This is a masterly, well-balanced, comprehensive history of the peoples living around the body of a water known by such names as Pontus Euxinus, Kara Deniz, and Chernoe More. Touching both Asia and Europe, the Black Sea has been used for thousands of years to transport grain, furs, wood, and slaves from the fertile north to Anatolia, the Mediterranean, and beyond in exchange for the products of the south. Occasionally it was the venue of invaders, though it served trade more than conquest.
King's story begins around 700 B.C. and continues until 1990. It is based largely on the writings, sometimes fanciful, of authors ranging from Heredotus, Strabo, and Porphyrogenitus to Evliya Celebi, Compte Segur, and Mark Twain, in addition to many other primary and secondary sources. The book deals extensively with the peoples inhabiting the steppe behind the northern shore, including Scythians, Sarmatians, Goths, Huns, Avars, Varangians, Pechenegs, Uz, Slavs, Norse, Vikings, Rhos (Russians), and Kalmyks. The Cumans (Kipchaks-Polovetsi), who ruled the steppe from the late 11th century to the early 13th century and supplied human stock—and rulers—to Hungary, Bulgaria, Wallachia, and Moldova are entitled to a longer treatment. Armenians and Caucasians, such as the mysterious Colchians living around the Rioni River in today's Georgia, constituted the sedentary population when the “civilizing” Greeks arrived and the written history began.
In the 1st century B.C., Pompey defeated Mithridates, the first native potentate who had attempted to create an empire that encircled the entire sea. The Getae-Dacis, led by Decebal, resisted Rome between 101 and 106. Traian celebrated his hard-won victory by raising the Forum Traiani in Rome in 113 (also the Tropaeum Traiani at Adamclisi in Dobrudja in 109) to chronicle in gravures—155 scenes and 2,500 figures—the people and events of the time. The Romans abandoned most of the northern shore in 275 and erected a wall between the Black Sea and the Danube to deny the “barbarians” access to the south. From the 4th to 9th centuries the region underwent profound changes as one group displaced, assimilated, or mixed with others to produce new ethnicities.
King rightly emphasizes the seminal role of the Fourth Crusade in putting a virtual end to the Byzantine Empire and indirectly helping to establish the rapidly expanding Ottoman state. The crusade enabled Genoa (and, to a lesser extent, Venice) to direct the main trade of the Black Sea from Constantinople and Caffa in Crimea and allowed the Comneni in Trebizond, who identified with Byzantium and Rome but not Hellas, to establish their own state that, allied with and related by marriage to the inland Turkmen, lasted until Mehmet II's conquest in 1461.
As King warns, today's religious, political, and national categories cannot be imposed on the extraordinary mix of languages, religions, and cultures or on the fluid relations among the peoples of the Black Sea. The sea was, in Marco Polo's time, the “center of an economic network that extended from the mulberry groves of China to the silk houses of Marseilles, from the fairs of Novgorod and Kiev to the bazaars of Tabriz” (p. 82). In Theodosia, Crimea, amid dozens of languages, “[b]ells from Franciscan and Dominican monasteries pealed the hours, competing with the Islamic call to prayer or the chants of Orthodox and Armenian priests” (p. 84). The political fate of the Black Sea in the 13th and 14th centuries was determined by the Turks and Russians, whose early states in Anatolia and Kiev, respectively, were conquered and ruled by the Mongols. Bringing order and security to the Black Sea trade, the Mongols provided the new model and philosophy of state that the Turks and Russians used to conquer the Balkans and the steppe and unite their own people and culturally heterogeneous subjects into the Russian and Turkish polities of today.
By the 15th century the Ottomans had turned the Black Sea into a “Turkish Lake,” the only power to dominate it to that extent, controlling its lucrative trade until 1774. The fate of the Ottoman state was decided on the shores of the Black Sea that year after Catherine the Great opened the sea to outside trade. Catherine annexed Crimea in 1783 and in 1794 built Odessa into a thriving port. Despite Trebizond's short-lived revival, the south coast stagnated. The history of the Greeks, Armenians, Turks, Lazes, and others who migrated to seek work in Russia still awaits its writer.
In the 19th century, modernization from above created havoc in traditional society. Tsar Nicholas I, proclaiming Orthodoxy, autocracy, and nationality to be state ideology, challenged Istanbul's rule over Jerusalem and the Balkan Christians. The ensuing Crimean War of 1853 and First Balkan War of 1877–78 signaled the end of the Ottoman state. Here, suddenly, King's detached and absorbing narrative deviates into an unfortunate subjectivity. Russia's religion-based nationality (and search for territorial security) produced a form of Orthodox Christian nationalism that led to pan-Slavism and was instrumental in the killing or uprooting of some 7 million Muslims from Crimea, the Caucasus, and the Balkans. King mentions these deaths as if they were the natural result of history (pp. 215, 229), while he laments at length (pp. 209–15) the fate of Armenian and Greek Christians who were “killed by Turks.” His narrative seems to have been influenced by the local literature, which described the Turks, Tatars, and Muslims as “aliens,” “intruders,” or “infidels,” therefore fit for the killing and uprooting to which I and members of my family, who hail from Dobrudja, have been subject. Such one-sided opinion and inflated figures justify and invite revenge by whichever party is portrayed as the victim. To describe the colonization of Dobrudja by Vlahs from the Balkans as “bringing them to the homeland” (p. 254) is a forced euphemism, which ignores the agony of the Turks and, ultimately, Bulgarians whom they displaced and persecuted.
Apart from these disconcerting lapses into subjectivity and a few minor factual errors, the book is an outstanding work of synthesis, with a broad comprehensive vista and lucid expression. King has successfully condensed a twenty-seven century saga of trade, migration, war, conquest, ethnolinguistic transformation, and statehood into a relatively short, easy to read, engaging story.
