Nearly a quarter of a century after his Media and Democracy (1991), John Keane decided to revisit the eternal theme of the relationship between politics and (mass) communication. Whether the new book is a sequel to the first one, its adaptation to the rapidly changing global context, or even its revaluation is difficult to say. Since the author only incidentally refers to it, he obviously does not see his new book directly related to the previous one.
Nevertheless, there are some important continuities but also striking contrasts. In his 1991 work, Keane was preoccupied with the consequences of market competition, media deregulation, and state interference for freedom of communication, and he vigorously defended the public-service model of the media. Whereas the “public service” concept was central to Keane in 1991, it is hardly mentioned in 2013. The central topics and concepts of the new book are “communicative abundance” and “(monitory) democracy,” which are thought of as “conjoined twins” (p. 18); the defense of public-service media is turned off and replaced with a plea for citizens’ “freedom of public communication” against forces of political power and capital.
Both books underscore and prove the importance of the historical dimension to be reflected on when studying social, political, and communication phenomena: The novelty of the present cannot be truly understood if we are ignorant of the past. In Democracy and Media Decadence, Keane (p. 21) emphasizes the importance of “wild thinking”—the need to use “bold new probes, fresh-minded perspectives, ‘wild’ concepts’ that enable different and meaningful ways of seeing things”—but also “the need for suspicion of neologisms that have a false-start quality about them” (such as the term cyberspace). I am certainly very much in agreement with Keane’s epistemology of historically embedded “wild” new perspectives, including his argument for the need to bridge disciplinary divisions between political science and communications and other scholarly fields, if we want to (and we need to) analyze media and democracy in their interconnectedness.
The 2013 version of the media and democracy discussion is specifically focused on two—according to Keane, most significant—social-political phenomena: communicative abundance and monitory democracy. “Communicative abundance” is a common denominator for five pivotal technologically driven social trends observable in the beginning of the twenty-first century: 1) the democratization of information stirring up public controversies; 2) the new publicity, which makes clear distinctions between “the private” and “the public” obsolete; 3) the new muckraking, particularly sensitive to the power of elites thriving on secrecy, silence, and invisibility; 4) the growth of “unelected representatives,” consisting of “champions of public causes and values, public figures whose authority and power base are located outside the boundaries of electoral politics; and 5) the emergence of cross-border publics “whose footprints are potentially or actually global in scope.”
These trends are pivotal also because they “are together having real effects on the spirit and institutional dynamics of democracy” (p. 77). Monitory democracy is Keane’s case in point to prove that we should “stop thinking in terms of the dead concepts and worn-out formulae of our predecessors” (p. 77). The second chapter of the book summarizes the idea of monitory democracy—“the most exact term for describing the big transformation that is taking hold in many regions of the world”—developed in his book The Life and Death of Democracy (2009). The most remarkable feature of monitory democracy is, according to Keane, “the marriage of democracy and human rights, and the subsequent worldwide growth of organizations, networks and campaigns committed to the defence of human rights” (p. 101). The combined effect of media abundance is “to encourage people’s suspicions of unaccountable power. … [T]he unmasking of power resonates strongly with the power-scrutinizing spirit of monitory democracy” (p. 103).
Yet “democracy does not feed automatically upon the untrammeled growth of communicative abundance” (p. 112). Despite “media abundance,” the democratic potential of the (digital) media and public life in general is threatened by “media decadence.” “The techniques and tools of media-saturated societies are being used by powerful forces in ways that are having harmful effects on democracy” (p. 112). To understand this process, the historical perspective becomes very important, and Keane offers ample examples of contradictory developments in the past and present—cases of “dirty business of promoting intolerance of opinions, stifling the public scrutiny of power and fostering the blind acceptance of the way things are heading” (p. 119)—from “mechanical solipsism,” advertising focused on young people and hacking to gated communities, and the power of media businesses in shaping citizens’ way of life.
In addition, there are also organized political and commercial forces of “democracy’s opponents.” Keane is particularly concerned with “mediacracy”—a closed system of “consociations among politicians, journalists, public relations specialists and lobbyists” (p. 191), specifically exhibited with the case of the People's Republic of China.
The concluding chapter of the new book is a plea for “freedom of public communication,” which Keane conceives of as “a way of enabling citizens and whole organisations and networks to sound the alarm whenever they suspect that others are causing them harm, or that calamities are bearing down on their heads, in silence” (p. 241). We find here familiar names from the past (including Milton, Hume, Bentham and Mill—but many others are missing) and more recent times (Bobbio) arguing for freedom of expression (communication) as “the most effective means of preventing dangerous accumulations of power, in the form of large-scale and high-risk business and government experiments in re-ordering the lives of citizens and their environment, sometimes with catastrophic consequences” (p. 223). Unfortunately, Keane fails to tell us what conceptual differences exist between the “old” concepts of the “right to communicate” and “right of access” (to which he does not refer) and his “wild” concept of “freedom of public communication.”
The story told by Keane is not a new one, but it establishes an overarching perspective in the understanding of media and democracy embedded in the historical context (with abundant references, sometimes even to the point of distraction) and of wild thinking. I am quite comfortable with Keane’s critical observations related both to empirical trends of communicative abundance and to global changes in democratic processes. Yet his theoretization of these changes falls short of my expectations. When reading his book, the reader gets the impression that democracy’s opponents, mediacracy, and media decadence have nothing to do with the global capitalist order, as if market economy, globalization of markets and changes in global governance were “somehow” related to technological changes and mediated by society, but not related to the capitalist mode of production. I am (still) not persuaded by his idea of monitory democracy, and I continue to believe that old concepts are still applicable and that all the talk about the necessity of a “radical rethinking of democracy” is misleading, as long as it is limited to the citizens’ surveillance of power only (which used to be the task of the publics and public opinion in old theories) and not concerned with the execution of power and decision-making process. Nevertheless, Democracy and Media Decadence is most welcome in sounding the public alarm about the ways in which governments and corporate power (can) misuse digital media everywhere and on a global scale in order to pursue their own private interests against the interests of the people.
