This collaboration by Richard Eaton and Phillip Wagoner is the most important publication on Deccan history in well over a decade. It is a model of scholarship in its empirical rigour and richness, in its innovative methodology, and in the wide-ranging scope of its inquiry. I am not alone in giving it high praise – Power, Memory, and Architecture has received book awards from both the Association for Asian Studies and the American Historical Association, in a rare display of scholarly consensus.
Perhaps the most striking departure Eaton and Wagoner make from previous scholarship on the Deccan is in their focus on secondary centres, especially fortified sites that were situated on frontiers between states. The book provides a wealth of new details on these secondary sites, which scholars have largely overlooked in favour of capital cities like Vijayanagara and Bijapur. But even more consequential is the shift in vantage point away from imperial centres to the secondary nodes of power that dominated rural localities. As Eaton and Wagoner state in their introduction, “in a very real sense, the political history of the Deccan revolved around struggles by primary centres for control of secondary centres” (p. xxii). Secondary centres were not only desirable for their material resources, but sometimes also for their symbolic resonances.
Much of the book is devoted to three “contested sites”: 1) Kalyana, situated at the frontier between the Bijapur, Ahmadnagar, and Bidar sultanates; 2) Warangal, in the border zone of the territories controlled by the Bahmani sultanate and by Telugu chiefs; and 3) Raichur, which lay close to the border between the Vijayanagara kingdom and the Bahmani (and subsequently Bijapur) sultanate. The sixteenth-century history of each of these cities and its architectural heritage is covered in a separate section, along with the impact of their architectural styles on activities elsewhere. Preceding them is a section that provides background on the political and cultural history of the Deccan, beginning with the Chalukya empire of the eleventh and twelfth centuries, and continuing with the intrusion of the Delhi Sultanate in the fourteenth century and the subsequent formation of the Bahmani Sultanate. A chapter on the range of ways that Sultans and their generals dealt with the Hindu temples encountered during their conquests ends this introductory section.
The sections on both Kalyana and Warangal illustrate one of the most exciting and original aspects of this work: its attention to how historical memories are manifested in architecture and cityscapes. The architectural styles characteristic of these two sites when they were capital cities – of the western Deccan's Chalukya empire in the case of Kalyana and of the eastern Deccan's Kakatiya kingdom in Warangal's case – continued to possess a symbolic power that later rulers sought to harness for their own purposes. Seeking both the imperial luster and local affiliation that Chalukya monuments signified, Adil Shahi sultans incorporated Chalukya inscriptions or architectural components or even small structures into their own buildings. The Aravidu rulers of Vijayanagara went so far as to dismantle an entire stepwell from the Chalukya period and transport it to their own capital city, in but one example of their re-use of Chalukyan material. Similarly, in the eastern Deccan, the former kingdom of the Kakatiyas continued to be invoked in sixteenth-century building activities. At Warangal itself, a Telugu warlord called Shitab Khan revived the worship of the Kakatiya's tutelary deity and recycled Kakatiya period components in building a new temple. Rather than temple styles, it was the built cityscape of Kakatiya Warangal that inspired the planning of Hyderabad, the new capital of the Qutb Shahis in 1591.
The last section on Raichur centres on the theme of ‘power’, with which the book's title begins, rather than on memory. Successive conquerors of this border town made modifications to its gateways in order to leave visible marks of their sovereignty. Raichur was the site of an important battle won by Vijayanagara in 1521, which made them complacent about the need to upgrade their weapons and fortifications to keep up with their rivals. The wide gap in military technology that resulted explains why Vijayanagara was so thoroughly defeated in 1565, leading to the empire's collapse.
The new observations and interpretations advanced by Eaton and Wagoner rest on the extensive research they conducted in a variety of source materials, as partially detailed in the appendices. For example, we are presented with eight maps showing the territorial extent of the various kingdoms of the Deccan at 10 year intervals from 1510 to 1580, created by the authors after identifying 96 sites mentioned by the chronicler Ferishtah and locating them using GIS software. These maps are the basis for the authors’ assertion that control over secondary centres was frequently contested: Warangal changed hands twice in the sixteenth century, Kalyana three times, and Raichur four times. The fieldwork carried out by Eaton and Wagoner is especially impressive – they visited a total of 48 sites in the Deccan. They examined not only the monuments and fortifications, but also artifacts like cannons, of which they noted 107 specimens. Close scrutiny of the cannons and their placement on fort bastions is what led Eaton and Wagoner to the realisation that the military technology of Bijapur, in particular, had become far superior to that of Vijayanagara by the mid-sixteenth century.
Numerous other examples of the empirical richness of this book could be cited, with its 160 figures and tables. The sheer materiality of this project stands in marked contrast to the emphasis on literary studies in South Asian Studies of late, much of which revisits well-known texts. This is not to say that literature, chronicles, and inscriptions are overlooked by Eaton and Wagoner, whether in Persian, Sanskrit, Telugu or Dakhani. Power, Memory, and Architecture sets a very high standard for breadth, depth, and comprehensiveness that will be difficult for future scholars to meet, even working collaboratively.
