“Square dance” is known to most Americans as an arrangement of four couples into squares where the dancers execute figures of varying complexity (allemande left, do-si-do, weave the ring, etc.) under the direction of a caller and to the accompaniment of old-timey music. It is danced throughout the United States; it can be seen in movies (especially cartoons) and occasionally on TV; kids learn it in elementary school. Nineteen states have designated square dance as their state's “official” dance; and bills have been introduced repeatedly but unsuccessfully in Congress to designate square dance as “America's National Dance.” Square dance is widely imagined to be the survival of the dance traditions that English immigrants brought to the United States in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, preserved in isolated regions, especially in the Appalachian Mountains, and spreading to the rest of the United States in the early twentieth century.
In this excellent book, Phil Jamison partly debunks, partly revises, and greatly enriches these familiar ideas and images, replacing them with an abundance of historical detail, highlighted by discussions of dance in its social contexts and wider cultural issues. He shows that square dance is not a European vestige but a new American creation that emerged in the first half of the nineteenth century and evolved considerably in the twentieth. The book is not just about square dancing but also about the history of dance more generally in the southern Appalachian region, from West Virginia to Georgia. As well as dances in four-couple squares, Jamison covers couples’ dances (waltz, two-step), dances where the couples face each other in lines (“contra” dances, reels), and step dances (jigs, breakdowns, clogging).
Jamison writes with the background of over thirty years of experience as a dancer, dance researcher, instrumentalist, caller, and promoter of dance conferences, festivals and other events. He is one of the guiding lights of the “traditional” square dance movement, which seeks to preserve and promote square dance traditions in the rural United States. Despite his personal commitment to the preservation of “traditional” dance, however, Jamison maintains a dispassionate perspective, granting validity to all the branches of Appalachian dance and acknowledging that he and his colleagues are creating new traditions just as much as they are preserving and reviving old ones.
The organization of the book is semi-chronological, beginning in the eighteenth century and ending near the present. Along the way, Jamison takes many short detours to follow one particular dance form across several decades or to examine the influence of a particular person or organization on the history of American dance. The narrative brims with interesting insights and little-known facts. For example, in the Appalachian region, “square dances” often begin in a large circle, then break down into two-couple mini-squares that form and re-form in a “visiting couple” pattern. In another passage, Jamison presents convincing evidence to show that dance “calling” is a distinctively American phenomenon. Nothing like calling is documented in eighteenth- or nineteenth-century Europe, and European visitors who attended dances in the early nineteenth century reacted with astonishment at Americans who hadn't learned the figures of the dance and had to be told what to do. A more modest insight concerns the “pigeon wing,” an athletic step dance move in which the dancer leaps in the air and taps his heels to one side. The “pigeon wing” is often said to have been learned by minstrel stage performers from African Americans, but according to Jamison, it was actually a French dance step, introduced to the United States by the (white) stage dancer John Durang.
Jamison supports and fleshes out his narrative with a plethora of documentation: diaries, letters and personal accounts from the eighteenth and especially the nineteenth century; accounts by European visitors and by northerners who traveled to southern Appalachia; newspaper and magazine stories; dance manuals, American and European. He uses recordings from the 1920s and ’30s to document the calls and the choreography of dances in various regions. Finally, Jamison himself conducted many oral history interviews between 1989 and 2012 with callers and dancers, most of them advanced in age, who testified to the culture of square dancing not just in their youth but in the twenty-first century as well.
Jamison steps outside of chronology to consider several issues in depth. In a chapter on the “Virginia Reel,” he explains that six-handed reels were popular in colonial times: three couples in facing lines alternating footwork in place with couples figures. The Virginia Reel, however, with long facing lines and elaborate figures that move couples from the top of the line to the bottom, was an adaptation of an English contra dance called “Sir Roger De Coverley,” introduced to the United States in the 1820s. Renamed “Virginia Reel,” it was a popular ballroom dance until after the Civil War. The Virginia Reel was hardly known in the southern mountains until it was introduced during the 1920s and 30s into school curricula, misleadingly billed as a surviving “colonial era” dance.
Jamison devotes two chapters to the visit in 1916–18 of the English folklorist Cecil Sharp to the southern mountains and the legacy that Sharp left. Parallel to modern critics of Sharp's song collecting endeavors, Jamison says that Sharp saw what he wanted to see in Appalachia—survivals of pre-industrial English “folk” dances: “The dances that Cecil Sharp called the ‘Running Set’ were not, as he believed, an ancient, unadulterated form of English country dance but represented a more recent American hybrid that developed from diverse roots in the American South during the nineteenth century” (74). Jamison blames Sharp and his followers for many of the modern myths about Appalachian dance. At the same time, he gives Sharp credit as an important witness to the performance practices of the early twentieth century.
The book's penultimate chapter, “Community Dance in Appalachia,” documents present-day dance events in three rural communities: one in North Carolina, another in Kentucky, and a third in West Virginia. In two of the communities, these are once-a-year festivals, in the third a monthly event, and Jamison seems to have attended each of them several times as a participant-observer. In all three communities he finds calls, figures, and dance styles very similar to written descriptions and historical recordings from the first half of the twentieth century. The dances attract nearby residents—some young, more old—as well as visiting dancers who come in search of a “traditional” square dance experience. All three of these community dances were still ongoing as of 2016, but their future is uncertain. As Jamison writes about the Community Dance Center in Carcassonne, KY: “Most of the older dancers who began it have now passed away. Those who remain can no longer dance, and, sadly, few of the next generation, now middle-aged, appear to have any interest in traditional square dancing” (173). Taking the place of “community dances,” Jamison says, are new “dance communities,” enthusiasts who share a passion for traditional American dances and find one another across widely separated geographical regions.
Many things are missing from the story that Jamison tells. There is little about singing or instrumental music. Jamison occasionally specifies the instruments that accompanied square dancing, and he often names the tunes they played: “Old Joe Clark,” “Sally Goodin,” “Whip the Devil round the stump,” etc. But he offers little about musical performance practices or about the relation between the music and the dance. The book teems with the names of square dance figures and calls—“Bird in the cage,” “Georgia rang-tang,” “Peek-a-boo over, Peek-a-boo back,” “Duck for the oyster”—but if you don't already know how to do the “Georgia rang-tang,” you won't find out here. These omissions are noticeable and occasionally disorienting, but they are probably for the best. Jamison's scope is already broad, and the book contains more than enough detail for most readers. Those who want to know more are referred to Jamison's excellent bibliography and to internet sources, especially www.squaredancehistory.com, where Jamison is a frequent contributor and where the reader can see him at work as a caller.
Three generalizations and overarching themes tie this book together. The first is that square dance does not represent the preservation of an English or Anglo-Irish tradition. It was a new and distinctively American synthesis, with elements drawn from a variety of traditions: French and English ballroom dance; English, Scottish, and Irish village dances; African American ring dances, early nineteenth-century stage dancing, and more. This conclusion refutes the ideology promoted by Cecil Sharp, Henry Ford, and others that southern Appalachian dance embodied the nation's presumed Anglo-Saxon heritage, before it was contaminated by immigration in the nineteenth century. Square dance was born in the nineteenth century, a child of this immigration and cultural exchange.
Jamison's second theme is that African Americans were a constant presence and important influence in the history of square dance. He presents copious documentation from the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries of African American fiddlers, slave and free, playing for whites to dance on plantations, in communities along rivers and canals, and in mountain resorts. Many of the early descriptions of dance calling specifically mention black callers, and Jamison hypothesizes (without much evidence) that this distinctively American practice may well have been adapted from African traditions. By the early nineteenth century, African Americans had adopted many of the dances of their white neighbors—quadrilles, reels, and jigs—and began transforming them into new styles like the cakewalk and tap dance. Jamison criticizes the twentieth-century square dance revival for making African Americans “invisible” both through its ideology of preserved tradition and by ignoring and excluding black instrumentalists and dancers from the culture that it created.
A third theme echoes through the last half of Jamison's book: attempts to preserve and/or revive square dance traditions have had paradoxical effects. They select certain elements from the tradition and turn them into performance genres or codify them as instructional norms. This twentieth-century revival can be called a success insofar as it disseminated square dance throughout the United States with choreography enriched by calls and figures from different regions. At the same time, the tradition became much less diverse, and in its heartland of the southern Appalachians, square dancing became less and less of a popular, community-based tradition. At the Mountain Dance and Folk Festival in Asheville, North Carolina, beginning in the 1930s, Bascom Lamar Lunsford presided over square dance competitions that encouraged dance “teams” to create ever faster, ever more polished choreography. The festival was discontinued in 1987, but its legacy survives in the performance-oriented clogging tradition. Similarly, “Modern Western Square Dance,” which began in the 1930s as an attempt to revive the dance styles of Colorado cowboys, spread across the country after World War II and even overseas as a club-based recreational activity. Calls and choreography became so complex that, in the 1970s, a national organization named “Callerlab” was established to regulate what had become a thriving but chaotic scene. Callerlab experts met and still meet periodically to decide what is and what isn't a legitimate square dance call. Another revival is the “Dare to be Square” movement, in which Jamison himself has played an important part and which aims to revive “traditional” square dancing as documented in this book. It has resurrected and popularized forgotten calls (“Duck for the oyster”), old formations (“visiting couples”), and foot-stomping fiddle tunes. Although “Dare to be Square” has a significant presence in Appalachia, the centers of “traditional” square dance activity tend to be urban centers like Boston, Seattle, and Los Angeles. These revival movements, Jamison insists, have not destroyed tradition; they themselves are living traditions. They have moved square dancing away from its original context in the southern mountains and have created new traditions for new audiences and new participants throughout the United States.
