This volume offers a refreshing new approach to the study of anthropology's broad topical history, presenting issues in the science's development seldom examined in the historiography. The first of five thematically focused parts surveys ‘Major traditions’. Especially for those new to the field, the chapters here are extremely useful. Regna Darnell, editor Henrika Kuklick, H. Glenn Penny and Emmanuelle Sibeud give comprehensive and concise overviews of the main developments and figures within, respectively, the North American, British, German and French anthropological traditions. What is more, each of these chapters considers often overlooked aspects of the relevant heritages. Darnell reminds us, for instance, of the role of Canadian scholars in the intellectual and institutional expansion of North American anthropological research.
Part Two, on ‘Early obsessions’, introduces some of the topics characteristic of anthropology in the nineteenth century. (A chapter by Harry Liebersohn at the beginning of the volume covers pre-nineteenth-century developments.) Ivan Strenski discusses anthropology and religion, Barbara Saunders looks at empiricism and race, and Robert Ackerman examines anthropology and the Classics. All three chapters manage to make complicated issues understandable and interesting. For example, Strenski brings the significance of religion in anthropological research up to date by relating anthropology in the Victorian period to the larger science-and-religion debates of the nineteenth century. In doing so, he discusses central figures within the anthropology of religion such as Edward Burnett Tylor and James Frazer, providing concise accounts of key theories. Anyone teaching students about religion as a historical focus in anthropological research will find Strenski's chapter a real ally.
In Part Three the volume shifts frame to consider ‘Neglected pasts’, specifically traditions in anthropology beyond the USA, Britain, Germany and France. Christer Lindberg examines anthropology in Scandinavia, Donna Mehos explores Dutch ethnographic museums, Nikolai Ssorin-Chaikov discusses early ethnographic fieldwork in late nineteenth-century Russia and Hilary Smith looks at Chinese archaeology. Particularly fascinating is Smith's chapter, ‘Using the past to serve the peasant’, which examines the use by Chinese scholars and government officials of archaeological sites in order to demonstrate communism as the apex of social development, while at the same time reinforcing Chinese cultural exceptionalism.
Historically, the relationship between cultural and biological anthropology has been tense. Both sides have traditionally made claims against the legitimacy of the other's evidentiary sources. Given the complexity of these debates, the challenge of introducing them to students is considerable; meeting that challenge is the burden of Part Four, ‘Biology’. Thomas Glick's ‘The anthropology of race across the Darwinian revolution’ and Jonathan Marks's ‘Race across the physical–cultural divide in American anthropology’ give solid foundations, while Robert Proctor's chapter on ‘Temporality as artifact in paleoanthropology’ adds interesting new insights into the history of biological anthropology specifically.
The volume's final section, ‘New directions and perspectives’, emphasizes the future of anthropology and potential new approaches to studying its past. Lyn Schumaker describes the role of women researchers in anthropology, Anna Grimshaw discusses visual anthropology, Rena Lederman looks at regionalism in anthropology and Merrill Singer explores applied anthropology. Of particular interest is Schumaker's comprehensive analysis of the integral contributions of women in the field as both researchers and assistants. Her chapter brings out an interesting new dimension to the history of anthropology by reminding readers that anthropology was an important avenue for women scholars in pursuit of academic careers. Indeed, certain cultural practices had social barriers that male researchers were unable to cross; in these cases, women's participation enlarged the scope of field research.
Overall, the history-of-science and the anthropological communities should applaud Kuklick for a superb job in putting together a book that will no doubt shape future generation's understanding of the rich history of the discipline. A New History of Anthropology does for more than introduce an array of central theories, concepts and figures in a stimulating and accessible way. It confirms a bright future for the history of anthropology, where a number of areas wait to be developed.
