A review of Paul McKechnie's study of Christianisation has to begin by noting that the title is misleading insofar as the analysis does not cover the whole of Asia Minor but only a small part of it, namely Phrygia. Asia, Galatia, Cappadocia, Cilicia and other parts of Asia Minor come into focus only to a very limited extent or not at all. Since the development of Christianity on the west coast and in Asia has already been well reviewed by Paul R. Trebilco and Colin J. Hemer, M. looks at the development of Christianity in Phrygian cities, making ‘a supposed periphery into the centre’ (2). Where sources are available he also takes a look at rural areas and, if necessary, draws from inland regions adjacent to Phrygia. M. draws on preliminary work by Stephen Mitchell, Peter Thonemann and Ulrich Huttner, but also on his own work on the region. His sources are texts of Christian and pagan provenance. He can also refer to inscriptions and archaeological findings due to the excellent situation for Phrygia in this respect. M. grounds his approach in the theory of the social construction of reality developed by Peter L. Berger and Thomas Luckmann. His goal is to explain how the shift from polytheist and imperial religion to Christianity came about in the first Christian centuries. The analysis covers developments up to the fourth century, when the situation was stabilised by Constantine.
Based on the reports of Paul's first conversions in Galatia in Acts 13–14, M. begins his account with the early congregations in the Phrygian Lykos valley (Colossae, Laodicea, Hierapolis), whose Christianisation has recently been dealt with in detail by Huttner (Early Christianity in the Lycus Valley, 2013). The Christianisation of Hierapolis is connected with a Philip, one of the seven deacons appointed in Jerusalem, who was later identified locally with the disciple of Jesus. More can be said about Papias of Hierapolis, who wrote an Account of Logia about the Lord and ‘brought Jesus home to Phrygia’ (68). In addition to notes on the gospels, this work refers to a Jesus memoir specially prepared for Asia Minor. M. uses the figure of Papias to introduce a wider discussion of the ‘teachers of Asia’. Ignatius travelled through Asia Minor, and probably Phrygia, on his way from Syrian Antioch to Rome; he also influenced the Phrygian churches with his letters. Polycarp of Smyrna is another teacher who ‘matters because of the impact he made during his long life across the province of Asia and beyond’ (79). Travelling less than many of his peers, he watered the seeds sown by Ignatius and seems to have been known from Philippi to Philomelium. As further ‘teachers of Asia’ M. cites Paul and Thecla (i.e. the author of the encratically coloured Acta Pauli, which M. like others tentatively locates in Iconium).
Two large chapters are dedicated to Montanism and its prominent representatives and prophetesses, as well as to the location of the ‘New Jerusalem’ and various Montanist communities. Aberkios from Hierapolis, by contrast, is seen as a representative of a ‘campaign of controversy against the Montanist church’. M. uses the example of Apollonia to demonstrate the importance of the imperial cult in the region from the time of Augustus and the compatibility of Christianity and public offices. He postulates a connection between a Christian family in Apollonia and the clergy of Temenothyrae, which he also classifies as Montanist.
Interpreting inscriptions with the so-called Eumeneian curse formula as Christian, M. sees here a hint that Christians in the region revealed their identity quite publicly already before the end of the persecutions, at least in remote areas. At their side M. puts the ‘Christians for Christians’ inscriptions which are specific to Phrygian Christianity and which suggest a Christian network. A short outlook on the Great Persecution and further developments in the fourth century concludes the reflection.
M. illustrates his account with the help of selected Christian leaders who practised Christianisation, such as Philip, Papias and Apollinarius in Hierapolis. To broaden the view, he treats other well-known Christians from Asia Minor. ‘Simple’ parishioners who were also involved in the Christianisation process, however, are rarely mentioned. M. correctly sees that Jewish diaspora communities were the most important starting point for the first Christian community formations. He also points to the importance of Hellenism in this respect, but it does not really become clear how Hellenism influenced Christianisation locally. This applies not only to religious cults and philosophical schools, but also to infrastructural conditions and social structures. It remains to be asked whether a presentation of Christianisation (and conversion) can succeed convincingly by concentrating on selected characters and without taking into account theological issues and the content of preaching. It is also doubtful whether a strongly homogenising treatment of different early Christian groups, which in M.'s view were strongly marked by Montanism, can really do justice to the dynamics and diversity of Christianity in the first centuries.
In summary: M. has presented a very readable and well-informed book, enriched by many historically important details. His sketch of the outlines of processes of Christianisation in Phrygia is valuable, though it can be debated and supplemented in some respects.
