In this well-researched book, a revised doctoral dissertation defended in Perugia in 2005, Miryam de Gaetano offers a thorough reconsideration of Dracontius, by examining both his ‘profane’ and his religious production. The decision to investigate the two sides of Dracontius’ literary activity together is an important novelty, though foreshadowed in a challenging article by Mark Edwards (‘Dracontius the African and the fate of Rome’, Latomus 63 (2004), 151–60). It is one of the book's major contributions, insofar as it allows an overall portrait of the poet, where the classicizing poems cast light on the major Christian epic, and, vice versa, religious writings display thematic links with the secular ones. The analysis also takes into account works like the Satisfactio, as well as works whose authenticity is denied (Aegritudo Perdicae). G. pays particular attention to the scholastic background of Dracontius in order to demonstrate that, like the majority of late antique authors, he drew from his education many poetical and stylistic tools. This is, of course, a well-known statement, which G. corroborates with persuasive arguments. Furthermore, she offers a positive evaluation of such a phenomenon, rejecting the old scholarly charge against Dracontius, namely his superabundant rhetorical fluency.
Here and there some repetitions reveal that this book was originally conceived as a thesis, as does the compilatory nature of certain sections (for example the chapter about school in the Latin world, or the pages summarizing Dracontius’ works). An abridgement of these parts would have resulted in easier reading, and made the book's original contributions more apparent. Among these it is surely worth mentioning the detailed analysis of the re-employment of rhetorical motifs and structures, mainly drawn from canonical authors, like Vergil and Lucan (often considered through the lenses of late commentators). G. investigates aspects such as the rhetorical construction of the tyrant, the antiphrastic employment of classical myths in order to show the fallacy of paganism, and the overturning of the celebrative theme of the endless empire. There is an excellent comparison between Dracontius and Orosius (286 ff.) and interesting hints about the evolution or transformation of curricula in Late Antiquity.
The final section, which deals with the question of the integration of Romans and Vandals, deserves some attention. G. offers a balanced view of the evaluation of the Vandal period in Africa, without yielding either to the black legend or to an over-sympathetic evaluation of it. Following the path paved by Roswitha Simons, G. shows how Dracontius intermingles the criticism against paganism (with a massive insistence on cruel myths) and, conversely, the exaltation of Christian values. Whereas I found her emphasis on consistency throughout the entire production of Dracontius persuasive, I was less convinced by the suggestion, which G. appears to make at the very end, that the case of Dracontius testifies that school acted as a sort of (crypto)-opposition against the Vandal newcomers and their pretensions to imitate Roman sophisticated customs. It is surely true that school played a crucial role in preserving and transmitting the ideals of Christianity, which were perceived as inheritance and transformation of Roman civilization, but it is better, I think, to regard schools as a factor of integration between Romans and barbarians, rather than a way to oppose them.
Other questionable points, in my opinion, concern G.'s interpretation of the vexed passage about Commodus as bonus in Satisfactio 190, where she inclines to identify this personage with Marcus Aurelius, therefore implying an error of Dracontius (I prefer, however, Clover's suggestion who argues for the actual Commodus). Likewise I am not sure that Lucan's proem is conceived as an ironic mocking of Nero, or that we can identify Fulgentius, Bishop of Ruspae, with Fulgentius the mythographer. Nonetheless, the book is a serious and fair inquiry, which can profitably be read by those who are interested in a global portrait of Dracontius.
Secondary literature is extensively cited, even though I noted some inexplicable omissions (Pernot's Rhétorique de l’éloge is not cited while dealing with this theme at p. 326 ff., nor Gnilka about the oriented reuse of pagan quotations, or chresis). Some recent contributions on African literature are also missing (M. Chalou – G. Devallet – P. Force – M. Griffe – J. M. Lassère – J. N. Michaud, ‘Memorabile factum: une célebration de l’évérgetisme des rois Vandales dans l’Anthologie Latine’, AntAfr 21 (1985), 207–62; the dichotomy between sacred and secular would have been better illuminated by taking into account Robert A. Markus’ numerous inquiries, or Richard Miles’ paper about ‘The Anthologia Latina and the creation of secular space in Vandal Carthage’, AntTard 13 (2005), 305–20; while a poet like Corippus, who is paralleled to Dracontius at pp. 68 ff., has enjoyed a certain revival in the last ten years). Conversely, Galli's edition of Romulea 6 and 7 was presumably too recent to be cited.
