Liba Taub and Frances Willmoth's book celebrates the sixtieth anniversary of the gift that begat the Whipple Museum of the History of Science at Cambridge. Their volume brings together essays from a broad range of students and academics, all of whom have studied some aspect of the Whipple's collections. Just a glance over the list of contributors, including Jim Bennett, Stephen Johnston and Simon Schaffer, gives some indication of the debt owed to the Whipple by the discipline of history of scientific instruments and even history of science itself. It is the type of book all museums serious about research might aspire to produce. The reader is left with a clear sense of the breadth and scope of the collection while at the same time meeting a range of different approaches to its study. Indeed, for those curious to see how instruments can be incorporated into narratives within the history of science, these essays form the perfect introduction. They were a pleasure to read.
Those intending to read from cover to cover will find the whole thoughtfully set out, taking us from the founding of the museum and then through various approaches to the study of objects, with similar approaches or objects of study grouped together. From the section on the founding of the museum it is possible to track its development, beginning with the donation of a private collection which in turn attracted the collections accumulated by individual departments. One possible omission from this opening section was any discussion of the museum's founding within a wider context outside Cambridge University. The Whipple does of course occupy an important place within the history of science and the scientific activities in Cambridge, and the Cavendish and the Cambridge Instrument Company (of which R. S. Whipple was director) are essential to the story. It might, however, have been interesting to compare the founding of the Whipple with the founding of other museums, especially those established around the same time. Reference is given to Jim Bennett's paper ‘Museums and the establishment of the history of science at Oxford and Cambridge’ (BJHS (1997), 30, 29–46), but this, as the title suggests, is primarily concerned with these museums as they matter for understanding the history of science as a discipline in this country. I would have been interested to know a little more about how the foundation of the Whipple fitted with contemporary ideas as to the purpose of museums, and how these ideas informed the early proposals.
As it appears through its depiction in these essays, the Whipple collection is one in which books, perhaps surprisingly, play as important a role as objects. R. S. Whipple himself, as several authors comment, placed a high value on the study of objects alongside relevant contemporary texts. Those he especially prized included manuals, catalogues, textbooks and other contemporary descriptions of composition and use. It is also a collection which contains objects made for a wide range of markets; the needs of those different markets become apparent through close study of the objects. The overlapping needs of scientific education and research mean that while, broadly speaking, all the objects in the collection might be deemed scientific, many can also be classed as educational in the broadest sense. Like all collections, the Whipple also contains a number of fakes. The value in studying this type of object, and in seeing how such study can inform understanding of the history of collecting and the relative importance of science and science collections in the past, is examined in several of the essays here.
Michael Rich's essay is a good example of one that incorporates a number of these themes. In his study of George Adams's geometrical models, Rich discusses a set of models which represent propositions from Euclid's Elements. He examines the objects alongside the text to explore the advantages of each in effectively teaching the same concepts. He also looks at the objects within the context of eighteenth-century society and how the look and feel of the objects helped to indicate the market Adams was aiming them towards. Other essays are equally successful, such as Stephen Johnston's on a mathematical rule. It is richly evocative of the value and reward of close study, and appealing too in its detective-like approach. Here one narrative is given only to be turned around when a new object is introduced, drawing out new comparisons and providing a twist to the original story.
The book's contributors all seem aware that they are writing for an audience that may never have considered the study of scientific instruments. To that end, many provide an introduction to the discipline with key bibliographic material included in the footnotes. Richard Dunn, for example, introduces his essay on the relationship between the market for scientific instruments and their outward appearance with a short overview of the history of collecting and studying scientific instruments. Simon Schaffer, meanwhile, introduces his essay on time machines, and a 1995 exhibition with which he had been involved at the Whipple, with a synopsis of the history of science museums. A bibliography drawing all these texts together might have been a useful addition. It may, however, have been considered and dismissed in order to keep the book, nearly five hundred pages long, to a manageable length.
