The decade since 2000 has seen a questioning, across Western Europe, of the policy approach to communities whose origins lie in immigration. The Netherlands has been central to this debate, as it is probably the country whose public policy has travelled furthest from its previous default position of tolerance of diversity. In the legal sphere, the principal result has been that it has had a pioneering role in the introduction of language and civic knowledge tests for naturalisation, permanent residence and admission to the territory.
Against that background, Sarah van Walsum's monograph, The Family and the Nation, is particularly welcome. It offers a reconstruction of Dutch immigration and nationality rules for the whole period from 1945 to 2000, with an emphasis on the position of families. While its time period means that it does not deal directly with the most recent developments, its merit is to detail the background to the new century's turn to integration in immigration and nationality law.
After an initial chapter which surveys changes in Dutch family norms through the postwar era, the core of the work is contained in three detailed chapters on the evolution of immigration and nationality law. Chapter 2 covers the period of fundamental social and political change in the Netherlands which lasted from 1945 to 1975. In the field of migration law, the central problem of that time was to identify those persons from Indonesia who should be eligible for Dutch citizenship and residence in the Netherlands after decolonisation. The work shows how the absence of a unified concept of Dutch nationality – akin to British subject status – led to a protracted process of definition and redefinition of those eligible. In practice, the classifications adopted for that purpose frequently followed the categories which had been used in the colonial period, so that having (or not having) a ‘European’ culture was crucial to an individual's fate.
This transitional period also saw fundamental changes in the social sphere, with the decline of the patriarchal family norm based on marriage, breadwinning husbands and stay-at-home wives. Initially, the field of migration law remained attached to the traditional model, so that wives and children were expected to follow the nationality and residence of a husband or father. By the mid 1960s, however, signs of change had begun to emerge. In the field of nationality law, a reform in 1965 meant that marriage no longer determined a woman's nationality under Dutch law. The same law provided for the acquisition of nationality by a second generation born in the Netherlands, even though their father was a foreign national. The traditional model was not entirely overturned, however: the foreign wives of Dutch husbands retained an unqualified right to opt for Dutch nationality, irrespective of their place of residence, while Dutch women continued to be blocked from passing Dutch nationality to their children. There were parallel changes in immigration law. In 1963, foreign male workers were allowed to bring wives and children with them for the first time, while 1965 saw the creation of a form of settlement for foreigners after five years' residence. But these reforms did not involve gender equality, as the rules on family reunification continued to strongly favour the admission of foreign wives over foreign husbands.
The reformulation of Dutch migration law between 1975 and 1990, largely in response to changes in social and political values, is the subject of Chapter 3. One sign of the changed approach in this phase was that the independence of Surinam posed far fewer problems than decolonisation in Indonesia had done. That was because the Surinamese were allowed to take up residence in the Netherlands prior to independence, as a result of which they were able to acquire Dutch citizenship. Equally, the years between 1975 and 1980 saw fundamental changes in the ways families were treated within immigration law. Gender-based distinctions were removed – thus enabling wives to sponsor husbands on equal terms – while recognition was given to unmarried cohabiting couples, including those in same-sex relationships. There was a similar reform of nationality law in 1985: the wives and husbands of Dutch citizens were now treated equally for the purpose of naturalisation, a route to naturalisation was created for unmarried couples, and women were enabled to pass on nationality to their children.
Van Walsum makes clear that these progressive reforms were not always cost-free. As formal distinctions – based on nationality or marriage – were removed, substantive controls tended to emerge in their place. That was seen for example in the ending of the possibility for Dutch husbands to confer nationality on their wives without a period of residence, as part of the 1985 reforms. Nevertheless, the progressive achievements of this second phase were considerable. Together, social democratic egalitarianism, a liberal view of family life, and feminist critique of state policies had led to a fundamental overhaul of immigration and nationality law. Such was the new climate that even when new restrictions were introduced they were often reversed after social and political objections.
The progressive period was followed by one in which new qualifications began to be introduced into immigration and nationality law. Chapter 4 of the work traces these developments from 1990 to 2000. In particular, it shows how the emergence of official concern at the non-integration of communities of migrant origin at that time led to restrictions on migration by adolescent children, and to new income requirements for the sponsorship of family members. By 2000, there was explicit questioning of multiculturalism among all the major political currents in the Netherlands. In the decade that followed, the consequence would be the direct imposition of integration conditions within immigration and nationality law.
The work goes on to offer some reflections on the interpretation of these post-1990 developments. One possibility is that the contemporary policy of excluding those whose capacity for integration is in doubt is connected to the colonial approach. Van Walsum's assessment is that the contemporary policy is ‘strikingly reminiscent’ of colonial-era racial classifications (p. 260), and the work concludes with the statement that ‘those who are producing and enforcing nationalist distinctions, in the increasingly global present … somehow rest on the shoulders of those who produced and enforced the racist distinctions of the colonial past’ (p. 281). Yet, her own hesitation about this thesis is evident in the recognition that (colonial) racism and (contemporary) nationalism ‘should … be kept distinct for purposes of analysis’, since the latter ‘also includes a discourse of shared territory’ (p. 278). This second view might have been explored further: the use of ‘culture’ to define a privileged stratum in a colonial context is surely rather different from its use in a socially diverse liberal democracy in order to regulate new migration.
A second possibility is that there are links between the progressive agenda up to 1990 and the exclusionary focus on the integration of migrants thereafter. As van Walsum puts it, in the more recent period ‘a social taxonomy was … produced which gave expression to an emancipatory project by defining who was to be excluded’ (p. 269). In other words, state policy has increasingly come to uphold contemporary ‘Dutch values’, including personal freedom and gender equality, against migrants and communities of migrant origin. While the author hints at this dilemma, she does not seek to resolve it. The reader is therefore left to ponder the question: can it possibly be legitimate for a mainstream conception of social progress to determine state policies on admission and residence?
