This monograph explores the regulatory ups and downs (mostly downs) of workplace safety controls in the United Sates over a number of decades. The Progressive Era is a major focus, with World War I serving as something of a fulcrum upon which the story pivots toward its conclusion in the New Deal. Given the turning point of 1917, the book's title carries a nice echo of Woodrow Wilson's call to war (“the world must be made safe for democracy”). Just as the book is well anchored in time, the analysis in Making Capitalism Safe is geographically centered firmly in the state of Wisconsin, which was at the vanguard of local reforms. The author knows this territory well, as this book represents an expansion of his 1983 dissertation.Footnote 1
Wisconsin was at the forefront of battles over emerging workers' compensation insurance (especially early in the twentieth century) and experimented early in industrial interventions through innovative administrative actions, in particular, safety codes. This was by no means a linear trajectory, however, as Rogers makes clear. The political landscape in Wisconsin was far from stable. The shifting fault lines of progressive reform and reactionary counter-reform drove the forwards-backwards motion of the state apparatus. This resonates considerably with the current political scene in Wisconsin, in which a conservative takeover of state government facilitated a frontal attack on the collective bargaining rights of governmental employees. Thus, the contemporary situation in Wisconsin appears to be every bit as divisive as that painted in Making Capitalism Safe, with the rights of working women and men once more front and center.
The strength of the Wisconsin analytic focus, to an extent, is negatively counterbalanced by the juxtaposition of this state's experience with that of five others: California, Illinois, Ohio, New York, and Alabama. These were selected for the purposes of similarities and contrasts, but frequently this element of the analysis seems forced and not particularly informative. This is especially the case with Alabama, as Rogers notes repeatedly that the state instituted very little, if any, effective reform or regulation. Wisconsin had it quirks over the years, so certainly some point of reference is useful. (Well into the second half of the twentieth century, for example, it still restricted the sale of margarine in deference to its dairy interests.) However, a more tightly constructed comparative framework might have held together more strongly, limited perhaps only to neighboring Illinois, a highly industrialized state with a long history of stymied progress in worker safety and health, as effectively shown by Rogers, and California, which shared many of Wisconsin's reformist characteristics, although it also diverged from it in interesting ways.
In Making Capitalism Safe, Rogers displays impressive erudition in dealing with the complex and often arcane legal aspects of worker injury liability and compensation in the United States. A European reader (or even a Canadian one) might find some of this curious if not provincial, but it is a critical component of the story and one that too often is glossed over in political-historical analyses of public policy questions. As opposed to the ways in which Making Capitalism Safe gives depth and breadth to physical safety hazards and how they were handled in the first half of the twentieth century, however, workers' health hazards are given fairly short shrift. They appear almost exclusively in the final chapter, with over-emphasis on the elsewhere well-covered ground of silicosis. In terms of timeframe, the health analysis starts off in the late 1920s, with little more than a nod to the earlier decades covered so effectively, in terms of physical injury, in previous chapters. The epilogue jumps forward somewhat jarringly to the formation of the United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). As if to underscore the shortcomings of the health discussion, the book fails to mention the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), established at the same time.
Despite its shortcomings, Making Capitalism Safe makes a useful contribution to the literature on the early history of workers' compensation and worker safety regulation in the United States. Wisconsin's story is particularly compelling.
