or without their national borders, presenting a form of “architectural diplomacy” in the latter case. The mosques may be built with funds from another country and may use materials, experts, and crafts also drawn from extra-national resources. Further, the architectural designs adopted typically display forms and historical references from other regions and time periods. It is in these multiple senses that mosques studied here are “transnational.”
The subtitle of the book, “Architecture and Historical Memory in the Contemporary Middle East,” announces Rizvi's interest in the question of how historical memory is embodied in architectural projects, through the design, processes of “making” or construction, and the programming of the mosques once realized. Rizvi focuses in on the intentions of the producers, including the commissioning state (patrons, clients) and architects. She interprets historical revivalism in terms of historical agency rather than dismissing it as unimaginative copying, while acknowledging at the end of the book that this is not a distributed agency, but instead one which is ultimately flattening and muting.
Due to the inherent transnational elements of the projects Rizvi examines, the case studies may or may not be located in the sponsoring country. In fact, Rizvi traces networks across a wide geography, including but not limited to cases from Italy, Germany, and Bosnia, to Lebanon, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan, Pakistan, and Japan. With the global mobility of mosques, comes the mobility of finance, expertise, and ideology. Or viewed from reverse, the mosques enable the mobility of finance, expertise, and ideology. For example, the Saudis propagate their version of (Salafi) Islam using their oil-based financial resources to fund mosque projects abroad in diverse geographies, and then contribute to shaping the activities that take place in them after they are built (88). The Saudi establishment engages in these practices because proselytization activity abroad legitimizes their government at home.
A common feature of the case studies is that, in the words of Rizvi, their “architectural design traverses geographic and temporal distances” (5). The introduction opens with the case of the Muhammad al-Amin Mosque (2008), built despite great controversy in post-war Beirut with Saudi funding and designed by Azmi Fakhouri who incorporated clear allusions to the imperial heritages of Istanbul and Cairo. According to Rizvi, the goal of looking to the past, to particular periods and places of transformation in the past, is to imagine a future defined by religious ideology. The backward glance is not reactionary or cynical (as in Postmodern Architecture of the 1980s). Rizvi explains: “Repetitions of form and echoes of the past conjure a history that is at once mutable and ever-present” (2). Rizvi turns to the “mutability of history” in her epilogue. The mosque projects examined in the book, she explains, are driven by the power of historical memory, but careful analysis of these projects also shows that history can be muted when used in the service of nationalist agendas. Both geography and history become contingent upon the mobility of actors (producers, financiers, and those with expert knowledge and skills or ideas) and forms (style, design, materials).
This book makes an important disciplinary contribution by foregrounding religion in the study of architecture. Leading media outlets in North America have frequently reported on the efforts of authoritarian rulers and regimes in the region to finance programs of mosque building;Footnote 1 however, we do not know much about how these mosques were realized as transnational projects. As a building type, mosques would and should be of interest to architectural historians of the Middle East. However, architectural historians have tended to focus on the travels and translations of architectural modernism and its imbrications with nationalism and nation-building projects (in associated building typologies and new city designs). Additionally, they have altogether dismissed most contemporary mosque-building for lacking stylistic merit since the designs tend to prefer historical references. Urban studies scholarship from within other disciplines has acknowledged the role of religion in contemporary politics and place-making, but analysis of contemporary mosques themselves is lacking within this type of scholarship, too. Thus, Rizvi addresses a glaring lacuna by studying contemporary mosques.
Of course, the mosques under consideration represent only a fraction of new mosques. To emphasize, these are very well-known, well-funded, and highly promoted projects that have required the professional services of the finest crafts-peoples and architects. The Muslim-majority countries selected for her case studies are also limited to those that consciously boast economic and political influence in the international arena. There are significant differences between each of them due to their divergent national histories, nation-building trajectories, and officially sanctioned versions of Islam. In Iran, for example, the focus of Chapter 3, the state has engaged not only in mosque- but also in shrine-building in pilgrimage complexes devoted to important Shi‘i religious figures.
Importantly, Rizvi does not cast transnational mosques in opposition to “national mosques.” Some of the “national mosques” built in the capital cities of postcolonial Muslim-majority countries (e.g., the Great Mosque of Riyadh, designed by the Jordanian architect Rasem Badran in Saudi Arabia; the Kocatepe Mosque in Ankara, Turkey, designed by Hüsrev Tayla and Fatin Uluengin; The Grand National Assembly Mosque in Turkey designed by Behruz and Can Çinici; and Sheikh Zayed Grand Mosque Center designed by Yusef Abdelki in Abu Dhabi, UAE) are also included in the discussion. National mosques typically represent the role of religion in state-making and nation-building, and they seek to educate citizens, visitors, and residents of the country. The author's analyses of the cases aptly complicate simplistic readings of such monuments by showing, for example, how national mosques may simultaneously seek to project a certain progressive face of the country to non-residents.
Trained as an architect and later as an art historian, Rizvi has multiple areas of expertise and is able to put into use both architectural and art historical modes of decorative, epigraphic, formal, stylistic, spatial, and urban analysis in her work. She supplements this expertise further with first-person observations and interviews with the producers of the projects to understand their intentions. The chapters are introduced with a map and a two-page first-person narrative account that carries the reader into the context and building to be discussed. Approximating a journalistic mode—and differentiated with italicization from the rest of the chapters which have a more traditional, somber academic tone and style—these vignettes are exceptionally helpful in (re)focusing the attention of the reader to the context in discussion.
Since reviews are meant to be projections into future scholarship, I would like to briefly suggest two avenues of further study prompted by this work. First, while mentioned once or twice in passing, mahya (the Ottoman art of writing in the sky) and adhan (the call to prayer) suggest mosques can also be interpreted as “media buildings.” Especially through adhan, mosques have spatial presence in the communities in which they are located. An emphasis on the mosque as media building could build on the documentary interpretation of epigraphs that so enrich this study. Secondly, the exclusive focus on large-scale mosques and transnational flows can be supplanted with dialogues of how they interact with small-scale, community-driven mosques and prayer spaces, and thus contemporary and historic pluralist interpretations of Islam. For example, when Diyanet (Turkey's Department of Religious Affairs) builds a Sunni mosque in the heart of an Alevi community and blasts annoyingly loud pre-recorded adhan and refuses to fund Alevi religious buildings (Cemevi), categorizing them instead as “cultural centers,”Footnote 2 state-sponsored mosques become not merely “conduits of political and religious ideology” (17) but also weapons.
