The politics of human rights is riddled with tensions and contradictions, as amply illustrated in The Human Rights Paradox, edited by Steve Stern and Scott Straus. A highly institutionalised international policy area has spawned a veritable global human rights industry with very significant resources being devoted to the promotion of what seems to be an ever expanding range of standards. Yet, ubiquitous violations around the world continue to highlight the very wide gap between the moral and legal invocation of human rights, and the pervasive reality of human suffering. The human rights paradox, as framed in this volume, exists in the often evoked alleged universality of human rights on the one hand, yet the inescapable reality, on the other, that they can only be realised in particular places and through particular means. Although the ‘paradox’ of human rights is a well-documented one, the contributions to The Human Rights Paradox advance long-standing debates in human rights scholarship.
The first set of chapters explores from different disciplinary perspectives the potential of contextual human rights analysis. Geoffrey Robinson's excellent chapter on East Timor shows how a deep historical understanding of contextualised trajectories of human rights mobilisation in a specific locality provides a significant corrective to recent revisionist scholarship on the global history of human rights. By highlighting local political contingencies, agency, and above all, anticolonial struggles, Robinson offers a crucial perspective on how local mobilisation of human rights discourse derives energy from, but also nourishes, the global human rights regime. Bridget Conley-Zilkic's chapter on the US Holocaust Memorial Museum offers an informed account of a specific case that serves to highlight the global growth of public memorialisation in recent decades. The chapter effectively illustrates, in particular, the politically contested character of memory museums. Meghan Foster Lynch's chapter offers a fascinating and innovative analysis of the drivers of non-violence. The author's rich discussion of community-level mobilisation for peace in Rumonge, Burundi, demonstrates the potential of notions of self-preservation and reciprocity for the protection of fundamental human rights. The specific case is highly suggestive of the very real limitations of abstract human rights moralising when confronted with mass violence.
The second cluster of chapters examines the ways in which human rights are socially and historically constructed. The chapter by Patrick Vinck and Phuong Pham offers a comprehensive analysis of the role of survivors of mass violence as potential agents of change by drawing on the authors’ work with survivors in various countries, including Cambodia and Uganda. Vinck and Pham critically review efforts to engage survivors through consultation processes in the design of transitional justice mechanisms in countries affected by mass violence, and arrive at the conclusion that there continue to be significant tensions between global efforts to promote international justice and local participation in their design and implementation. Noa Vaisman's chapter on the struggles over the truth concerning the violations committed during the last military regime in Argentina offers an engaging account of the politics of intergenerational mobilisation in the field of transitional justice. Vaisman discusses the case of a leading Argentine organisation in these struggles, H.I.J.O. S., and highlights the tensions that exist between human rights work that seeks to advance how the past is remembered on the one hand, and the continuities between human rights of the past and human rights of the present, on the other. Jo-Marie Burt's chapter on accountability struggles in Peru describes the ways in which local politics shape the ‘impact’ of transitional justice principles. Burt's excellent account of the struggles over transitional justice in Peru highlights the often overlooked role of ‘pro-impunity forces’ mobilising against accountability; a mobilisation that may have successfully, for now, tilted the scales of justice in favour of the perpetrators of human rights violations in that country.
The contributions to the third and final part of the book explore the shifting meanings of human rights over time, and across space. Fuyuki Kurasawa examines the role of social media in human rights advocacy work by unpacking a number of common doubts (‘aporias’) about the efficacy and appropriateness of social media activism. Kurasawa deftly navigates the terrain between ‘techno-idealism and its skeptical counterparts’ (p. 178) as he critically examines a range of unforeseen consequences of social media activism that serve to highlight the multifaceted, and unpredictable, effects of technological change on the character of the interactions between the global and the local. Philippe Cullet's chapter on the right to water in India offers a detailed illustration of the importance of concrete local measures to give meaning to abstract constitutional, and international, law claims for rights to be meaningful to the people most in need. The final chapter of the volume by Richard Hiskes offers a fresh take on the well-trodden topic of the foundations of human rights. By drawing his inspiration from the writings of Thomas Hobbes, Hiskes develops an account of the building blocks of human rights that emphasises the importance of relationships based on shared promises, or reciprocity. In a thought-provoking move, Hiskes turns attention away from state-citizen relations as the privileged focus of human rights politics to the myriad interactions between individuals as the foundation of human rights.
The Human Rights Paradox, overall, makes important contributions to human rights scholarship by seeking to move beyond the dichotomous understandings of ‘the global’ and ‘the local’ that permeate the literature. One might quibble with the extent to which the contributing authors have actively engaged with the overarching analytical framework of the volume, but this should not detract from the consistently high quality of the thought-provoking set of chapters assembled here. On a slightly different note, however, partly due to the volume's overwhelming focus on ‘the local’, it overlooks the many challenges to human rights that can be found in the ways that ‘the global’ is structured. According to the editors, ‘human rights abuse is thus always local […]’ (p. 9). And yet, it is not clear how globalised actors and institutions of abuse, from, say, NATO bombings, extra-judicial killings by drone warfare, Guantanamo Bay, to the activities of (certain) multinational corporations, fit into this picture. Moreover, one does not necessarily have to agree with recent accounts of the ‘endtimes of human rights’ to recognise that international human rights are confronted with, arguably, existential challenges. From the resurgence of sovereigntist critiques of what is perceived as overbearing, and hypocritical, global human rights practices, to the revitalisation of the cultural relativist charge against alleged Western values, the global human rights regime is clearly at a delicate conjuncture. These dynamics are part and parcel of the ‘human rights paradox’ set out to be explored in this book, yet they cannot readily be understood in terms of a ‘tension between universal affirmation and local struggle’ (p. 10). Rather than merely ‘affirming’ human rights, the global, as much as the local, is a site of contention and struggle, and the future of human rights hinges on, to a large extent, how these struggles play out.
