Steven Suskin begins The Sound of Broadway Music with a moment of self-conscious uncertainty about how best to classify the activity of orchestration. “Theatre orchestration is the art of—well, is it a creative art?” he asks. In reviewing this book, I find myself in a similarly difficult position because it is a work that is likewise hard to classify. Suskin is not an academic, and this is not a scholarly monograph (at least in the usual sense), for of the 600-plus pages only 100 or so are dedicated to critical interpretation. Nonetheless, it is, clearly, the product of an impressive amount of research—much of it original. It is most like a reference book or encyclopedia. There are 125 pages dedicated to brief professional biographies of most of the men and women who contributed orchestrations to Broadway musicals from 1943 to 1965, and 300 pages that identify, show by show, who orchestrated what for almost every Broadway musical during this period. Indeed, Suskin's own description of his book suggests he thinks of it as more encyclopedic than critical: “This volume is not intended as a technical primer in orchestration, nor for that matter a treatise on music theory; The Sound of Broadway Music discusses the work and careers of the major orchestrators of a certain period of the Broadway musical, along with the shows they orchestrated” (178).
Still, the entries on orchestrators and their musicals are shoehorned into the structure of something like the “treatise” Suskin promised not to write: a book organized by chapters with a continuous though somewhat meandering narrative that is, as much as anything, “a primer on orchestration” (admittedly, not an overly technical one). This arrangement may have contributed to the somewhat uneven tone of the narrative. Suskin's writing is, as always, eminently readable, but his chatty, self-indulgent style grates a bit in a book marketed as a scholarly study. His frequent personal narratives, especially the lengthy account of watching a Kennedy Center production of Sweeney Todd from the orchestra pit, seem to be included less to illustrate any particular point than to invite the reader to look back from the subject to the writer and marvel at the depth of his research and his professional connections, especially when he mentions looking out at the presidential box and remembers an evening he spent there with the Reagans. Such name-dropping seems indecorous in such a book based on important original research findings.
Suskin may have adopted this approach in the desire to attract the most diverse readership possible. He writes, “My aim is to explain the process [of orchestration] in a manner that is comprehensible to musicians and nonmusicians alike,” and “While these pages are presumably packed with information that will be of keen interest to professional musicians, my goal is to keep the discussion comprehensible to nonmusicians.” As a “nonmusician” myself, I appreciate Suskin's effort, but his attempt to discuss the technique of orchestration and describe aural sensation using only paper and ink is only partially successful. Suskin uses the overture to Gypsy—a piece he assumes “readers of these pages already know”—as a shared text from which he builds a language to discuss orchestration more generally. It is a very smart move, but one that is nonetheless limiting; relying on readers’ memories of an overture permits only a certain range of argument.
As Suskin strains against the limitations of the printed page to describe musical sound to both musicians and nonmusicians, the potential usefulness of an e-book for his subject becomes apparent. Electronic publishing has developed significantly since this book was published but is, at the time of this writing, not yet entirely mature. However, the increasing functionality and popularity of e-book readers, mobile computing devices, and tablet computers may make books like Suskin's anachronistic in the future. Why depend on a reader's memory of an overture, for instance, when a recording can be linked to the text? Suskin's paper-based, 300-page, show-by-show listing of orchestrator credits could also be made available in the form of an electronic database, thus facilitating readers’ searches for information.
Despite its shortcomings, The Sound of Broadway Music is an impressive reference book with information that is mostly not duplicated elsewhere. Suskin's opening section includes (mostly) previously untold personal and professional biographies of the men and women who orchestrated Broadway shows from 1920 until around 1980 (although some have continued working to the present day). Their stories help to fill out an important strand in the history of musical theater previously unknown to those not connected with the industry. What makes the book most valuable, however, is the meticulous song-by-song analysis of manuscript drafts of scores, which, along with extensive interviews with those connected with the shows, allow Suskin to confidently identify, in many cases for the first time in print, who orchestrated most of the important Broadway shows of the twentieth century. Suskin has convincingly demonstrated that orchestrators, as the co-creators (and in some cases the primary composer) of much of the music in the Broadway musical, deserve greater recognition—or at the very least to have their often initially anonymous work credited as the narrative of twentieth-century musical theater history is constructed. For this the book represents an important contribution to scholarship on the Broadway musical.
