This volume began life as a series of papers presented in honour of Professor Elaine Fantham at the Presidential Panel held during the Annual Meeting of the Classical Association of Canada in 2010. The late, great, Elaine Fantham, in whose honour this volume was similarly produced, died in the year of its publication. But the papers contained within, each accompanied by the authors’ reflections on the contribution that Fantham made to their lives (both personal and professional), are testament to the huge impact that she has had — and continues to have — on the study of Roman literary culture and on those who promote its study. Fittingly, this volume has been edited by two of the people who knew her best: Alison Keith and Jonathon Edmondson. Together they have edited a volume of papers that is as varied in content as Fantham's own extensive body of work (listed in its entirety on pp. xiii–xxi), and whose ethos reflects her own pioneering work in situating literary works within their cultural context.
There are fourteen papers in total, including the introductory chapter, which are divided into three groups: ‘Part I: Domestic Politics’, ‘Part II: Revolutionary Poetics’ and ‘Part III: Civic Spectacle’.
Part I focuses on ‘the impact of contemporary political debates for our understanding of literary works set in the Roman house and household’ (6). This section consists of four papers, by Christer Bruun (‘Varro on the battle against moisture in the Roman domus (a note on Men. Fr. 531–2)’, 17–38), Fanny Dolansky (‘Rape, the family, and the “father of the fatherland” in Ovid Fasti 2’, 39–58), Alison Keith (‘Naming the elegiac mistress: elegiac onomastics in Roman inscriptions’, 59–88) and Sarah Blake (‘In manus: Pliny's letters and the arts of mastery’, 89–107). All four papers are good. Dolansky furthers the debate on the function of rape in the Ovidian corpus by contextualising it within (Augustan) contemporary legislation on morality, and Blake draws attention to Pliny's use of in manus in his letters and studies the wider implications of this phrase, particularly in reference to slaves and the role they played in literary production. Bruun and Keith's papers perhaps best evoke the ethos of this section. Bruun's paper on Varro combines the study of literary fragments with what we know about the construction of Roman houses, and specifically water features, to offer an interesting new take on how one can use material culture to help solve textual problems. Keith's paper (originally published in Italian) offers a fascinating and detailed study of onomastic material and epigraphic remains, that gives new insight into how Latin elegists employed Greek names (especially in reference to their beloved). Moreover, she comments on what this usage says about Rome's imperial project, including its claim to assert cultural (as well as literal) hegemony over Greece.
Part II, on revolutionary poetics, is the largest section and focuses on ‘the significance of genre, allusion, and intertextuality in Latin literary texts, especially those of Ovid’ (7). The five papers by Barbara Weiden Boyd (‘Ovid's Circe and the revolutionary power of carmina in the Remedia amoris’, 111–23), Sarah L. McCallum (‘Primus pastor: the origins of pastoral in Ovid's Metamorphoses’, 124–39), C. W. Marshall (‘Narrative transitions in Ovid's Metamorphoses 9’, 140–58), Cedric Littlewood (‘Elegy and epic in Lucan's Bellum Ciuile’, 159–84) and Elizabeth Kennedy (‘Reading Aeneas through Hannibal: the poetics of revenge and the repetitions of history’, 185–99) all focus in varying degrees on the idea of ‘revolution’ within Latin poetry and how authors — notably Ovid — ‘play’ with genre and employ intertextuality to redefine poetic boundaries. All five of these papers offer new and interesting ways of approaching these texts, but of particular note are the papers by Boyd, Marshall and Littlewood. Boyd, perhaps more than any of the others, encapsulates the concept of ‘revolutionary poetics’ in her paper on Ovid, whilst Marshall's well-written piece on the ‘segues’ within Ovid's Metamorphoses Book 9 sheds new light on the composition and function of Ovid's narrative structure. Finally, Littlewood's detailed approach to the presence of ‘elegiac mourning’ in Lucan's bleak epic on civil war challenges us to rethink how we approach an epic that speaks of resistance and a desire to reclaim an idealised Republic (whilst simultaneously showing the futility of that desire).
Part III, on civic spectacle, has four papers which ‘explore the public ceremonies and political ceremonial that engaged the Roman citizenry en masse both in and through Roman textual culture’ (8). The four papers in this section, by Jarrett Welsh (‘The charms of an older lover: Afranius 378-82 Ribbeck3’, 203–20), Jonathan Tracy (‘Knowledge, power, and republicanism in Lucan’, 221–53), Clifford Ando (‘The rites of others’, 254–77) and Jonathan Edmondson (‘Rituals of reciprocity: staging gladiatorial munera in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’, 278–309), return us once more to the study of literary texts and their socio-political backdrop. The content of this section is more varied than those that precede it; Walsh's article offers a detailed, important and ultimately convincing re-reading of a fragment by the republican comic playwright Afranius, whilst Ando's paper focuses on how Roman law (as recorded in political documents and epigraphic material) attests to the fact that the Romans supported the continuation of ‘foreign’ religious cults even after communities had been incorporated into the Empire. Tracy's paper argues that Lucan's epic presents a vision of the Roman Republic where every citizen is encouraged to claim his share in the knowledge typically reserved for the elite. The final paper in this volume, Edmondson's ‘Rituals of reciprocity’, argues that Apuleius’ Metamorphoses ‘evokes a very real sense of place, a cultural milieu: that is a world of the Greek province under Roman rule’ (279), and as such can be seen as a reflection of Roman civic practices, especially gladiatorial games.
This volume has been well produced, with few typos. There is a useful general index, as well as an index locorum, and each paper is followed by a bibliography. The diversity of the volume means that the themes serve as anchor points, rather than uniting the content into a compact ‘whole’, but this does not detract from the quality. Certainly, this volume is a fitting tribute to the diverse, rich and invariably excellent work of its main inspiration: Elaine Fantham.
