More than a recuperative gesture to fill a “gap” in Western performance studies, Amy Bryzgel's Performance Art in Eastern Europe since 1960 aims to challenge and deconstruct reductive stereotypes. Her core argument is that performance art in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union developed “in parallel and in dialogue with practices in Western Europe and North America, despite its exclusion from the canon of that history” (1; original emphasis). RoseLee Goldberg, for instance, omitted Eastern European theatre in her otherwise seminal Performance: Live Art, 1909 to the Present (1979), Bryzgel's recurring reference point in this book. Grotowski, Meyerhold, and a few others aside, most theatre of the region has been ignored indeed by Western scholars. Bryzgel's thorough investigation is therefore a much-needed study, covering twenty-one countries from the former Eastern Bloc. Although Bryzgel is an American art historian, her formidable language skills (she learned both Polish and Latvian), extensive primary research (she conducted more than two hundred and fifty interviews), and immersive firsthand experience (she traveled to all of the countries except for Ukraine) gives her the essential insider's perspective.
The introductory Chapter 1 addresses an impressive range of happenings and performance art experiments in various Eastern European countries. Likely depending on the availability of resources, some examples are cited only briefly, which occasionally gives the impression of a dry database rather than a critical discourse. Yet when archives allow, Bryzgel effectively blends anecdote, historical information, and comparative performance analysis. For example, she discusses a highly subversive 1982 production by Laibach, a major Slovenian multimedia artistic group, in the larger sociopolitical context, including one of their prescripted television interviews, “a performance in itself” (62). Furthermore, she analyzes Slavoj Žižek's assessment of that same project as “a strategy of ‘overidentification’” and compares it with Sylvia Sasse and Inke Arns's concept of “‘subversive affirmation’” (62).
Bryzgel's excellent archival work and sophisticated analysis are even more effective in the subsequent chapters. She structures her book into “categories [that] emerged from the research, as opposed to preceding or being applied to it” (4): “the body (chapter 2), gender (chapter 3), politics and identity (chapter 4), and institutional critique (chapter 5).” The overlap with common themes of Western performance studies may come as a surprise; to Bryzgel, however, it is one more argument that Eastern European artists are part of a synchronized global performance tradition to which they have added “their own unique statements, expressions and manifestations” (4). Accordingly, Bryzgel resignifies numerous pre- and postcommunist performance experiments from that area—a critical move I found both beautiful and retroactively empowering.
In Chapter 2, for instance, she challenges Klara Kemp-Welch for considering Jiří Kovanda's “quiet” actions in 1970s Czechoslovakia as “reticent in their quiet minimalism” (118). His experiments occurred in private homes, with a photographer as the only spectator/recorder of the event, or in public spaces, but completely ignored by oblivious and/or scared passersby. In contrast, Bryzgel argues for their performative and political efficacy as “an assertion of the presence of the individual in the public sphere at a time when such acts of individuality were not welcomed” (119). Yet later in the book, talking about similar performance actions, she herself wonders “how these works can truly be considered subversive, disruptive or revolutionary given that they were not observed by a public that would be disrupted, disturbed or challenged by them” (194). The historian wrestles the performance scholar; in oppressive contexts, it is often a tie.
In Chapter 3, which focuses on gender, Bryzgel's Western theoretical perspective occasionally conflicts with the subject of her investigation. The specific development of feminism as a historical Western activist movement and ideological lens distinguishes it from Eastern European women's struggle for equal rights during and after the fall of communism. In this context, it appears contradictory that Bryzgel associates feminism with certain artists, such as the Croatian Vlasta Delimar (188–9), the Hungarian Dóra Maurer (213–14), and the Polish Natalia LL (185–6), despite their consistent public opposition to this framing.
Chapter 4 emphasizes the moral integrity and persisting risks of advocating for human rights in these countries, in Bryzgel's account of artists such as Russian Vladislav Mamyshev, a Marilyn Monroe impersonator who was a victim of gay bashing, and Estonian Sandra Jõgeva, who reenacted in several performances her 2005–6 work experience as a dominatrix. Similar dangers apply in post-Soviet Russia, where three of the feminist punk group Pussy Riot were charged with “hooliganism motivated by religious hatred” (289) and were sentenced to two years in prison following a 2012 performance action critical of the Orthodox Church's support of President Putin.
Chapter 5 further validates the book's main argument, investigating the Eastern European artists’ critique of the institutionalization of art. According to Bulgarian Ivan Moudov, in the almost complete absence of an art market because of totalitarianism, followed by very limited postcommunist state support, locally they “‘don't even get the chance to hate the museum’” (298). In the international context, however, giving an intentionally untranslated lecture in Croatian in 1979 Amsterdam (Mladen Stilinović [323]), being present at the 2007 Venice Biennale by donating Bulgarian wine for its opening in the absence of a national pavilion (Ivan Moudov [325]), and stating “An Artist Who Cannot Speak English Is No Artist” (Stilinović in 1992 [325]), these artists clearly refute any suspicion of ever being derivatives and/or outsiders. As Bryzgel explains, one can challenge a system only when one is/becomes part of it.
Bryzgel's consistent comparison of works from different Eastern European countries helps (re)construct a performative space on its own cultural and political terms. In addition, the many illustrations are a visual treat and help readers imagine the performances discussed. As a Romanian-born writer and director who resided and worked in Bucharest until 2000, I must agree with Bryzgel: given the linguistic, political, and economic barriers, living in Eastern Europe before and even after 1989 does not guarantee that one knows the work of artists there, nor that they know of each other's work. In this and many other ways, the informative value of Bryzgel's study is remarkable for both Western and Eastern scholarship.
