Given the paucity of ethnographic research on gender in Saudi Arabia, Amélie Le Rendard's A Society of Young Women, a study of urban women in the Saudi capital of Riyadh, is a welcome contribution. Based on fieldwork mainly among university students, the author analyzes how young women navigate the city's segregated spaces, consume the many values and objects of a neoliberal economy, and define a new femininity amidst opportunities and restrictions. Throughout the text, Le Renard highlights the difficulties foreign researchers, especially women, face in a country that imposes general restrictions on local and foreign women, and this is especially true for researchers attempting to observe their interlocutors in their own homes and in limited public spaces. Yet, despite these obstacles, she succeeds in painting a plausible picture of young women's lives, struggles, and aspirations.
The central location of her fieldwork is a city in which public space is divided according to sex. Only minimal interaction between the sexes is permitted, and even this is regulated. From the shopping mall to the university campus, Saudi men and women learn to move, interact, and socialize in confined spaces that are constantly watched by the state and its agents. Specific state institutions, such as the police and religious authorities, constantly monitor public space to mitigate breaches that may shake the moral order and tarnish the reputation of the nation as a pious entity.
The book confirms that hierarchies of gender, class, race, nationality, and age mediate access to Riyadh's public spaces. Female students and salaried women are more mobile than old and poor women who cannot afford a driver in a country that bans women from driving. Influenced by postcolonial feminist discourses that deconstruct gender relations in the Middle East, Le Renard explores how women's lives are mediated by politics, culture, religion, and economics.
The state espouses the concept of reform to empower women in women-only spaces, jobs, and professions. According to Le Renard, this reform stumbles because it is limited to specific areas of women's lives while keeping structures of domination and exclusion well entrenched. The ṣaḥwa (Islamic Awakening), which became strong in the 1990s, also influences the position of women. Le Renard argues that the state reformist agenda, together with Saudi Islamism, simultaneously opens and closes venues for emancipation. Both promote specific opportunities for women, construct a model of Islamic femininity, and most importantly, create boundaries and hierarchies between Saudis and foreigners and between different social classes and races. Here politics and religion work together to define and construct limits to women's mobility, job opportunities, and professional empowerment.
As women are above all situated within family units, negotiating emancipation and mobility with male and female relatives is a skill that all of them must master in order to go to the shopping mall, register for a university degree, or accept a job. Women are, however, constrained by a constant fear of doing something that endangers the reputation of their families, or of engaging in activities that are deemed scandalous. In order to counteract this fear, women develop gender solidarities and aspire to rewarding careers and professional activities. But these solidarities remain limited, as they do not lead to the formation of civil society or pressure groups. Women are confined to the family unit and unable to organize themselves to call for emancipation and legal and political rights. Notwithstanding the campaigns, mainly virtual, that Saudi women have organized in the past, the absence of an autonomous civil society impinges on women's ability to move from being consumers of public spaces, where they shop and socialize, to being in charge of them. At present, Saudi women, according to Le Renard, engage in minor resistance against the restrictions imposed by the religious authorities and the state. Those who can afford the many Western goods that flood the Saudi market engage in conspicuous consumption in which lifestyles and luxury goods become symbols of femininity. Le Renard maps this conspicuous consumption, which is by definition limited to a small circle of women belonging to wealthy families, as a new mode of subjectivity. This subjectivity is generated by oil wealth and the opening of the Saudi market to global flows of objects and values, despite the government's attempts to restrict the latter, lest they undermine the so-called uniqueness of Saudi Muslim society.
Le Renard argues that consumer-centered femininity is challenged by a minority of the young urban population, namely, those who favor transgender and more masculine identities symbolized by manly attire and bodily manipulation. From wearing boyish clothes to having very short haircuts, some women subvert the consuming feminine subject in favor of a masculine body, clothed in what is the antithesis of the feminine Saudi woman. Between feminization and masculinization, urban women struggle to conform to and resist a local and global culture mediated by consumption, political and religious controls, and social norms.
The book concludes by highlighting how young urban women succeed in transforming their lives without recourse to forms of contestation that carry many risks. They represent the largest cohort of Saudi women and are not concerned with debates about gender equality. According to Le Renard, they also do not give attention to the liberal constituencies or the Islamists’ concern with authenticity. As a group, these urban women remain powerless and depoliticized when it comes to challenging the entrenched structures of exclusion, yet they achieve limited gains within the confined roles and spaces allocated to them by negotiating with the state, religious control agencies, and their families. They also embark on personalized self-help projects—by attending workshops, for example—but they are either incapable or unwilling to challenge the multiple layers that keep them segregated and marginal.
Le Renard succeeds in deconstructing stereotypical images of Saudi women as either the rebellious and courageous heroines depicted in superficial accounts of their lives, or as helpless victims of their society with its many surveillance agencies. Although Saudi women face serious obstacles far more challenging than those faced by women in other parts of the Muslim world, the predicaments of all these women share commonalities. Like other young urban women around the world, Saudi women focus on what interests them most, navigate these interests, succeed in some projects, and fail in others.
With good intentions, the author tries to challenge the well-rehearsed dark image of Saudi women, but her ethnography perhaps moves too far in the direction of a positive, rich, and colourful image. It must be noted, though, that personalized projects, self-help, individual achievement, and consumption patterns take place within well-known structures that either enable or thwart them, and it would have been beneficial to provide a wider context that includes not only local domestic politics but also the global concern with gender and its impact on domestic contexts such as Saudi Arabia. Le Renard does not clearly explain why individual urbanites remain disconnected despite heavy socialization patterns or why this urban generation remains depoliticized.
Notwithstanding these minor shortcomings, the book should be of interest to anthropologists and gender studies specialists. The lucid analysis is written in an easy and accessible style, and is accompanied by interesting illustrations. Detailed references and a bibliography illustrate the author's wide knowledge of the literature on Saudi Arabia. Despite the obstacles Le Renard faced in her fieldwork, she got close enough to her informants to be able to humanize them and capture their aspirations and frustrations.
