This luster bowl, made by the Persian potter Abu Zayd in February–March 1204 (Jumada II 600), exemplifies the broad range of questions that can be raised by Islamic art. The first question is that of provenance. The bowl appeared on the art market in 2001, unknown and undocumented but in virtually perfect condition. A battery of tests supports its authenticity. Jonathan Bloom and I included it in the exhibition Cosmophilia: Islamic Art from the David Collection, Copenhagen, which we organized for the McMullen Museum, Boston College, and which was on view until 20 May 2007 at the Smart Museum, University of Chicago. However, we are in the dark about where the bowl has been in the eight centuries since it was made.
The second question is the timing of its creation. The fifty years around the turn of the 13th century saw a burst of creativity in Persian ceramics unparalleled anywhere in the world until the rise of industrial pottery in 18th-century England. Potters in the desert city of Kashan adopted a new stonepaste body that they decorated in a host of ways. Wares could be molded or thrown, decorated with incised or applied ornament, covered in a monochrome glaze, and painted under or over the glaze. However, historically this was a period of political confusion, with the demise of the Saljuqs as the Khwarazmshahs moved into the area. Clearly, artistic creativity is not contingent on political stability.
A third question is the role of the individual artist in creating a work of art. The bowl is twice signed by the most famous potter of medieval Iran, Abu Zayd, who worked in the two most expensive overglaze techniques, enamel and luster, and who left behind the greatest number of signed works. What role did he play in the florescence of the Kashan style? Was he the prime mover behind the resurgence of the ceramics business or did he just claim credit?
The fourth question is what the decoration means. The well of the bowl shows a seated couple, a male on the right with cap and boot on a flexed leg, a female on the left with a headdress and longer braid. How do they relate to the Persian poetry around the edge that laments the beloved's infidelity? Do the verses just exemplify the literary culture of the time, when Persian lyric poetry emerged as a classic genre, or is there a specific story behind the iconography?
The fifth and final question is what was the function of such a bowl and who used it and for what. Contemporary chronicles are generally silent on crafts and the artisans who produced them, so to answer these questions we must study the objects themselves. This bowl, probably dug up clandestinely in Afghanistan, tells us that Kashan potters at the turn of the 13th century, like the high-ranking viziers and amirs who purchased such vessels, were important and well-educated members of the community who read and wrote both Arabic and Persian and knew much about contemporary literature. Through this bowl and other, better-known works we can learn more about daily life in medieval times.
