This book looks to offer its readers insight into the exchanges between Latin America and the Arab World throughout a series of revolutionary moments in the twentieth century. The study has two main goals: the first is to highlight the encounters between Latin American and Arab revolutionaries, and place these encounters within the field of transnational Global South history. The second goal is to argue for the political and ideological autonomy of Latin Americans and Arabs involved in these encounters – independent actors who were not merely proxies caught between superpowers in a Cold War climate. Six chapters cover a broad geographic scope of the Latin American, Middle Eastern and North African regions. Temporally, the case studies range from the rise of Gamal Abdel Nasser in 1950s Egypt to Hugo Chávez's diplomatic strategies in the twenty-first century.
The book's first aim dovetails with a growing field of transregional scholarship linking Latin American history, culture and politics to Middle Eastern and North African panoramas. This scholarship does the important work of interrogating the utility of area studies borders which we inherited from the Cold War era. These borders still largely dictate academic departmental and funding structures, and continue to exert influence on guiding theoretical frameworks. In this light, more information on the relationships that developed between Latin American ‘revolutionaries’ of all stripes and their Arab counterparts is a welcome addition to this broader transregional project. Regarding the second aim of the book, Federico Vélez proposes positioning Global South peripheries of the Cold War as more than just ‘proxies’ for superpower designs. This is a position clearly staked out by early Cold War scholarship, notes the author in his introduction. This leaves the reader wondering, though, about the decision to respond to the pitfalls of early Cold War scholarship, in lieu of actively engaging with the vibrant field of Cold War scholarship of the last decade or so. The contemporary field of Latin American Cold War studies has squarely moved beyond the once taken-for-granted binaries of superpower–proxy, first world–third world, local–global as the core determinants for how nations experienced and participated in the unfolding of this global conflict. In this respect, the second aim of the book is not breaking new ground.
Chapter 1 opens with an overview of Gamal Abdel Nasser's influence in various Latin American contexts. Here the author sets the scene for South–South relationships that developed in the post-World War II moment, yet also characterises this time as a moment when Latin America ‘closed into itself’ (p. 9). From the author's description of Panamanians who saw parallels between their neocolonial relationship with the United States manifested in the Panama Canal and Egypt's situation with Suez, the image of a ‘closed’ Latin America does not work. The author also records incidences of ‘military Nasserism’ in Argentine and Brazilian contexts, as well as incidences of manifestation from Arab and Jewish diaspora communities in the Southern Cone.
The diasporic dimension is interesting, but the argument lumps these groups into a discussion of the Latin American ‘Left’. One need look no further than the example of the Nasserist Arab-Argentine Raúl Jassen, a member of the Peronist extreme Right, whom the author cites a few pages later, to find this generalisation problematic. The chapter concludes that there would be no possibility of a Latin American version of Nasser to arise until Chávez appeared in Venezuela. And yet, the reader is left wanting a more thorough treatment of Panama's Omar Torrijos regime, which the author characterises as a regime that both friends and foes branded as ‘Nasserist’ in the 1970s.
Following this overview are three chapters on Cuba, followed by a dual-focus ‘Cuba–Nicaragua’ chapter. These chapters explore Cuban revolutionaries’ relationships with Nasser, and Ahmed Ben Bella, who was the leader of the Algerian revolutionary government of the 1960s. These chapters add a compelling transnational dimension to the history of Cuba's involvement with the Non-Aligned Movement. For example, it frames Che Guevara's purposeful cultivation of Nasser's endorsement of the Cuban Revolution of 1959 as a way of gaining legitimacy with members of the Afro-Asian bloc who were spearheading Global South conversations about neutralism in an increasingly polarised world.
The chapter on Cuba and Algeria as ‘Partners in Revolution’ builds on this line of argumentation, and provides interesting information about Cuban military and medical aid to Algeria in the 1960s. In particular, the discussion of Cuban medical personnel dispatched to Algeria reveals the tensions that lay between revolutionaries who strongly identified with a common path between these two nations, yet struggled with the sometimes frustrating cultural differences that they experienced upon arrival. Despite these differences, the author demonstrates how Algerians like Ben Bella could serve as facilitators between Cuban and Afro-Asian diplomatic relationships. In addition, Ben Bella worked in concert with Cuban revolutionaries to promote revolution elsewhere in Latin America. While Castro and Guevara's desires to export the revolution to Latin American neighbours are well documented, Algeria's role is less often acknowledged, but convincingly argued here. The reader concludes these chapters with the keen sense that the Cuban–Algerian relationship embodied the achievement of an international dimension of the Cuban Revolution, even if Algeria's revolutionary state was ultimately short-lived.
The Cuba–Algeria relationship is the most thorough and well-developed angle in this study, with other national examples playing more ancillary roles. The section on ‘Cuba–Nicaragua’ examines Sandinista–Palestinian ties, and exemplifies one of these ancillary case studies that merit more ample development. The condensed nature of this case study in contrast with Cuba leads to a somewhat confusing timeline – for example, the author's claim that the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) had no contact with Palestine after 1970, followed immediately by noting a series of communications and interactions between the FSLN and Palestinian organisations such as communiqués dispatched in 1978 and 1979 (pp. 119, 121). Limiting the treatment of Sandinista affinities for Middle Eastern and North African referents to a discussion of Palestine also leaves out interesting material on Sandinista inspiration and admiration for the Algerian example. For example, Nicaragua's FSLN was originally the ‘FLN’, taking its name in direct homage to Algeria's FLN before incorporating the symbol of Sandino into their organisation's name (Matilde Zimmermann, Sandinista, Duke University Press, 2001, p. 73). Other geo-political relationships, such as the Algeria–Nicaragua connection, have the potential to enrich the information presented in this case study, which reveals notable collaboration between Palestinian and Nicaraguan revolutionaries.
The final chapter tackles Hugo Chávez's diplomacy and rhetoric, which situated Latin America and the Arab world as both historically connected and destined for a shared future. While Chávez is certainly a complex and intriguing figure in the arc of Latin American–Arab world diplomatic overtures and rhetorical flourishes, this chapter strays from the stated dual purpose of the book on both fronts. It tracks Chávez's correspondence and emerging relationship with figures such as Libya's Muammar Qaddafi and Syria's Bashar al-Assad, yet at the outset the author emphasises the book's goal of tracking Latin American and Arab revolutionaries, and their relationships. This purpose seems incongruous with the decision to highlight the relationship between, for example, Chávez and an hereditary autocrat such as al-Assad. The desire to carry the book to a more contemporary moment thus weakens the text in terms of sticking to the stated purpose of the book. The second goal – to prove that Latin American and Arab states were not merely Cold War proxies – is also much less relevant to this chapter, much of which takes place after the formal end of the superpowers’ 44-year-long standoff. The rush to bring the case material to the present also results in some inaccurate reductions, such as the characterisation of the current Syrian Civil War as a ‘mostly sectarian’ conflict (p. 165). The case studies of Cuba and Nicaragua both respond much more directly to the introduction's stated intentions.
The author concludes by surmising that Chávez's death ‘closed the last chapter’ of Latin American revolutionary encounters with the Arab world. Far from a certainty, this of course remains to be seen (p. 177). Transregional revolutionary connections – even if only at an aspirational level – may very well be a thing of the future in this era of intensifying human migration and economic globalisation.
