Leta Miller's Music and Politics in San Francisco: From the 1906 Quake to the Second World War weaves an intricate tale of musical art in its social context to offer an elegant example of the potential of archival research, urban history, and musical analysis to mediate ideas, relationships, and power. Although Miller builds upon a growing vein of musicological research concerning music and place, her book takes unusual advantage of music's range of engagement with social issues to address topics such as race, gender, class, labor, immigration, institution building, and public policy. Musical arenas discussed cover a astute range of traditions: ballet, choral music, concert band and orchestral music, Chinese music, African American spirituals, jazz and club music, musical theater, opera, organ recitals, and the cross-cultural experiments of the ultramoderns. By inviting music into her study as circumscribed by time and place, rather than by style or genre, Miller presents a colorful tapestry of social relations mediated by the civic soundscape.
The book is organized chronologically in nine chapters divided into two parts: part 1 covers “From the Quake to the Crash,” and part 2 addresses “The Depression and Beyond.” An introduction and epilogue frame the text, while two “Interludes” offer detailed discussions of signal musical works that amplify themes of idealism, diversity, influence, and tolerance identified by Miller's narrative. The first interlude examines Chinatown's musical influence, and the second features compositions from the 1930s Federal Music Project. The eighty-six pages of back matter include a bibliography that not only recognizes the book's secondary sources, but also serves as a research guide to the region's newspapers and archives. The detailed index makes the book a useful reference tool, especially given that a large number of prominent musicians had careers that moved through San Francisco, including Marian Anderson, Amy Beach, Ernest Bloch, Nadia Boulanger, John Cage, Enrico Caruso, Henry Cowell, Henry Hadley, Lou Harrison, Alfred Hertz, William Keeton, Walter Loving, Yehudi Menuhin, Arnold Schoenberg, John Philip Sousa, Luisa Tetrazzini, and Paul Whiteman. Although a few notables receive limited mention—for example, San Francisco's other violin virtuosos, Ruggiero Ricci and Isaac Stern—nevertheless the author's overall portrait offers a view of surprising national scope.
In 277 pages of prose Miller avoids specific (and potentially limiting) definitions of “music” or “politics,” preferring to illuminate her study's implications for a cultural civic discourse through specific instances. Examples range from suspiciously utopian claims by patrons and educators about music's capacity to benefit community to the 1901 election of musicians’ union president Eugene Schmitz as San Francisco's mayor. Elitism and public access emerge as consistent themes. Beginning in 1910, citizens questioned the construction of a municipal opera house for more than two decades. Debate over whether opera functioned as adornment for the wealthy or as a moral right for wageworkers served as a lightning rod for class tension. In 1932 the city's War Memorial Opera House finally opened, but only after subterfuge concealed the project within a monument honoring World War I veterans. Nevertheless, the role of municipal government in supporting culture was consistently affirmed by San Franciscans. A unique Depression-era ballot measure authorized a half-percent property tax that preserved the San Francisco Symphony, and this cultural tax quietly continues to support the arts in the city today. (In 1961 an additional three percent hotel tax would fund a Grants for the Arts program, but this topic lies outside the chronological bounds of Miller's study.)
Informed by an extensive body of her previously published research on the city's music, Miller's text remains accessible to the general reader.Footnote 1 Her prose is animated by anecdote and intrigue reminiscent of a Victorian novel. She surveys an enormous cast of engaging protagonists whose fervor, idealism, and prejudices motivate the interplay of combative factionalism and utopian idealism that drives the narrative forward. The author offers rich characterizations of figures such as Bloch, Cowell, Harrison, and Hertz, as well as Ada Clement (1878–1952), founder of the San Francisco Conservatory. Certainly her study leaves some music unexamined—for example, the city's religious music, the sounds of Mexican-American and Spanish culture, and even classical chamber music (e.g., the San Francisco String Quartet) largely escape note—but these gaps stem from the author's decision to focus on cultural discourse in the public sphere, especially as represented in its mainstream, English-language press. Fairs and festivals thus receive particular emphasis, with the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition and the 1939–40 Golden Gate International Exposition highlighting shifts in San Francisco's musical culture over the course of the study.
Miller's chronology opens with a seemingly obligatory introductory tale—common to most books on San Francisco—of the city's April 1906 earthquake. The dystopian story is leavened with humorous images of a frantic tenor, Enrico Caruso, “running about in the scantiest of attire” and insisting that all were “doomed” while locals seemed “unperturbed” (16); of course, Caruso's fears would soon be justified as fire followed quake to complete the city's devastation. Chapter 2 presents a detailed examination of the founding of a professional orchestra for the city and opens debate about music and class interest—especially regarding the creation of a People's Philharmonic. Here the tension between artistic excellence and money becomes apparent, specifically in the desire of some cultural philanthropists for control. Founded in 1911, with the pioneering and unfortunately forgotten American composer Henry Hadley (1871–1937) at its helm, the San Francisco Symphony changed direction in 1915 when the board of directors instead hired German-born conductor Alfred Hertz (1872–1942) and his Dionysian baton technique to direct the orchestra. The resulting controversy precipitated the resignation of board members and sparked negative press coverage tied to World War I anti-German sentiment. Unlike Boston Symphony conductor Karl Muck, Hertz navigated the political maelstrom to bring the ensemble to a new level of artistic accomplishment and national respect.
By engaging issues of labor, race, and ethnicity, Miller goes well beyond the chronicling of highbrow institutions that often limit musicological studies of American cities. Called the “Gate to the Orient” during the period of this study, San Francisco housed thousands of Chinese immigrants, who arrived initially looking to the Gold Rush for riches. Despite racial prejudice and increasingly harsh immigration laws, the city's Chinese population created a vibrant musical life in its iconic Chinatown (chapter 3). Up to six competing Cantonese opera houses brought exceptional artists to the United States. Examples include Jue Quon Tai and Tam Wai Jon, two women who represented a new trend of Chinese “prima donna” in the 1920s, and the progressive actor Ma Shizeng, who embraced Western influence in the early 1930s. Although they sold a troubling exoticism to white tourists, San Francisco's Cantonese theaters supported a vibrant immigrant community and introduced their culture to a few open-minded Western musicians. In 1896, piano virtuoso Ignacy Paderewski eagerly embraced Cantonese opera and publicly endorsed Chinese music as art. The city's composers were also exposed to China's musical influence. Bloch, who led the San Francisco Conservatory from 1925 to 1930, translated his experience of Chinatown's soundscape into the fourth movement of his 1926 suite for chamber orchestra—Four Episodes. Although racial discrimination frequently punished its Asian inhabitants, San Francisco served as an important U.S. entry point for people and ideas from the Pacific Rim. Asian musics, as Miller describes, were typically discounted as “primitive,” but were also sometimes legitimized and humanized. The Golden Gate Exposition, for example, featured a triumphal eighty-foot statue of Pacifica, symbolizing the positive embrace of rim cultures.
Miller's candid exposure of discrimination against the city's African American musicians (chapter 7) similarly cuts across the celebratory grain of many publications focusing on the legacy of the city's cultural institutions. In 1897 San Francisco's professional musicians affiliated with the American Federation of Musicians (AFM), to form Local 6 and become some of the first to join this ultimately dominant arts labor union. AFM protections of fair wages and working standards, however, were not typically extended to African Americans. Reflecting a bias that characterized the union as a whole, Local 6 discouraged black membership. Miller explains that union auditions required reading sheet music and that even highly skilled jazz musicians often did not possess the requisite classical training to qualify (94). Further, San Francisco's white union leadership resisted the creation of a black musicians union. Local 648 was not formed until 1923, and then only as a separate but far from equal “colored” affiliate. Union wages for black musicians were more than forty percent lower than for whites, and, as competition for performance jobs increased during the Depression, Local 6 moved to exclude black musicians. Remarkably, Local 648 sued Local 6 in Superior Court, making national news; it later dropped the suit, although it was still punished by the national union. Pay and conditions for black musicians nevertheless improved. Maybe unsurprisingly, neither union seems to have considered representing the city's Asian musicians.
A pioneering study, Miller's work would nonetheless benefit from additional economic detail (the impact of Gold Rush and later railroad wealth, for example) and a wider frame of analysis that places San Francisco's cultural developments in the context of musical life in other cities. Such comparison would explore music's role in the competition among urban centers not just for cultural prestige but also for associated economic development. The claims of early twentieth-century boosters that San Francisco was the “Paris of the West” (chapter 1), for example, did more than simply praise artistic accomplishment; they positioned the city favorably against East Coast competitors, such as Boston, New York, and Philadelphia. In this regard, an exploration of how news reports, radio, and especially recordings shaped San Francisco's artistic reputation would be telling. Further bibliographic resources from the field of urban studies would also support Miller's most ambitious conclusions about the social impact of San Francisco's cultural practice. Richard Florida's finding in The Rise of the Creative Class that cultural tolerance is an indicator of economic success supports Miller's own observation that cycles of factionalism counterbalanced by idealism nurtured tolerance as a civic value in San Francisco.Footnote 2 Whereas the author might be accused of falling prey to the utopianism of her most sympathetic subjects, such as when she cites the eclecticism of Cowell and Harrison as symbolic of the “victory of the utopian over the divisive” (276–77), Miller ultimately resists a more encompassing claim connecting this tolerance to a broad “West Coast” aesthetic, while still suggesting that cultural affirmation of social diversity anticipates “one of the essential ingredients of musical postmodernism” (277).
Music and Politics in San Francisco offers a compelling model for music scholars exploring urban cultural dynamics as well as for those looking for strategies to incorporate detailed discussions of music in historical narrative. More generally, Miller's work showcases the power of spatial criteria in cultural analysis. By circumscribing her topic using geographic boundaries of place, rather than by genre or style, Miller invites analytical insight. Her study is especially engaging when examining interactions of musics normally insulated within spheres of scholarly specialization: symphony, opera, jazz, and Cantonese opera interact not only within the civic soundscape but also in institutions such as the American Federation of Musicians and economic practices such as tourism. In a field where reading lists, journals, and even conference sessions have become increasingly sequestered and homogenized, Miller's work offers a reminder that diversity and eclecticism may also be a virtue of scholarship.
