What is the relationship between foreigners and democracy? This is the central research question posed in Fighting for Foreigners: Immigration and its Impact on Japanese Democracy. Do foreigners strengthen or weaken civil society? If they do strengthen democracy, what do the mechanisms and processes look like? In this timely work, Shipper analyzes the role of nonstate institutions in immigrant rights and local governments in advancing democracy in Japan. He argues that foreigner support groups within Japanese civil society contribute to democratic governance through associative activism when ‘(1) like-minded activists form a range of NGOs to address specific problems and (2) local governments increasingly cooperate with activists and their organizations, forming novel and flexible institutions’ (11). Building upon the works of political theorists such as Iris Marion Young and Melissa Williams, he forwards a dynamic, pragmatic, deliberative, and representative model of associative activism that addresses two theoretical concerns: ‘(1) how the political motivations of Japanese activists change as deliberative exchanges occur across organizations in various localities; and (2) how these networks transform both local institutions and dominant social meanings’ (11).
The book is structured in seven chapters. After a sustained theoretical discussion on the relationships between foreigners and democracy in the introduction, Chapter 2 lays out the socio-political context of Japan's foreign workers policy. Chapters 3 and 4 distinguish between two main kinds of civil society organizations: immigrant ethnic groups and immigrant rights groups led by Japanese. He argues that ‘in promoting their members’ attachment to the “home” lands, ethnic associations also foster psychological and political detachment from Japanese society, thereby weakening national identity’ (78). Chapter 5 then looks into the role of local governments as partners with immigrant rights NGOs in institutionalizing democratic representation of foreigners. Chapter 6 analyzes how narratives of immigrant rights NGOs serve as counterweight to predominant social meanings in Japan. He concludes that associative activism by immigrant rights groups has ‘forced government officials to reflect on Japan's national identity and to negotiate a new social contract with citizens on agreed rules, procedures, and responsibilities for all those who reside on their islands’ (200).
The strength of this book lies in its novel theoretical argument about the partnership between nonstate institutions and local governments in furthering the representation and deliberation of foreigners’ rights in Japan. Further, Shipper details for the reader how immigrant rights NGOs manage to push for legal and political reforms as well as contest the dominant social meanings in the public sphere. He makes a nuanced distinction between different types of civil society organizations and argues that certain NGOs are more effective in fostering democratic governance. Supported by fieldwork spanning over a decade, the book is rich in interview data and observation about marginalized foreigners in Japan.
A couple of theoretical and empirical questions might be worth raising. Shipper mentions in his ending paragraph that ‘Japanese activists will certainly continue to invoke international norms, monitor the government's responses, and provide new ideas’ (201). In a book on foreigners’ rights, it is somewhat surprising that ‘international norms’ come only at the end. Over the past two decades, both immigrant ethnic associations and immigrant rights groups led by Japanese have used a range of international human rights norms to advance their cause. Even though the author does carefully delineate the differences among immigrant ethnic associations and immigrant rights groups, he falls short in explaining how these diverse groups (with their focus on labor, women, medical issues, and immigration etc.) mobilize (or not) around the discourse of human rights along slightly different lines. For example, women's shelters for foreign sex workers might invoke international norms against violence against women, while medical groups might use a universal right to health argument. Adding a more substantive discussion on international human rights norms concerning foreigners (how they emerge, change over time, and are mobilized by different groups along gender, race, and immigrant status lines) might then enrich Shipper's argument. The causal chain begins less in associative activism in Japan; but in international human rights norms. A second question pertains to an empirical aspect of the author's argument that cooperation between local governments and immigrant rights NGOs has shaped the role of the state in redefining citizenship rules and boundaries in Japan. Besides the examples given in Chapter 5 about the establishment of NGO advisory council in Kanagawa prefecture and the Kanagawa Foreign Residents’ Council, there is little empirical evidence of representation of and deliberation on immigrant rights in other parts of Japan.
In sum, this is an excellent book to anyone interested in the issue of foreigners’ rights and NGO activism in Japan and in other comparative contexts. It is a must-read for all who are concerned about democratic governance and citizenship negotiations.
