As the world goes through an accelerated process of globalization, states and societies are pressed to adapt while dealing with a multitude of internal and external challenges. State power, authority, and resources seem to be declining in relation to societal needs and expectations, whereas society's control over its identity and destiny is increasingly elusive in the face of global market forces, neoliberal economic prescriptions, and global cultural markers. States and societies are not the only entities facing this existential challenge. Individuals and groups are also facing dilemmas of identity and destiny as a result of both their weakening of connection to the state and the increasing pull of the global environment.
Shana Cohen's book deals precisely with this phenomena in the case of Morocco; it suggests from the outset that as a result of liberal market reforms, which changed “the social structure of society by producing new social groups … we may be witnessing the birth of a class that does not take the state as its objective, but rather pushes for a role in the global economy” (p. 3). For Cohen, the key factor here is “global market integration,” a process that puts in place “a universal economic structure through the implementation of uniform reform policies, the domination of neoliberal ideology, and the global production of consumer culture” (p. 3). Using this definition, and on the basis of her field study that includes observations of and interviews with Moroccan youth, the author proposes that “the social power of public institutions, the state, and nationalism have shifted to the firm, globalization, and global market capitalism, which together impose an atomistic, nonlocated vision of social order.” As a result, she finds, young, urban, educated Moroccans feel—and seem—alienated from their state and are becoming part of a new global middle class. In this process, this young generation shies away from the national public space because it is both alien and irrelevant, is highly critical of social and political life at home, and “idealizes” alternative venues for its own social emancipation in the global arena. This collection of individuals “must negotiate the present and future outside of a system of collective representation of a nation” (p. 7). Drawing on the works of Max Weber and Karl Marx on alienation and industrialization, Cohen explains this tendency by “a loss of philosophical purposes and meanings derived from the declining relevance of both territory and citizenship” (p. 8). Her analysis, which centers on class formation in Morocco, also uses an eclectic collection of thinkers, such as Antonio Gramsci, Abdalah Laraoui, Pierre Bourdieu, and de Tocqueville, among others, and a multidisciplinary approach that combines sociology, politics, political economy, and psychology.
The Moroccan youth groups Cohen studied are presented as having lost “connection to the social space and existential purpose of the nation” (p. 12). They include entrepreneurs and midlevel managers in the private sector (in national-service industry and multinational companies), the unemployed and temporarily employed, bureaucrats, professionals and informal business owners, workers in public-sector occupations of the older postcolonial middle class, and teachers, doctors, and technicians in the private sector. From within these groups was born a new middle class that looks for emancipation and freedom abroad, using means ranging from the Internet to illegal labor overseas. This heterogeneous collection of people who make up what Cohen calls the new middle class does not seek to change the state or its policies. Instead, it chooses the exit option (a generation of fuyards, flee-ers) by looking for a future in the global economy (p. 34).
For the author, this phenomenon began when the economic crisis and state retreat from “the social economy” began in the 1980s, which led to deteriorating standards of living and social decline among the modern middle class. In the end, Morocco's development project and market reforms are left without “the middle class as a primary agent.” She finds this worrisome not only for Morocco but also for this alienated “global middle class” that may never find the niche it seeks in the global economy.
Even though it is based on research done mostly in a single Moroccan city—Casablanca—Cohen's work is quite informative on the impact of globalization and state failure on socioeconomic mutations and identity in peripheral countries. This impact is relayed to the reader through interviews and anecdotes used as illustrations. As for the analysis itself, it seems to be weakened by the spread of its scope and the eclectic theoretical framework used. In the end, the reader is left wondering whether the Moroccan “global middle class” really exists as such. Can a class be composed of the many heterogeneous socioeconomic groups Cohen identifies? Does it have a consciousness of itself as a class? What makes it “global” beyond aiming at fleeing the country and seeking any future beyond the national borders? Is it really apolitical, not involved in national politics, and apathetic?
Clear and accurate answers to these questions would have certainly strengthened this daring study, which remains highly informative and inspiring for the direction of future studies of this sort in the Arab world and beyond. This book should be read by anyone interested in recent socioeconomic and political development in Morocco and in social and economic mutations generated—or by anyone affected by globalization and neoliberal policies in the developing world.
