No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
This book represents an attempt to bring historical evidence to bear on issues that maintain contemporary importance in the areas of public health and public policy. Contributors use new historical data sets to explore the factors affecting mortality and health outcomes across populations and labor-supply decisions of the aged.
Most of the papers make use of the Life-Cycle Data on the Aging of Veterans of the Union Army collected under the project title “Early Indicators of Later Work Levels, Disease and Death.” The sample consists of longitudinally linked observations for 39,616 white males in the Union Army. The data set was created by linking information from military records, pension records, surgeons' reports, and population censuses. It includes a wealth of information that provides a picture of the life history of each veteran. In the first chapter, Larry Wimmer provides an account of the collaborative effort that was required to create this data set.
There appear to be three central themes that connect the articles in this volume. The first is the effect of socioeconomic status on mortality and health. Joseph Ferrie uses a sample of 175,000 individuals from the 1850 and 1860 censuses to examine the relationship between wealth and mortality. Previous studies had found little relationship between wealth and mortality in historical data. Ferrie, on the other hand, finds evidence of disparities in mortality by socioeconomic status in 1860 (p. 31). In an investigation of the effects of socioeconomic status on health outcomes, Clayne Pope and Sven Wilson consider community- and family-level influences that affect adult heights. They find that farmers enjoy a distinct height advantage over other occupations in both urban and rural communities (p. 132). This finding is explained by both better nutrition and reduced exposure to infectious disease for farmers in rural areas.
The second central theme in the book is the effect on mortality of infectious diseases and migration, both important features of nineteenth-century life in America. In a pair of papers, Chulhee Lee and Daniel Scott Smith examine the question “Why did so many Union Army soldiers die of disease during the Civil War?” (p. 110). Whereas Lee focuses on prior exposure to infectious diseases, Smith considers the environment to which soldiers were exposed during the war. Lee finds that prior exposure to infectious diseases reduced the chances of dying from disease (p. 69). This appears to be due to increased resistance. Smith finds that although prior exposure was important, its effects became less important over time. After the first year of service, the environment experienced during the war became a more important predictor of death from infectious disease (pp. 107–08).
Mario Sanchez examines the characteristics of migration patterns in the nineteenth century and the effect of migration decisions on later mortality of migrants. He finds return migration was a common feature of nineteenth-century migration patterns (p. 219). Migration was also found to reduce life expectancies, a finding that is explained by the increased probability of dying from infectious diseases (p. 220).
The third theme connecting the papers in this volume concerns the labor-supply and retirement decisions of Union Army veterans. Tayatat Kanjanapipatkul finds that the receipt of pensions reduced labor-force participation among Union Army Veterans (p. 246). In addition, the elasticity of retirement with respect to pension income varies across occupations (p. 249). Chen Song and Louis Nguyen examine the labor-supply implications of poor health for Union Army veterans. Specifically, they examine the case of hernias. They find that retirement decisions for Union Army veterans were not influenced by the existence of hernias.
As the papers in this book depend largely on the Life-Cycle Data on the Aging of Veterans of the Union Army, its focus may at first appear somewhat narrow. Yet a particularly appealing feature of the book is that it carries implications for broader issues in American economic history. For example, the evidence relating to the costs of migration may help to explain the existence of large urban wage premiums in the nineteenth century. Likewise, the evidence on the factors affecting adult heights of Union Army veterans may shed light on the larger issue of declining heights in mid-nineteenth-century America. Despite these advantages, it is also true that the Union Army data are confined to a sample of white males from the North. It is unfortunate that this wonderful data set cannot be used to examine the experiences of women, children, Southerners, or African Americans.
Overall, the book provides a detailed analysis of the factors affecting health, mortality, and labor-force participation in nineteenth-century America. As such, it will be of interest to economic historians, labor economists, and historians. One point that emerges clearly is the importance of infectious diseases for health outcomes and subsequent mortality in nineteenth-century America. From this standpoint, there may be implications for developing economies in which infectious diseases remain prevalent. This book may therefore be of special interest to those in the field of public health. Finally, the attention devoted to migration means that this book should also hold the interest of those interested in demography.