1. Introduction
Fluid flow through porous or perforated surfaces has been a research hotspot, as it spans various engineering fields, such as industrial aggregation, sedimentation and filtration (Singh & Narasimhamurthy Reference Singh and Narasimhamurthy2022), the cooling of electronic devices (Chingulpitak et al. Reference Chingulpitak, Ahn, Asirvatham and Wongwises2019; Zhao, Zhang & Dong Reference Zhao, Zhang and Dong2024), energy absorption (Godini & Kheradmand Reference Godini and Kheradmand2021), the drag reduction of bluff bodies (Zhou et al. Reference Zhou, Liu, Chen, Zhang, Zhang, Li and Zhao2023; Zhang et al. Reference Zhang, Liu, Xiang and Pan2024), and the modelling of flows over wind farms (Bossuyt et al. Reference Bossuyt, Howland, Meneveau and Meyers2017). Nevertheless, the flow characteristics and underlying mechanism are typically highly complex. To promote a fundamental understanding of this aspect, the interaction between vortex rings and porous surfaces has attracted attention because a vortex ring can be readily generated in a laboratory setting. Additionally, a series of research on the free development of vortex rings (Glezer Reference Glezer1988; Shusser & Gharib Reference Shusser and Gharib2000; Sullivan et al. Reference Sullivan, Niemela, Hershberger, Bolster and Donnelly2008; Gao & Yu Reference Gao and Yu2010; Tinaikar, Advaith & Basu Reference Tinaikar, Advaith and Basu2018; Mitchell & Morris Reference Mitchell and Morris2025) and their interactions with non-penetrating walls (Cheng, Lou & Luo Reference Cheng, Lou and Luo2010; New & Zang Reference New and Zang2017; New et al. Reference New, Long, Zang and Shi2020; Chen, Gao & Chen Reference Chen, Gao and Chen2022; Ahmed & Erath Reference Ahmed and Erath2023; New, Xu & Shi Reference New, Xu and Shi2024; Tang et al. Reference Tang, Li, Liu and Wen2024), as well as walls with circular apertures (Hu & Peterson Reference Hu and Peterson2018, Reference Hu and Peterson2021) can provide important theoretical foundations.
In an early study, Adhikari & Lim (Reference Adhikari and Lim2009) examined the flow behaviour of a vortex ring impacting porous walls with varying porosities (
${\phi }$
) using flow visualisation. The results revealed that at a low Reynolds number (Re), the flow behaviour was similar to that of a vortex ring impinging on a solid wall. When Re was sufficiently high, the fluid of the incident vortex ring could pass through the wall and regenerate into a new ring via vortex stretching and reconnection. Furthermore, the critical Re for the formation of the transmitted vortex ring depended on
${\phi }$
. Hrynuk, Van & Bohl (Reference Hrynuk, Van Luipen and Bohl2012) investigated the interaction of vortex rings with porous walls with variable wire structure sizes. They observed that for small wire mesh diameters (d
w
), the transmitted vortex ring could immediately reform and remain coherent downstream of the wall. Conversely, increasing d
w
led to the generation of smaller subscale structures, which could disrupt the transmitted vortex ring and transition the flow to turbulence. To characterise this variation, they defined an interaction Reynolds number Re
i
= U
c
d
w
$/$
${\phi }{\nu }$
, where U
c
is the convection speed of the upstream vortex ring, and
${\nu }$
is the kinematic viscosity. In an extended work, Hrynuk, Stutz & Bohl (Reference Hrynuk, Stutz and Bohl2018) reported that
${\phi }$
mainly affected the convection speed of the transmitted vortex ring, but did not impact its formation. Thus the interaction Reynolds numbers could be modified as Re
i
= U
c
d
w
$/$
${\nu }$
. Cheng, Lou & Lim (Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014) conducted a numerical simulation of a vortex ring–porous wall interaction across a wide range of parameters. They reported the specific effects of Re,
${\phi }$
, the wire structure dimension, and the wall thickness (H
w
) on the core vorticity, kinetic energy and enstrophy during the interaction. Recently, Jain, Rao & Basu (Reference Jain, Rao and Basu2025) studied the impingement of vortex rings on a porous wall with different included angles. When the included angle was smaller, the incident vortex ring could be split into two halves through the porous wall, which reconfigured the flow with no bias of the upstream vorticity. As the included angle increased, the interaction between the flow from each side intensified, resulting in vorticity cancellation both in the central region and between adjacent jets.
The transport characteristics of fluid represent important aspects in research on vortex ring–porous wall interactions. Naaktgeboren, Krueger & Lage (Reference Naaktgeboren, Krueger and Lage2012) employed particle image velocimetry (PIV) to obtain the impulse (I) and kinetic energy (E) of a vortex ring impinging on a porous wall. The results indicated that the changes between the upstream and downstream values of these quantities,
$\Delta $
I and
$\Delta $
E, depended primarily on
${\phi }$
. In particular, they proposed a model to correlate
$\Delta $
E and
$\Delta $
I by considering the flow deceleration due to the drag force imposed by the porous wall. Li, Xu & Wang (Reference Li, Xu and Wang2020) analysed PIV data of the interaction between successive synthetic-jet vortex rings and a porous wall. They introduced a dimensionless similarity parameter
$Re_j^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
that reflected the combined effects of the jet Reynolds number (
$Re_j$
) and hole diameter (
${d}_{{h}}^*$
). With this similarity parameter, the losses in momentum flux, kinetic energy and vortex circulation could be effectively scaled. In later studies, Xu, Li & Wang (Reference Xu, Li and Wang2021), Sun et al. (Reference Sun, Sun, Fan, Yu, Chen, Kong and Yu2023) and Xu et al. (Reference Xu, Wang, Xu, Li and Wang2025) further improved the similarity parameter by incorporating
${\phi }$
, H
w
and the jet-exit-to-wall distance, respectively. This enabled a more accurate characterisation of the dynamic properties of the vortex ring–porous wall interaction. More recently, Wang, Xu & Wang (Reference Wang, Xu and Wang2025) started from vortex ring characteristics and considered the possible flow transition caused by porous-wall disturbances. They theoretically derived a new model to correlate energy and impulse losses as
$\Delta $
E
* = 1 – k(1 –
$\Delta $
I
*)2, where k is a parameter that depends on the dimensionless core radius. This new model was shown to be applicable to different porous-wall geometries, with significantly improved accuracy compared with the model proposed by Naaktgeboren et al. (Reference Naaktgeboren, Krueger and Lage2012).
In addition to the aforementioned dynamic properties, wall drag also merits attention. This is because the drag is closely related to momentum transfer, energy consumption and structural loading in practical applications of fluid–porous surface interactions. However, in contrast to the case of a free stream that passes through perforated plates (Castro Reference Castro1971; Koo & James Reference Koo and James1973; Graham Reference Graham1976; Steiros & Hultmark Reference Steiros and Hultmark2018), the drag characteristics when vortex rings interact with a porous wall have received less attention. The few existing studies in this area are reviewed as follows. On the basis of numerical simulations, Cheng et al. (Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014) computed the force exerted by a vortex ring on a porous wall using the pressure difference on the upstream and downstream sides of the wall. The results decreased with increasing
${\phi }$
. In fact, the calculated force represented only the pressure drag, which could approximate the total drag when the wall thickness was extremely small. With respect to a finite wall thickness, the contribution of the shear forces generated by the fluid that passes through the holes cannot be disregarded. Xu et al. (Reference Xu, Wang, Feng, He and Wang2018) used PIV data to reconstruct pressure fields, and further estimated the drag of synthetic-jet vortex rings impinging on a porous wall via the control volume method. The drag decreased as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increased. However, considering that the accuracy of PIV-based pressure calculations is sensitive to measurement noise and boundary conditions (Pan et al. Reference Pan, Whitehead, Thomson and Truscott2016; Faiella et al. Reference Faiella, Macmillan, Whitehead and Pan2021), they calculated only the time-averaged pressure, and thus the time-averaged drag. However, the unsteady variation in drag and its relationship with flow structures are not yet fully understood.
In this study, the interaction between a laminar vortex ring and porous walls with varying hole diameters (
$d_{{h}}^* = 0.067-0.20$
) is experimentally investigated using time-resolved planar PIV and laser-induced fluorescence (LIF). A physics-informed neural network (PINN) is employed to reconstruct the pressure fields from the PIV velocity fields, thereby computing the instantaneous drag force of the porous wall during fluid transport. Particular attention is given to understanding the unsteady behaviour of the drag, and clarifying its relationship with the evolution of the vortical structures. A further analysis is conducted on the contributions of different drag components, and a method for estimating the mean drag is proposed. These findings may provide useful guidance for practical applications of vortex–porous wall interactions.
Schematic of the experimental set-up for the PIV measurements.

Figure 1. Long description
The diagram illustrates an experimental setup for particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements. It includes a cubic water tank with dimensions of 600 millimeters, a hollow circular cylinder with a horizontal section of 100 millimeters, and a piston connected to an eccentric disk via a connecting rod. The connecting rod has a length of 300 millimeters. The cap at the end of the hollow circular cylinder of inner diameter D_p has an orifice of diameter D_0. The setup also features a CMOS camera positioned above the water tank to capture images, and a laser sheet that illuminates the flow field. The porous wall placed inside the water tank has specific hole diameter and pitch labeled as d_h and d_p. The diagram shows the interaction between vortex rings and the porous surface, with coordinates x, y, and z marked for reference.
2. Experimental set-up and methodology
2.1. Experimental set-up
The vortex ring–porous wall interaction was studied experimentally in a cubic plexiglass water tank with exterior dimensions 600 mm and wall thickness 20 mm. The vortex ring was generated by a piston–cylinder configuration that consisted of a high-precision servo motor, an eccentric wheel, a connecting rod and a piston, as shown in figure 1. In each experiment, the servo motor drove the eccentric wheel with eccentricity e = 5.5 mm to rotate uniformly at a set frequency f = 0.5 Hz for a duration T, which was equal to half of the excitation period, i.e. T = 1/(2 f) = 1 s. Furthermore, the connecting rod with length l = 300 mm moved from the same initial position, ensuring that the piston maintained a forward stroke within the cylinder and thus attained a semi-sinusoidal velocity programme. The piston velocity can be calculated by taking the derivative of the piston displacement. Under the condition l
$\gg$
e, the piston velocity u
p
can be simplified as
The other end of the cylinder was connected to an L-shaped hollow circular cylinder via a section of rigid rubber tube, which was firmly installed on the water tank by a clamp. The inner diameter of this hollow circular cylinder was equal to the piston diameter D
p
= 29 mm. The horizontal section between the bent section and the jet exit was 100 mm in length, and was 300 mm away from the bottom of the tank. As suggested by Krishna, Gundiah & Arakeri (Reference Krishna, Gundiah and Arakeri2017), a dimensionless transverse distance traversed by the fluid during the semi-sinusoidal pulse
$\hat{{P}}$
can be calculated to reflect the extent of movement of the secondary flow structures produced by the bent section of the L-shaped hollow tube. With the current experimental parameters and geometric parameters of the bent tube, the estimated value of
$\hat{{P}}$
is 0.027, which falls in the regime where no significant secondary flow motion is expected (Krishna et al. Reference Krishna, Gundiah and Arakeri2017). This suggests that the deformation of the bent section has no impact on vortex ring generation. The tube outlet was sealed to a cap with the same outer diameter using waterproof adhesive. The thickness of the cap was 5 mm, and a sharp-edge jet exit with diameter D
0 = 15 mm was located at the cap centre (figure 1). Based on the mass conservation of the incompressible flow, the instantaneous velocity at the exit u
0 can be expressed as
The mean exit velocity during the motion time of the piston U 0 is defined as
Thus U
0 = 41.12 mm s–1. With U
0, the stroke ratio and jet Reynolds number are computed as L
$/$
D
0 = U
0
T
$/$
D
0 = 2.7 and Re = U
0
D
0
$/$
ν = 617, respectively, where ν is the kinematic viscosity of water. A quantification of the repeatability of vortex ring generation using this experimental set-up is provided in Appendix A.
A perforated plate with circular holes was used as the porous wall, as illustrated in figure 1. It was manufactured using a high-precision computer numerical control machine from a square aluminium plate that was subjected to surface oxidation treatment. The side length was 150 mm (10D
0), and the wall thickness was H
w
= 2 mm. It was placed vertically at the centre of the water tank, with the distance between the upstream surface and the jet exit being H
0 = 49 mm (3.3D
0). The porosity
${\phi }$
, which is defined as the ratio of the open area to the total wall area, was fixed at 0.75 by adjusting the values of the hole diameter d
h
and pitch d
p
. In this study, four hole diameters, d
h
= 1, 1.5, 2 and 3 mm, were examined that corresponded to dimensionless values
$d_{{h}}^*=d_{h}/D_0$
= 0.067, 0.10, 0.133 and 0.20, respectively. Moreover, the results of a freely developed vortex ring and a vortex ring impinging on a solid wall were also measured for comparison. The centre of the porous wall was defined as the origin of the coordinates. Cartesian and cylindrical coordinate systems were used according to different analysis requirements. The x-axis was oriented along the streamwise direction, with the y- and z-axes perpendicular to the x-axis, as depicted in figure 1. Additionally, r and θ denoted the radial and azimuthal directions, respectively.
2.2. The PIV and LIF measurements
The upstream and downstream flow fields of the porous wall in the axisymmetric (x–r) plane of the jet exit were measured using time-resolved planar PIV. An 8 W continuous laser produced a 1 mm thick laser sheet that passed through the symmetric axis and illuminated the measured flow fields (figure 1). Hollow glass beads with medium diameter 10 μm and density 1.05 g cm–3 were seeded as tracking particles. A high-speed CMOS camera (Photron Fastcam SA2) equipped with a Nikon lens (AF 105 mm/f2.8) was employed to capture the particle images. The camera resolution was set to 2048 × 960 pixels, with magnification 0.068 mm pixel–1, covering a field range approximately 139 mm × 65 mm (9.3D 0 × 4.3D 0) in the streamwise (x) and radial (r) directions. The sampling frequency was set at 180 Hz so that the maximum particle displacement between two adjacent frames was less than 10 pixels. The velocity vector fields were calculated by a multipass iterative Lucas–Kanade algorithm (Champagnat et al. Reference Champagnat, Plyer, Le Besnerais, Leclaire, Davoust and Le Sant2011). The final size of the interrogation window was set to 32 × 32 pixels with a 75 % overlap, leading to physical scale 2 mm and vector spacing 0.5 mm. With the assumed 0.1 pixel accuracy in the particle displacement, the uncertainty in the instantaneous velocity was less than 2 % of the maximum jet velocity. Furthermore, the uncertainty in the azimuthal vorticity was 0.66 normalised by the mean exit velocity U 0 and the exit diameter D 0 according to the uncertainty propagation method of Sciacchitano & Wieneke (Reference Sciacchitano and Wieneke2016).
The evolution of the downstream flow fields in the cross-sectional (y–z) planes was measured using time-resolved planar LIF at x
$/$
D
0 = 0.67, 1.33 and 3.33. Rhodamine 6G was used as the fluorescent dye, and the sampling frequency was set at 100 Hz. In particular, the flow information in the cross-sectional plane has rarely been analysed in previous studies on vortex ring–porous wall interactions. The results of the current study can therefore contribute to a better understanding of the formation and development of transmitted vortex rings. Note that in this study, the LIF/PIV measurements were conducted solely for the interaction between a single vortex ring and the wall to reveal the instantaneous vortex dynamics.
3. Results and discussion
In this section, the flow and drag characteristics of the vortex ring–porous wall interaction are analysed in detail, with the specific organisation as follows. The evolution of the flow structures in the axisymmetric and cross-sectional planes is depicted in §§ 3.1 and 3.2. The characteristics of the PINN-reconstructed pressure field are presented in § 3.3. The relationship between the instantaneous drag and the flow structures is discussed in § 3.4, and a further analysis of the mean drag is provided in § 3.5.
3.1. Flow evolution in the axisymmetric plane
The evolution of the flow structures visualised by the finite-time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE) for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, 0.10, 0.133 and 0.20 is shown in figure 2. It is widely known that the FTLE method can be used to identify Lagrangian coherent structures (LCS) in complex flows (Haller & Yuan Reference Haller and Yuan2000; Shadden, Lekien & Marsden Reference Shadden, Lekien and Marsden2005; Shadden et al. Reference Shadden, Katija, Rosenfeld, Marsden and Dabiri2007; Haller Reference Haller2015). In this study, the backward-time FTLE field, in which the local maximum represents the attracting LCS, is computed using the PIV velocity fields. The integration time is set to –4.0 s, which is equal to four times the piston movement period. This integration time is sufficient to identify the vortex boundaries in both the upstream and downstream regions while considering acceptable computational expenses. The original data grid is refined via bilinear interpolation to resolution 0.1 mm × 0.1 mm. A fourth-order Runge–Kutta scheme with time step 1/180 s is employed for numerical integration. Additionally, the contours of the azimuthal vorticity
${\omega }_{\theta }$
D
0
$/$
U
0 are superimposed on the FTLE field for reference. Here, and throughout the paper, the initial time t = 0 corresponds to the moment when the core of the primary vortex ring reaches the streamwise position x
$/$
D
0 = -2.
Temporal evolution of the FTLE field superimposed by the contours of azimuthal vorticity
${\omega }_{\theta }$
D
0
$/$
U
0 for
${d}_{{h}}^*=$
(a) 0.067, (b) 0.10, (c) 0.133 and (d) 0.20, at tU
0
$/$
D
0= 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 7.0 and 9.5. The solid and dashed lines represent regions of positive and negative vorticity, respectively. The contour levels are in the range |
${\omega }_{\theta }$
D
0
$/$
U
0| = 1–10, with interval 1.5. See supplementary movies 1–4.

Figure 2. Long description
The image contains a series of graphs showing the temporal evolution of the FTLE field superimposed by the contours of azimuthal vorticity. The graphs are organized in a grid with four columns and six rows, each representing different values of d_h^* and tU_0/D_0. The solid and dashed lines represent regions of positive and negative vorticity, respectively. The contour levels range from 1–10 with an interval of 1.5. The graphs illustrate the interaction between vortex rings and porous surfaces, highlighting the complexity of flow characteristics and underlying mechanisms.
At tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 2.0, on the upstream side of the porous wall, a fully developed primary vortex ring is observed that convects towards the porous wall. On the downstream side, the transmission of a small amount of vorticity can be detected near the wall for a larger hole diameter
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20 (figure 2
d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 2.0$
). When the primary vortex ring approaches the porous wall, the upstream shear layer grows in strength, and more vorticity is transmitted to the downstream flow field for the cases
${d}_{{h}}^* = 0.10-0.20$
(figures 2
b–d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 3.0$
). After impingement, the primary vortex ring spreads radially along the wall, causing the shear layer to separate and form a secondary vortex ring, which subsequently pairs with the primary vortex ring. The upstream flow patterns are quite similar across all
${d}_{{h}}$
* cases (figures 2
a–d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 4.0$
and 5.0).
However, because of the effect of the hole diameter, distinct differences can be observed downstream of the wall. For the smallest diameter
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, very few LCS and vorticity emerge downstream because less fluid passes through the porous wall (figures 2
a,
$tU_0/D_0 = 4.0$
and 5.0). As
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, more fluid of the incident vortex ring can penetrate the porous wall in the form of jet-like structures, as reported in previous studies (Hrynuk et al. Reference Hrynuk, Van Luipen and Bohl2012; Naaktgeboren et al. Reference Naaktgeboren, Krueger and Lage2012; Xu et al. Reference Xu, Wang, Feng, He and Wang2018; Jain et al. Reference Jain, Rao and Basu2025). For the cases
${d}_{{h}}^* = 0.10$
and 0.133, these jet structures can interact with each other through vorticity cancellation at the early stages of emerging out, resulting in a continuous front of the LCS and the outer vorticity concentration (figures 2
b,c,
$tU_0/D_0 = 4.0$
and 5.0). In contrast, for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20, these jets still maintain a distribution of alternating positive and negative vorticity (figure 2
d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 4.0$
), and the LCS exhibit a finger-type flow pattern (figure 2
d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 5.0$
). This flow pattern arises because increasing the hole diameter enlarges the distance between jet structures generated from two adjacent holes, leading to a greater difference in their strengths. In this case, the process of vorticity cancellation is delayed, which further affects the redistribution of vorticity.
As the flow evolves to tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 7.0 and 9.5, the secondary vortex ring gets entrained by the primary vortex ring towards the interior. With an increase in
${d}_{{h}}^*$
, the interaction weakens, as reflected by the relative positions of their LCS. Moreover, the radial spreading of the primary vortex ring decreases. With a larger spreading distance, the primary vortex ring for the
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067 case even causes the shear layer to separate again, leading to the formation of a tertiary vortex ring. On the downstream side, when
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, the LCS develop relatively slowly and are distributed mainly in the vicinity of the wall (figure 2
a,
$tU_0/D_0 = 9.5$
). When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10 and 0.133, the continuous front of the LCS can roll up and form a highly coherent transmitted vortex ring, as shown in figures 2(b,c,
$tU_0/D_0 = 9.5$
). For the largest diameter
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20, the branches of the finger-type LCS also roll up and interact with each other, tending to form a large-scale vortex ring. However, because of insufficient vorticity cancellation in the early stage of the interaction as depicted above, the coherence of the transmitted vortex ring is reduced compared with that in the cases
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10 and 0.133 (figure 2
d,
$tU_0/D_0 = 9.5$
).
The flow evolution can be further quantified based on the vortex centre trajectory and vortex circulation. The streamwise and radial positions (x
c
, r
c
) of the vortex and circulation
${\varGamma }$
are calculated as follows (Musta & Krueger Reference Musta and Krueger2014):
where
${\varOmega }$
denotes the vortical region for integration. The vortices are identified by applying the Q-criterion (Hunt, Wray & Moin Reference Hunt, Wray and Moin1988) with threshold Q > 0, which can retain most of the vorticity within the vortical region while eliminating the background noise in the measured data.
Figure 3 depicts the evolution of the trajectories of the primary (PVR), secondary (SVR) and transmitted (TVR) vortex rings. The results for the free vortex ring and solid-wall cases are also provided in each plot for comparison. For both porous and solid walls, the PVR experiences a re-impact after the initial rebound from the wall. Compared with the solid-wall case, as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, more fluid can penetrate the porous wall, reducing the spreading distance of the PVR, and enabling it to approach closer to the wall. Additionally, the trajectory of the SVR surrounding the PVR becomes shorter due to changes in their strengths, which is explained in more detail later. On the downstream side, the TVR trajectory can be detected in all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases. For
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, the TVR cannot effectively convect downstream because of its significantly lower vortex strength. However, based on the free case results, the radial position of the TVR remains similar to that of the PVR during the convection stage, irrespective of the effect of
${d}_{{h}}^*$
on vorticity transmission. This is consistent with the observations in previous studies with similar porosities (
${\phi }$
= 0.64–0.79) (Hrynuk et al. Reference Hrynuk, Van Luipen and Bohl2012; Naaktgeboren et al. Reference Naaktgeboren, Krueger and Lage2012; Xu et al. Reference Xu, Wang, Feng, He and Wang2018).
Trajectories of the primary vortex ring (PVR), secondary vortex ring (SVR) and transmitted vortex ring (TVR) for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= (a) 0.067, (b) 0.10, (c) 0.133 and (d) 0.20. The results for the free vortex ring and solid wall cases are provided for comparison.

Figure 3. Long description
The image contains four graphs labeled (a), (b), (c), and (d), each depicting the trajectories of primary vortex rings (PVR), secondary vortex rings (SVR), and transmitted vortex rings (TVR) for different hole diameters. The graphs compare these trajectories with those of free vortex rings and solid wall cases. Each graph has a vertical axis labeled r/D_0 and a horizontal axis labeled x/D_0. The trajectories are marked with different symbols: circles for PVR, squares for SVR, and diamonds for TVR. The solid line represents the solid wall case, while the dashed line represents the free vortex ring case. The graphs illustrate how the vortex rings behave under varying conditions, providing insights into fluid flow characteristics.
Temporal evolution of (a) circulation of the PVR
${\varGamma }$
PVR
$/$
${\varGamma }$
0, (b) circulation of the TVR
${\varGamma }$
TVR
$/$
${\varGamma }$
0, and peak vorticity of the SVR
${\omega }_{{\theta}{\kern-1pt p,\textit{SVR}}}D_0/U_0$
for the porous and solid wall cases. The red and blue shaded regions represent the strong and weak vortex–wall interaction stages, respectively.

Figure 4. Long description
The image contains two line graphs. The first graph on the left shows the temporal evolution of the circulation of the PVR for different hole diameters. The x-axis represents the dimensionless time tU_0/D_0, and the y-axis represents the normalized circulation Γ_PVR/Γ_0. The graph includes multiple lines representing different hole diameters, with a red shaded region indicating the strong vortex-wall interaction stage and a blue shaded region indicating the weak vortex-wall interaction stage. The second graph on the right shows the temporal evolution of the circulation of the TVR and the peak vorticity of the SVR for different hole diameters. The x-axis represents the dimensionless time tU_0/D_0, and the y-axis on the left represents the normalized circulation Γ_TVR/Γ_0, while the y-axis on the right represents the normalized peak vorticity ω_0,SVR D_0/U_0. The graph includes multiple lines representing different hole diameters, with a red shaded region indicating the strong vortex-wall interaction stage and a blue shaded region indicating the weak vortex-wall interaction stage. An inset in the second graph provides a zoomed-in view of the peak vorticity data.
The circulations of the PVR and TVR, and the peak vorticity in the SVR core, are presented in figure 4. The results represent the average values of those in the upper and lower half-planes of the symmetric axis, and
${\varGamma }$
0 is the PVR circulation at the initial moment. The error bars represent the uncertainty caused by the differences between the two half-plane values. For all the cases, the uncertainty in the circulation is no more than 4 % of
${\varGamma }$
0, and the uncertainty in the peak vorticity is less than 0.5 normalised by U
0 and D
0. As shown in figure 4(a), during the initial convection towards the wall, the PVR circulation essentially shows little variation in all the cases. When the PVR interacts with the wall, its circulation begins to decline sharply, and the corresponding moment is defined as the start of the vortex–wall interaction, t
s
. This decrease in the circulation is attributed to vorticity cancellation resulting from the interaction between the PVR and the shear layer, as well as to vorticity transmission that occurs in the porous-wall case. Decay can be more rapid for a larger
${d}_{{h}}^*$
due to higher vorticity transmission, leading to the lower strength of the PVR. Subsequently, the circulation declines relatively slowly, with a similar decay rate for all the cases. Based on the rates of change of the circulation, the interaction of the PVR with the porous wall can be divided into two stages: the strong vortex–wall interaction stage, featuring intense PVR–wall collision and significant vorticity transmission; and the weak vortex–wall interaction stage, featuring slow spreading of PVR and moderate vorticity transmission, as indicated in figure 4(a) by the red and blue shaded regions, respectively. For the sake of brevity, these two stages are hereinafter referred to as the strong-interaction and weak-interaction stages.
Figure 4(b) shows that during the strong-interaction stage, both the SVR and the TVR grow in strength over time. The growth of the SVR is influenced by both the PVR–wall interaction and the extent of vorticity transmission. For the solid-wall case, the peak vorticity of the SVR reaches its maximum earlier than that for the porous-wall case (see the inset in figure 4
b). This occurs because the PVR ends its intense interaction with the wall more rapidly, as observed in figure 4(a). For the porous-wall case, with an increase in
${d}_{{h}}^*$
, enhanced vorticity transmission significantly reduces vorticity of the wall shear layer, resulting in a weaker SVR. In this case, the mutual interaction between the PVR and SVR weakens, causing the SVR to orbit the PVR more slowly, thereby shortening its trajectory, as depicted in figure 3. Furthermore, as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, the formed TVR can be stronger due to higher vorticity transmission. The TVR circulation subsequently stabilises at approximately a constant value, which can be estimated from the local mean values, as indicated by the black dashed lines in figure 4(b).
(a) The LIF sequence images in the y–z plane sampled at x
$/$
D
0 = 0.67 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10. See supplementary movie 5. (b) Streamwise trajectories of the TVR for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10, 0.133 and 0.20. (c) The front and back views of the 3-D structures constructed from the LIF sequence images for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10. The flow structures are visualised by the isosurfaces of the image intensity equal to 10 % of the maximum value.

Figure 5. Long description
The image contains three sequence images in the y-z plane sampled at x/D_0 equals 0.67 for a specific hole diameter. These images show the evolution of fluid flow structures over time. Additionally, there are two 3-D structures constructed from the LIF sequence images for the same hole diameter. The front and back views of these structures are displayed, highlighting the flow characteristics visualized by the isosurfaces of the image intensity equal to 10 percent of the maximum value. The flow structures are complex and exhibit petal-shaped pattern.
3.2. Three-dimensional structure construction of the TVR
The formation and evolution of the TVR can also be depicted from the flow information in the y–z planes at different stations. The LIF sequence images in the y–z plane at x
$/$
D
0 = 0.67 for the
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10 case are shown in figure 5(a). The results indicate that at the same station, the transmitted structures exhibit different flow patterns over time, including scattered spots (tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 5.48), petal-shaped structures that are densely distributed along the azimuthal direction (tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 6.85), and subsequent contraction along the radial direction (tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 8.22 and 9.59). To gain a better understanding of the three-dimensional (3-D) characteristics of the TVR, the Taylor hypothesis is applied here to convert the temporal measurements of the LIF images into a spatial region, thus approximately constructing the 3-D topology structures. Similar applications were performed by Toyoda & Mori (Reference Toyoda and Mori2001) when the 3-D jet boundary surface and streamwise vortices were constructed. Specifically, the time coordinate is converted into the streamwise position by multiplying it by the local convective velocity of the vortex core.
The 3-D structures constructed by the LIF sequence images sampled at x
$/$
D
0 = (a,d) 0.67, (b,e) 1.33 and (c, f) 3.33 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= (a–c) 0.133 and (d–f) 0.20. The flow structures are visualised by the isosurfaces of the image intensity equal to 10 % of the maximum value. See supplementary movies 6–9.

Figure 6. Long description
The image displays 3-D structures of fluid flow visualised by the isosurfaces of image intensity equal to 10 percent of the maximum value. These structures are sampled at different x/D_0 values: 0.67, 1.33, and 3.33. The flow characteristics are shown for two different values of the hole diameter: 0.133 and 0.20. The visualisation highlights the complex interaction between vortex rings and porous surfaces, which is a key area of research in fluid dynamics.
As shown in figure 5(b), for the cases
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10, 0.133 and 0.20, which generate a well-coherent TVR, the streamwise trajectories increase approximately linearly over time. Thus within the examined range, convection speed U
c
is regarded as constant and can be estimated from the slope of the corresponding fitting lines, as indicated by the dashed lines in figure 5(b). Figure 5(c) shows the front and back views of the constructed 3-D structures visualised by the isosurfaces of the image intensity equal to 10 % of the maximum value. The results show that the initial structures are wrapped layer-by-layer along the azimuthal direction by numerous rolled-up petal-shaped structures that resemble a flower disc overall.
To reflect the effect of
${d}_{{h}}^*$
, figure 6 depicts the 3-D structures constructed by the LIF sequence images at x
$/$
D
0 = 0.67, 1.33 and 3.33 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133 and 0.20. When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133, compared with the case
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10, the number of petal-shaped structures decreases as the scale increases (figure 6
a). As the flow develops and the dye diffuses, these petal-shaped structures rapidly merge with each other, evolving into a large-scale and coherent TVR (figure 6
b). During downstream convection, the TVR can further grow through the entrainment of the dye (figure 6
c). When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases to 0.20, the scale of the petal-shaped structures further expands. From x
$/$
D
0 = 0.67–1.33 (figures 6
d,e), outer petal-shaped structures merge with the ring that they wrap. Moreover, the ring is wrapped by six larger petal-shaped structures that were previously closer to the centre. Therefore, compared with the case
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133, the merging of these petal-shaped structures appears to be slower, which is consistent with the insufficient vorticity cancellation for this case, as depicted in figure 2. Consequently, the formed TVR at a further downstream position x
$/$
D
0 = 3.33 becomes relatively less coherent and non-uniform along the azimuthal direction (figure 6
f).
Notably, the current 3-D structures constructed based on the passive scalar of the dye may differ significantly from the vorticity surfaces obtained from the 3-D flow field measurements. However, such results can more clearly display the details of the flow structures at a relatively low experimental cost. Additionally, the results enhance the understanding of the 3-D characteristics reflected by the flow information in the cross-sectional planes. This is because it is rather difficult to understand them merely from the temporal evolution of the planar images in figure 5(a).
3.3. The PINN-based pressure reconstruction
After the flow evolution characteristics are analysed, the drag force of the porous wall is calculated. In this study, the drag is evaluated based on the control volume method. Before the integral momentum equation is solved, it is crucial to obtain the instantaneous pressure. Recently, the PINN (Raissi, Perdikaris & Karniadakis Reference Raissi, Perdikaris and Karniadakis2019), as a data assimilation method that integrates physical laws with observations, has attracted widespread attention in the experimental fluid mechanics community. It has performed well in augmenting sparse experimental data, removing spurious noise, and predicting unmeasured flow information and variables (Cai et al. Reference Cai, Wang, Fuest, Jeon, Gray and Karniadakis2021; Wang, Liu & Wang Reference Wang, Liu and Wang2022; Fan et al. Reference Fan, Xu, Wang and Wang2023; Lai, Liu & Wen Reference Lai, Liu and Wen2024; Zhu et al. Reference Zhu, Jiang, Lefauve, Kerswell and Linden2024). In terms of predicting pressure from velocity data, Fan et al. (Reference Fan, Xu, Wang and Wang2023) compared the performance of the PINN with that of traditional pressure reconstruction methods that solve the Poisson equation or integrate the pressure gradient (Dabiri et al. Reference Dabiri, Bose, Gemmell, Colin and Costello2014; Ahmed & Erath Reference Ahmed and Erath2025). The results indicated that PINN-based pressure reconstruction can achieve higher accuracy even when the velocity data have poor quality and are significantly contaminated by measurement noise. Therefore, the PINN is employed here to reconstruct the pressure fields from the PIV-measured velocity fields.
The main parameter information for PINN training is provided as follows. For a detailed introduction to the PINN algorithm, one can refer to the works of Wang et al. (Reference Wang, Liu and Wang2022) and Fan et al. (Reference Fan, Xu, Wang and Wang2023). Considering that the present flow can be regarded as axisymmetric, the two-dimensional (2-D) incompressible Navier–Stokes equations in cylindrical coordinates are used as the physical constraint for the loss function of the PINN. Furthermore, the results of Gan, Dawson & Nickels (Reference Gan, Dawson and Nickels2012) demonstrated that even for a turbulent vortex ring, the contribution was much less for the azimuthal velocity component than for the in-plane components. Therefore, the current planar PIV data can be used to provide a reasonable estimation of the pressure fields for a laminar vortex ring.
The instantaneous data of 700 snapshots starting from the initial moment are used as the input velocity of the PINN. This period can last until the late stage of the vortex–wall interactions, at which time the wall drag tends to zero (as is indicated later). The input velocity of the PINN simultaneously covers both the upstream and downstream regions of the porous wall, within the range |x
$/$
D
0| ≤ 2 and |r
$/$
D
0| ≤ 2.1. This can guarantee that the reconstructed upstream and downstream pressure fields share the same reference pressure. Furthermore, for the current porous-wall configuration where reliable boundary conditions cannot be specified accurately, the data in the near-wall region located within 2 mm (equal to the scale of the PIV interrogation window) from the porous wall are excluded, which ensures the data reliability for PINN training. The loss function of PINN therefore comprises the data loss and the residual of the Navier–Stokes equations, without explicitly imposing boundary condition constraints. The PINN has been previously demonstrated to recover accurate velocity and pressure fields from sparse measurements even when boundary conditions are partially or completely unknown (Arzani, Wang & D’Souza Reference Arzani, Wang and D’Souza2021; Mai et al. Reference Mai, Li, Long, Huang, Zhang and You2024; Soibam et al. Reference Soibam, Aslanidou, Kyprianidis and Fdhila2024). The neural network contains 14 layers with 128 neurons in each layer, and is trained using 2 × 106 data points and 2 × 106 equation points. The initial learning rate is set to 1 × 10−3 with a stepwise exponential decay. The training is stopped after 3 × 104 epochs when the loss is reduced to less than 10–3. Based on the trained network, the reconstructed velocity and pressure results are extracted over the same domain and spatial resolution as the input data. Because the ground truth pressure is unknown, the spatially averaged pressure at each time instant is subtracted from the reconstructed pressure results to enable comparative analysis across different cases and to reduce the uncertainty caused by the choice of the reference pressure (Fan et al. Reference Fan, Xu, Wang and Wang2023; Wang & Liu Reference Wang and Liu2023; Wang et al. Reference Wang, Wu, Liu, He, Feng and Wang2025).
To validate the PINN predictions, figure 7 presents a comparison of the azimuthal vorticity fields and vorticity profiles across the vortex cores obtained from PIV and the PINN, as exemplified by the case
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133. Two instants at t
${U}_{0}$
$/$
D
0 = 2 and 5 are selected that correspond to the convection of the PVR before impingement and the formation of the TVR, respectively. The PINN results exhibit high agreement with the PIV results both qualitatively and quantitatively. Additionally, compared with the raw data, the PINN results have a better convergence of vorticity profiles at larger radial positions because the measurement noise is effectively reduced.
Comparisons of (a,c) the azimuthal vorticity fields and (b,d) vorticity profiles across the vortex centres of the PVR and TVR (dashed black lines) obtained from PIV and the PINN at
$tU_0/D_0$
= (a,b) 2 and (c,d) 5 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133.

Figure 7. Long description
The image contains four subplots comparing azimuthal vorticity fields and vorticity profiles across vortex centers obtained from Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) and Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINN) at different time values. Subplots (a) and (c) display the azimuthal vorticity fields at dimensionless time equals 2 and 5, respectively, with PIV results on the left and PINN results on the right. Subplots (b) and (d) show the vorticity profiles across the vortex centers at the same time values, with PIV data represented by black circles and PINN data by red lines. The vorticity fields are color-coded, with blue indicating negative values and red indicating positive values. The vorticity profiles illustrate the variation in vorticity across the vortex centers, highlighting differences and similarities between the PIV and PINN methods.
Figure 8 shows the evolution of the azimuthal vorticity field, which is superimposed by the pressure contours for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133. In the upstream field, after the formation of the PVR, a leading pressure maximum, a pressure minimum and a trailing pressure maximum develop on the symmetric axis along the streamwise direction, as has been observed for a steady, axisymmetric vortex ring (Lawson & Dawson Reference Lawson and Dawson2013). When the PVR approaches the wall, the pressure near the wall increases significantly. Moreover, part of the fluid penetrates the porous wall, leading to the generation of a positive pressure region downstream of the wall (figure 8
a). As the PVR interacts with the wall, the negative pressure region moves along with the cores. Outside the cores, the shear layer separates under the adverse pressure gradient and causes the local negative pressure to expand outwards. Furthermore, the positive pressure region behind the ring can merge with that near the wall (figures 8
b,c). In the downstream field, following the initial positive pressure, distinct negative pressure develops across the radial range because of the increase in transmitted vorticity (figure 8
c). During the subsequent vortex–wall interaction, the upstream positive and negative pressure regions decrease (figures 8
d,e), which can be attributed to the flow deceleration and decay of the vortex strength. The overall pressure characteristics are similar to those of vortex rings impacting a solid wall (Cheng et al. Reference Cheng, Lou and Luo2010; Ahmed & Erath Reference Ahmed and Erath2025). Additionally, the pressure distribution of the TVR resembles that of the evolution of a free vortex ring (figures 8
d–f).
Temporal evolution of the azimuthal vorticity field superimposed by the contours of pressure p
$/$
${\rho }{{U}}_{0}^{2}$
reconstructed by the PINN at
$tU_0/D_0$
= (a) 2, (b) 2.75, (c) 3.5, (d) 4.25, (e) 5 and (f) 6.5 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133. The solid and dashed lines represent regions of positive and negative pressures, respectively. The contour levels are in the range |p
$/$
${\rho }{{U}}_{0}^{2}$
| = 0–0.1 with interval 0.01. See supplementary movie 10.

Figure 8. Long description
Six graphs illustrate the temporal evolution of the azimuthal vorticity field superimposed by the contours of pressure reconstructed by the PINN at different time values. The graphs are labeled (a) through (f) and represent dimensionless time equals 2, 2.75, 3.5, 4.25, 5, and 6.5 respectively. The solid lines indicate regions of positive pressure, while the dashed lines represent regions of negative pressure. The contour levels range from 0 to 0.1 with an interval of 0.01. The x-axis represents the streamwise direction (x/D_0) and the y-axis represents the radial direction (r/D_0). The graphs show the variations of vorticity and pressure over time, highlighting the dynamic changes in the flow field.
A quantitative description of the pressure variation is presented in figure 9 by tracking the near-wall pressures at x
$/$
D
0 = ±0.13, r
$/$
D
0 = 0, and the minimum pressure in the PVR core regions. The subscripts up and do denote the quantities in the upstream and downstream fields, respectively. The average values of the minimum pressure above and below the symmetric axis are used in figure 9(b), where the uncertainty is less than 0.02 normalised by
${\rho }{{U}}_{0}^{2}$
for all tested cases. The results suggest that during PVR convection towards the wall, the upstream near-wall pressure can increase rapidly after approximately t
${U}_{0}$
$/$
D
0 = 1.5 (figure 9
a). As expected, the solid-wall case exhibits the fastest pressure growth. For the porous-wall case, as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
decreases, the growth rate increases because of the faster flow deceleration, whereas the opposite occurs in the downstream situation because of the reduced fluid penetration. In the strong-interaction stage, both the upstream and downstream pressures decline rapidly after reaching their maximum values. This is followed by pressure recovery in the weak-interaction stage, which gradually becomes similar across all the cases. The core pressure of the PVR continuously increases, with distinct growth rates during the strong- and weak-interaction stages (figure 9
b). Moreover, the effects of the wall configuration and hole diameter on the pressure growth directly correlate with the reduction in the PVR circulation, as depicted in figure 4(a).
Temporal evolution of: (a) upstream and downstream near-wall pressures p
up
and p
do
at x
$/$
D
0 = ±0.13, r
$/$
D
0 = 0; (b) minimum pressure in the PVR core regions p
c
for the porous- and solid-wall cases.

Figure 9. Long description
The image contains two line graphs. The first graph (a) shows the temporal evolution of upstream and downstream near-wall pressures at a specific location. Different markers and colors represent various porous wall cases with different hole diameters. The second graph (b) illustrates the minimum pressure in the PVR core regions for both porous and solid wall cases. The x-axis in both graphs represents normalized time, while the y-axis represents normalized pressure. The graphs highlight the interaction between vortex rings and porous surfaces, showing how pressure changes over time for different hole diameters.
3.4. Relationship between the drag and flow structures
The unsteady drag force of the porous wall can now be estimated from the PINN-reconstructed velocity and pressure fields. For control volume V delimited by control surface S that includes the object under investigation, the integral momentum equation for incompressible flow can be expressed as follows (Kurtulus, Scarano & David Reference Kurtulus, Scarano and David2007; Xu et al. Reference Xu, Wang, Feng, He and Wang2018):
where
F
is the force vector,
${\rho }$
is the fluid density,
u
is the velocity vector,
n
is the unit normal vector, and
$\boldsymbol{\tau }$
is the viscous stress tensor. For the present axisymmetric flow, a cylindrical control volume across the porous wall is employed. The radial range of the control volume is the same as that of the pressure reconstruction domain, as denoted by the solid red frame in figure 10(a). Note that the streamwise range of the control volume in the upstream and downstream fields varies synchronously. The distance between the front or rear surface of the control volume and the porous-plate axis, L
V
, ranges from 2 mm (0.13D
0) to the boundary of the pressure reconstruction domain 2D
0.
(a) Schematics of the pressure reconstruction domain (solid red frame) and the control volume (dashed black frame) across the porous wall. (b) Variations in the wall drag F
D
$/$
${\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
calculated using different control volume sizes for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10.

Figure 10. Long description
The image contains two parts. Part (a) shows a schematic diagram of the pressure reconstruction domain and the control volume across a porous wall. The control volume is outlined with a dashed black frame, while the pressure reconstruction domain is outlined with a solid red frame. The diagram includes labels for various components such as the vortex ring, upstream, downstream, and the porous wall. Part (b) presents a graph depicting the variations in the wall drag (F_D) calculated using different control volume sizes for a specific value of the hole diameter. The x-axis of the graph represents the dimensionless time (tU_0/D_0), and the y-axis represents the dimensionless wall drag (F_D/ρΓ_0^²). The graph includes multiple data series, each represented by different symbols and colors, corresponding to different control volume sizes (L_V). The data series show how the wall drag varies over time for each control volume size.
Additionally, considering that vortex rings possess a weak azimuthal velocity (Maxworthy Reference Maxworthy1977; Gan et al. Reference Gan, Dawson and Nickels2012), the azimuthal component in (3.3) can be reasonably disregarded for the case of a laminar vortex ring. Thus the expression of (3.3) along the streamwise direction can be simplified as
\begin{align}{{{F}}_{{D}}}&=-{\rho }\iiint _{{V}}\frac{{\partial }{u}}{{\partial }{t}}\,{{\rm d}V}-\rho\iint_{{S}} {{u(u_rn_r + un_x)\,{\rm d}S}} \nonumber \\&\quad -\iint_{{S}} {{pn_x\,{\rm d}S}}+\iint _{{S}} \left(2\mu\frac{\partial {{u}}}{\partial {{x}}}n_x + \mu \! \left(\frac{\partial u}{\partial r}+\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial x}\right)n_r\right){\rm d}S,\end{align}
where
${F}_{{D}}$
denotes the drag force,
${\mu }$
denotes the fluid dynamic viscosity, and the subscripts x and r denote the quantities along the streamwise and radial directions, respectively. On the right-hand side of (3.4), the first term indicates the unsteady momentum variation, the second term indicates the momentum convection flux, and the third and fourth terms indicate the contributions of the pressure and the viscous stress, respectively (Kurtulus et al. Reference Kurtulus, Scarano and David2007). The instantaneous values of all of these terms can be derived from the velocity and pressure data. The drag forces calculated using different control volume sizes for the case
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10 are compared in figure 10(b). The results indicate that the drag magnitude is essentially unaffected by the control volume size L
V
, although slight differences exist across different control volume sizes. The differences mainly originate from the uncertainty in the reconstructed velocity and pressure fields. Overall, these results validate the reliability of the calculation method, and demonstrate that the reconstructed fields by PINN satisfy the underlying physics despite the absence of explicit boundary conditions.
Figure 11 shows the temporal evolution of the wall drag for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases, and the results of the free case are also provided for comparison. The results are the average values computed from the data above and below the symmetric axis to reduce the influence of the relative asymmetry. The error bars represent the uncertainty that incorporates: (i) uncertainty in the reconstructed velocity and pressure fields; (ii) uncertainty resulting from the differences between the two half-plane values; and (iii) uncertainty related to the calculation method. For all investigated cases, the first two uncertainties are no more than 0.02 normalised by
${\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
, respectively. The third uncertainty can be estimated from the deviation between the mean value of the calculated results and the theoretical value for the free case, as depicted later. Furthermore, for the solid wall case, the drag cannot be calculated because the pressure downstream of the wall is not available based on the current data. Therefore, this case is not presented here. One can refer to the force results for a solid-wall case reported by Cheng et al. (Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014) via numerical simulation. Theoretically, for a free vortex ring, the drag should be zero, as no object interacts with the vortex ring within the control volume. As shown in figure 11, although the calculated drag for the free case is not exactly zero, the magnitude is very small, with mean value approximately –0.005, as indicated by the dashed black line. These findings support the reasonable accuracy and reliability of the data and method used in this study.
Temporal evolution of the wall drag
$F_D/{\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases. The results of the free case are provided for comparison.

Figure 11. Long description
The line graph displays the temporal evolution of the wall drag F_D over time for various cases. The x-axis represents the dimensionless time tU_0/D_0, ranging from 0 to 10. The y-axis represents the dimensionless wall drag F_D/ρΓ_0^², ranging from −0.05 to 0.25. The graph includes five data series, each represented by different symbols and colors: blue squares for d_h^* equals 0.067, orange triangles for d_h^* equals 0.10, yellow inverted triangles for d_h^* equals 0.133, green diamonds for d_h^* equals 0.20, and black circles for the free case. The data series show varying trends in wall drag over time, with the free case remaining close to zero throughout. The other cases exhibit peaks and subsequent declines in wall drag, with the highest peak observed for d_h^* equals 0.067. The graph is divided into three shaded regions: a red region from approximately tU_0/D_0 equals 2.8 to 4.4, a blue region from approximately tU_0/D_0 equals 4.4 to 10, and a white region from tU_0/D_0 equals 0 to 2.8.
Temporal evolution of the total drag F
D
$/$
${\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
, momentum convection flux term Term
m
$/$
${\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
and pressure term Term
p
$/$
${\rho }{{\varGamma }}_{0}^{2}$
calculated with the control volume size L
V
= 0.13D
0 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= (a) 0.067, (b) 0.133 and (c) 0.20.

Figure 12. Long description
The image contains three line graphs labeled (a), (b), and (c), each showing the temporal evolution of the total drag (F_D), momentum convection flux term (Term_m), and pressure term (Term_p) calculated with the control volume size L_V = 0.13D_0. Graph (a) represents values of 0.067, graph (b) represents values of 0.133, and graph (c) represents values of 0.20. Each graph has a horizontal axis labeled tU_0/D_0 and a vertical axis labeled F_D/ρΓ_0^2. The graphs show how these parameters evolve over time, with distinct lines for each term. The data points are marked with different symbols for each term, and the graphs are color-coded: blue for (a), orange for (b), and green for (c). The dashed lines indicate different time instants labeled t_1, t_2, and t_3. The graphs illustrate the interaction between vortex rings and porous surfaces, highlighting the complex flow characteristics and underlying mechanisms.
In the case of the porous wall, the drag shows significant temporal variations. The drag rapidly increases before the onset of the PVR–wall interaction. This is primarily ascribed to the sharp rise in the near-wall pressure during the PVR convection towards the wall, as depicted in figure 9(a). Generally, the drag magnitude decreases as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases. In the strong-interaction stage, the drag can reach the maximum value and then decrease. Notably, when
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20, unlike in the other cases, the drag experiences a secondary increase before it reaches the maximum value. It should be noted that this secondary increase is not caused by the PVR re-impact after initial rebounding, which occurs when the vortex ring interacts with a solid wall or low-porosity porous walls (Cheng et al. Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014). This is because this study adopts a high porosity (
${\phi }$
= 0.75), and a detailed explanation of this behaviour is provided later. Furthermore, the variation trends and magnitudes for the cases
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067–0.133 are also similar to those in Cheng et al. (Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014), with
${\phi }$
= 0.6–0.8. In the weak-interaction stage, the drag follows a similar decay behaviour for all the
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases, although the strengths of the PVR and TVR are distinctly different.
To further elucidate the unsteady behaviour of the drag and its correlation with the flow structures, figure 12 analyses the contributions of the momentum convection flux term and pressure term in (3.4) to the total drag for the cases
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, 0.133 and 0.20. The results are calculated using the control volume size closest to the wall, i.e. L
V
= 0.13D
0, whose unsteady and viscous stress terms are relatively small and can thus be neglected. The near-wall flow structures at three selected moments t
1–t
3 in figure 12, which cover the strong- and weak-interaction stages, are presented in figure 13. The profiles of the differences in streamwise momentum transfers
$\Delta$
u
2
$/$
${{U}}_{0}^{2}$
and pressures
$\Delta$
p
$/$
${\rho }{{U}}_{0}^{2}$
on the upstream and downstream sides of the control volume are also provided.
Contours of the near-wall azimuthal vorticity field and the profiles of the differences in streamwise momentum transfers
$\Delta$
u
2
$/$
${{U}}_{0}^{2}$
(red) and pressures
$\Delta$
p
$/$
${\rho }{{U}}_{0}^{2}$
(blue) at the upstream and downstream sides of the control volume size L
V
= 0.13D
0 at
$tU_0/D_0$
= (a,d,g) t
1, (b,e,h) t
2 and (c, f,i) t
3 in figure 12 for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= (a–c) 0.067, (d–f) 0.133 and (g–i) 0.20.

Figure 13. Long description
The image contains nine graphs arranged in a 3×3 grid. Each graph displays contours of the near-wall azimuthal vorticity field on the left and profiles of the differences in streamwise momentum transfers (Delta_u^2) in red and pressures (Delta_p) in blue on the right. The graphs represent different time values (t1, t2, t3) and hole diameters (0.067, 0.133, 0.20). The x-axis represents the normalized streamwise position (x/D_0), and the y-axis represents the normalized radial position (r/D_0). The contours show regions of positive and negative vorticity, while the profiles illustrate the variations in momentum transfers and pressures at the upstream and downstream sides of a control volume.
As shown in figure 12, before approximately t
${U}_{0}/$
D
0 = 2, the momentum convection flux across the porous wall is nearly zero, and the increase in the drag is dominated by the pressure term. As the PVR approaches the wall and fluid penetration occurs, the momentum transfer intensifies, leading to a rapid rise in the momentum term. Conversely, the pressure term decreases. This is associated not only with the reduction in the near-wall positive pressure region squeezed by negative pressure from the cores, but also with the increase in the positive pressure downstream of the wall (figure 8
b). Consequently, the total drag during the subsequent vortex–wall interaction can be significantly influenced by both the momentum and pressure terms.
Specifically, for
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, because of weak fluid penetration, the upstream pressure and velocity distributions near the wall have a greater effect on the pressure and momentum terms. From t
1 to t
2 (figures 13
a,b), the PVR cores and the induced shear layer separation create a wide range of negative pressures, significantly reducing
$\Delta$
p beyond approximately |r
$/$
D
0| = 0.75, and thus the pressure term in figure 12(a). Conversely, an increase in
$\Delta$
u
2 can be detected when |r
$/$
D
0| = 0.25–1 because of greater streamwise momentum transfer upstream of the wall. This results in a larger increase in the momentum term than in the decrease in the pressure term. Consequently, the total drag can continue to increase and reach the maximum value at t
2 when the momentum term becomes the largest.
Similar variations in the momentum and pressure terms are observed for the cases
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.10 (not shown here) and 0.133. The main differences are as follows. Compared with
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067, the enhanced fluid penetration reduces the upstream near-wall pressure while increasing the downstream near-wall pressure, as depicted in figure 9(a), thus reducing
$\Delta$
p in the range |r
$/$
D
0| < 0.5 (figure 13
d). Additionally, although the downstream momentum transfer increases, the upstream momentum transfer can increase more significantly, resulting in a larger
$\Delta$
u
2 within the same radial range. These changes cause more substantial decrease and increase in the pressure and momentum terms, respectively (figure 12
b). Additionally, the drag reaches its maximum at a later time when the momentum and pressure terms are undergoing decay and secondary increase, respectively. This moment corresponds to the flow scenario in figure 13(e), where a more profound PVR–wall interaction occurs, along with the development of enhanced vorticity transmission.
When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases to 0.20, the momentum term can reach a larger peak value (figure 12
c), as a result of the increased
$\Delta{u}^2$
for |r
$/$
D
0| < 1 (figure 13
g). Moreover,
$\Delta{u}^2$
exhibits a multipeak distribution, which is caused by the formation of the jet-like structures downstream of the wall. Notably, the pressure term decreases to an evidently negative value. In addition to the relative change in the upstream and downstream near-wall pressures in figure 9(a), this result correlates with the fact that the PVR moves closer to the wall in this case, as reflected in figure 3(d), thus yielding stronger negative pressure upstream of the wall. This further reduces
$\Delta$
p beyond |r
$/$
D
0| = 0.5 (figure 13
g). Because of the significant negative contributions of the pressure term, the total drag decreases before reaching its maximum value. Similar to the case
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.133, the moment of maximum drag corresponds to the flow scenario of a profound vortex–wall interaction (figure 13
h). In the weak-interaction stage, the upstream flow scenarios become similar for the three cases (figures 13
c, f,i). Compared with those of
$\Delta$
p, the different flow characteristics downstream of the wall result in local changes in the distribution of
$\Delta{u}^2$
. Nonetheless, this does not seem to have a large impact on the combined effect of the momentum and pressure terms, as well as the total drag shown in figure 12.
3.5. Further discussion on porous-wall drag
For the current porous plates with a finite wall thickness (the ratio of wall thickness H
w
to ring radius R is approximately 0.26), the drag mainly comprises pressure drag (or form drag) generated when the fluid impacts the impermeable area of the porous wall, and friction drag (or shear force) that results from the fluid passing through the cylindrical holes. Note that in the case of Cheng et al. (Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014), with a very small wall thickness (H
w
$/$
R = 0.02), the friction drag is approximately negligible. The form drag F
D,p
can be expressed as (Cheng et al. Reference Cheng, Lou and Lim2014)
where
$\Delta$
p is the pressure difference on two sides of the porous wall, S
1 (=
$\phi$
S
2) is the open area, and S
2 is the total wall area. With the reconstructed pressure fields, the form drag F
D,p
can be approximately estimated using the pressures on the front and rear surfaces of the smallest control volume (x
$/$
D
0 = ±0.13, |r
$/$
D
0| ≤ 2.1). The shear force is proportional to the streamwise velocity gradient normal to the hole wall and the curved surface area of the cylindrical holes. However, accurately obtaining the velocity fields inside the holes using the present experimental techniques is difficult. Therefore, the frictional drag F
D,s
here is estimated by subtracting the form drag from the total drag, i.e. F
D,s
= F
D
− F
D,p
.
To measure the overall influence of the wall drag on fluid transport, the time-averaged drag is computed for each drag component and different stages of the vortex–wall interaction. The results are shown in figure 14 for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases. The durations for the strong- and weak-interaction stages are marked by the red and blue shaded regions in figures 4 and 11. Moreover, the onset of the rapid circulation decay is defined as the start time of the vortex–wall interaction, t
s
(figure 4), and tU
0
$/$
D
0 = 10 is selected as the end time, t
e
, based on the fact that for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases, the total drag approaches zero at this moment (figure 11).
Contributions of the mean form drag
${\overline{F}_{D,p}}/\rho\varGamma_{0}^{2}$
and mean friction drag
${\overline{F}_{D,s}}/\rho\varGamma_{0}^{2}$
during the (a) strong-interaction and (b) weak-interaction stages for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
cases.

Figure 14. Long description
The bar graph compares mean form drag and mean friction drag during strong-interaction and weak-interaction stages for all cases. The x-axis represents the variable d_h^* with values ranging from 0.05 to 0.25. The y-axis represents the normalized drag force values. The graph features two sets of bars for each d_h^* value: one for mean form drag (blue) and one for mean friction drag (red). In the strong-interaction stage, the mean friction drag is significantly higher than the mean form drag across all d_h^* values. In the weak-interaction stage, both drag components are lower and more comparable. The data shows a decreasing trend in both drag components as d_h^* increases.
As shown in figure 14(a), in the strong-interaction stage, the contributions of form drag are significantly smaller than those of friction drag. This is because the high porosity corresponds to a relatively small impermeable area of the porous wall. As a result, most of the fluid interacts with the holes to generate a shear effect. When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.2, the form drag makes a negative contribution to the total drag, which is associated with the negative pressure term, as depicted in figure 12(c). Additionally, the friction drag decreases with increasing
${d}_{{h}}^*$
. This is consistent with expectations since when the open area remains constant, the total surface area of the holes can be larger for the case of a smaller
${d}_{{h}}^*$
. In the weak-interaction stage in figure 14(b), the form drag is also much smaller than the friction drag. Additionally, for all
${d}_{{h}}^*$
, the contributions of both form drag and friction drag are approximately the same. This further indicates that the drag characteristics in this stage do not seem to depend on
${d}_{{h}}^*$
.
It should be pointed out that the estimated form drag might be lower than that calculated using the pressure data on the front and rear surfaces of the porous wall. Nonetheless, for the present low Reynolds number flow, the finite thickness and high porosity of the porous wall significantly increase the contribution of friction drag. Furthermore, the current results for a large hole diameter differ from the mean drag characteristics of periodic vortex ring–porous wall interactions reported by Xu et al. (Reference Xu, Wang, Feng, He and Wang2018). This discrepancy may be due to the fact that their results were derived based on the Hagen–Poiseuille equation, which is of limited applicability to the momentum-driven flow.
After the wall drag is obtained during the vortex ring–porous wall interactions, a link between the drag and some characteristics of the vortex ring can be established. Considering the vortex ring with circulation
$\Gamma$
moving in an inviscid fluid of density ρ, when the core radius is much smaller than the ring radius (the ratio of the core radius to the ring radius is 0.28 in this study), the impulse of such a ring is expressed as (Sullivan et al. Reference Sullivan, Niemela, Hershberger, Bolster and Donnelly2008)
For fluid transport through a porous wall, the relative impulse loss
$\Delta$
I
* can be written as (Wang et al. Reference Wang, Xu and Wang2025)
According to the aforementioned results in figure 3, R up ≈ R do . By using this relationship, (3.7) gives
where
$\Delta \Gamma ^{{*}}$
denotes the relative loss in the vortex circulation caused by the porous wall.
As suggested by Li et al. (Reference Li, Xu and Wang2020) for the interaction of synthetic-jet vortex rings with a porous wall, the relative circulation loss can be effectively scaled with a similarity parameter, namely,
$Re^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
. In the current situation, a linear relationship still exists between
$\Delta \Gamma ^{{*}}$
and the logarithm of
$Re^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
, as shown in figure 15(a), where
$\Delta \Gamma ^{{*}}$
is derived from the PIV results in figure 4. Through linear fitting (correlation coefficient > 0.99), this relationship, as indicated by the dashed line in figure 15(a), can be expressed as
(a) Relative circulation loss
$\Delta {\varGamma }$
* versus
$Re^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
, where the dashed line is the fitting curve that corresponds to (3.9). (b) The mean drag during the vortex–wall interaction
$\overline{F}_{D}/\rho\varGamma_{0}^{2}$
versus
$Re^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
, where the dash-dotted line is the prediction curve that corresponds to (3.12).

Figure 15. Long description
The image contains two separate graphs. The first graph on the left shows the relative circulation loss versus the dimensionless parameter Re^2d_h^*3. The data points are represented by different symbols corresponding to various values of the dimensionless parameter. A dashed line indicates the fitting curve. The second graph on the right illustrates the mean drag during vortex-wall interaction versus the same dimensionless parameter Re^2d_h^*3. Different symbols represent various values of the dimensionless parameter, and a dash-dotted line shows the prediction curve. Both graphs use a logarithmic scale for the x-axis and a linear scale for the y-axis.
This expression is very similar to that proposed by Li et al. (Reference Li, Xu and Wang2020), i.e.
$\Delta \Gamma ^{{*}}$
= –0.08 ln(
$Re^2{d}_{{h}}^{*3}$
) + 1.22. Notably, the disparity between the vertical intercepts 1.29 and 1.22 originates mainly from the different definitions of the mean exit velocity U
0 in Re. When the same definition of U
0 is adopted, the intercept in (3.9) is 1.19. By using this relationship, (3.8) can be written as
In particular, (3.10) provides an a priori method for estimating the impulse loss of fluid transport based on the jet Reynolds number and hole diameter of the porous wall, without the need for quantitative flow field measurements.
The impulse loss
$\Delta$
I can also be written as
where
$\Delta {t}$
denotes the duration of the interaction. Then, substituting (3.10) into (3.11), the time-averaged drag
$\overline{F}_{D}$
can be given by
Thus a link is established between the mean drag and both the upstream vortex ring characteristics and the geometric parameters of the porous wall. The interaction duration
$\Delta {t}$
in (3.12) can be obtained from the currently defined start (t
s) and end (t
e
) moments of the vortex–wall interaction, i.e.
$\Delta {t}$
= t
e
– t
s
. As shown in figure 15(b), the calculation results of the right-hand side of (3.12), as represented by the dash-dotted line, are in good agreement with the mean drag derived from figure 11. These findings further confirm the validity of (3.10) and the accuracy of the current drag calculations. Given that the effect of
$\phi$
on the porous wall drag is not considered in this research, further studies will be conducted to improve the prediction accuracy and applicability of (3.10).
4. Conclusions
In this study, the interaction between a laminar vortex ring and porous walls with varying hole diameters (
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.067–0.20) is experimentally studied using time-resolved planar PIV and LIF at constant Reynolds number (Re = 617) and porosity (
$\phi$
= 0.75). The FTLE is presented to depict the evolution of the vortical structures, and the Taylor hypothesis is applied to construct the 3-D structures of the TVR using the LIF images in the cross-sectional planes. With the help of the PINN, the pressure fields are reconstructed from the PIV velocity data, which enables the calculation of the porous wall drag based on the control volume method.
On the basis of the time rates of change in the PVR circulation, the vortex–wall interaction can be divided into the two stages of strong interaction and weak interaction. As
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, vorticity transmission is enhanced, while the mutual interaction between the PVR and SVR weakens. Furthermore, the downstream flow structures are initially wrapped along the azimuthal direction by petal-shaped structures. These petal-shaped structures can subsequently merge to form a large-scale TVR. When
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20, their merging occurs more slowly than when
${d}_{{h}}^*$
is smaller. This corresponds to insufficient vorticity cancellation, resulting in reduced coherence of the TVR.
Regarding the temporal evolution of the drag, during PVR convection towards the wall, the drag is governed mainly by the pressure term, which is related to the difference in pressure on the upstream and downstream sides of the wall. With the onset of the strong-interaction stage, the drag is significantly influenced by both the pressure and momentum convection flux terms. As
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, the enhanced fluid penetration and streamwise momentum transfers lead to more substantial decrease and increase in the pressure and momentum terms, respectively. Additionally, the drag reaches its maximum value later, which corresponds to the flow scenario of a more profound PVR–wall interaction and stronger TVR. Notably, when
${d}_{{h}}^*$
= 0.20, a secondary increase in the drag is observed, which is caused by the significant negative contributions of the pressure term. This is different from previous observations of the PVR interacting with a solid wall or low-porosity porous walls. However, in the weak-interaction stage, the superposition of the momentum and pressure terms seems to be less affected by
${d}_{{h}}^*$
and results in similar drag characteristics. These findings can enhance the understanding of the unsteady behaviour of drag and its correlation with the vortical structures.
A further analysis of the mean drag is performed. For the current porous plates with a finite wall thickness, the contributions of friction drag are much greater than those of form drag. In the strong-interaction stage, as
${d}_{{h}}^*$
increases, the friction drag decreases in association with the reduced curved surface area of the holes. Conversely, in the weak-interaction stage, the contributions of both form and friction drag are independent of
${d}_{{h}}^*$
. These findings suggest that in practical applications that involve interactions between vortex flows and porous surfaces, the focus should be placed on the strong-interaction stage. In particular, even when the porosity remains constant, increasing the hole diameter can effectively reduce the friction drag, and thus the total drag. Finally, an a priori method is proposed for predicting the impulse loss of fluid transport based on Re and
${d}_{{h}}^*$
, without the need for quantitative measurements. By using this method in combination with the upstream vortex ring characteristics, the mean drag can be estimated, and the results show good agreement with those derived from the experimental results.
Supplementary movies
Supplementary movies are available at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2026.11701.
Funding
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (nos 12322212, 12472281, 11902019), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (no. YWF-1113) and the Talent Fund of Beijing Jiaotong University (no. 2024XKRC046).
Declaration of interests
The authors report no conflict of interest.
Appendix A. Repeatability of vortex ring generation
To quantify the repeatability of vortex ring generation, the measured flow fields during the free development stage of the vortex ring obtained from twelve data sets of all investigated cases (each case contains two independent tests) are analysed. Figure 16 presents the circulation and trajectory of the vortex ring in the upper and lower half-planes of the symmetric axis from the jet exit (x
$/$
D
0 = –3.3) to the location 1.5D
0 away from the wall. The shaded region denotes the standard deviation. The results show that both the circulation and trajectory during the free development stage are less influenced by the presence of the porous and solid walls. For the circulation in figure 16(a), after the vortex ring is fully formed (x
$/$
D
0 > –2.5), the uncertainty related to the experimental repeatability is no more than 7 % of
$\Gamma$
0, while the uncertainty resulting from the differences between the two half-plane values is less than 5 % of
$\Gamma$
0. For the trajectory in figure 16(b), these two types of the uncertainties are less than 2 % of D
0 and 3 % of D
0 over the entire streamwise range, respectively. These variations are small and indicate good repeatability of vortex ring generation. Additionally, the present study investigates a laminar vortex ring at a low Reynolds number, which maintains better coherence during its free evolution, thereby further enhancing the reproducibility of the flow.
(a) Circulation and (b) trajectory of the vortex ring during its free development stage obtained from twelve data sets of all investigated cases. The subscripts
$+$
and
$-$
represent the quantities in the upper and lower half-planes, respectively. The shaded region denotes the standard deviation.

Figure 16. Long description
The image contains two line graphs side by side. The first graph on the left shows the circulation of the vortex ring during its free development stage. The x-axis represents the normalized position x/D_0, ranging from −3.5 to −1.5. The y-axis represents the normalized circulation Γ/Γ_0, ranging from 0 to 1.4. Two data sets are plotted: one with red circles representing Γ_+ and another with blue circles representing Γ_−. The shaded region around the data points indicates the standard deviation. The second graph on the right shows the trajectory of the vortex ring. The x-axis is the same as in the first graph, representing the normalized position x/D_0. The y-axis represents the normalized radius r/D_0, ranging from 0 to 1. Two data sets are plotted: one with red circles representing r_c+ and another with blue circles representing r_c−. The shaded region around the data points indicates the standard deviation. The graphs illustrate the behavior of the vortex ring in the upper and lower half-planes during its free development stage.







ωθ
/
dh∗=
/
ωθ
/
dh∗
Γ
/
Γ
Γ
/
Γ
ωθp,SVRD0/U0
/
dh∗
dh∗
dh∗
/
dh∗
tU0/D0
dh∗
/
ρU02
tU0/D0
dh∗
/
ρU02
/
/
/
ρΓ02
dh∗
FD/ρΓ02
dh∗
/
ρΓ02
/
ρΓ02
/
ρΓ02
dh∗
Δ
/
U02
Δ
/
ρU02
tU0/D0
dh∗
F¯D,p/ρΓ02
F¯D,s/ρΓ02
dh∗
ΔΓ
Re2dh∗3
F¯D/ρΓ02
Re2dh∗3
+
−