“What do we actually know of lives in motion?” (p. 2). This is the primary inquiry of The Places We Share: Migration, Subjectivity, and Global Mobility, a collection of essays that invites the reader to consider the concrete and personal realities of the people who inhabit the interdisciplinary terrain of migration and globalization studies. The edited volume, which emerged from a conference about experiences of migration to and from Morocco, explores lived experiences of serial migration. Morocco serves not only as the thematic thread connecting the different chapters but also as a shared “point of passage” for their authors (p. 4). The stories told in these chapters, many of which fall under the rubric of “autoethnography,” are vivid expositions of the political and psychic conditions of what it means to be transnational.
The book is divided into two sections, “Mobility and Visibility” and “Cosmopolitan Contradictions.” Three chapters, those by Laacher, Terrio, and Jerad, make up the first section. Laacher's “The Power to Name and the Desire to be Named: State Policies and the Invisible Nomad,” the only translated work, explores an Afghani migrant's confrontation with state power in France and considers some of the ways in which the nation-less expose “the limits of law based on citizenship and nationality” (p. 26). Terrio writes about the life and trial of Zacarias Moussaoui in “Zacarias Moussaoui: Moroccan Muslim? French Terrorist? Benighted Zealot? War Criminal? All of the Above?” as a way of probing the notion of a third space in which Moussaoui, the serial migrant, “retreated and rehearsed the sentiment and hatred that set him on his migratory path at the outset” (p. 44). Jerad's “From the Maghreb to the Mediterranean: Immigration and Transnational Locations” looks at syncretic forms of language, music, and literature that, in the experiences of migration, produce a kind of Mediterranean Creole that resists binarization.
Through a consideration of Rushdie's Satanic Verses and the 2004 veil controversy in France, Nadia Tazi explores “how politics confers depth and ethical substance to the cosmopolitan idea and puts it to the test” (p. 65) in her essay “Is it Possible to be Both a Cosmopolitan and a Muslim?” In “A New Take on the Wandering Jew,” Cohen straddles conversations in migration and diaspora studies by examining the constitution of Jewish identity and its existential and ethical components through migration experiences. “Moving Into Morocco: A Cosmopolitan Turn in the Medina” looks at the processes of gentrification taking place in Fez by self-identified serial migrants from Europe and the United States who come to restore and live in historic areas. The autobiographical “Trilateral Touchstones: Personal and Cultural Spaces” details the itinerant life of Evelyn A. Early through her personal and professional journeys in the Middle East and North Africa. Leila Abouhouraira's “In Search of Tangiers' Past” and Abderrahmane Lakhsassi's “From Tribe to Virtual Tribe” are both personal tales of migration, belonging, and reflections about the meanings and makings of cosmopolitanism, with Tangiers and southern Morocco, respectively, at their centers.
The most provocative essays in the volume are those by Mai and Badry. These authors attend to how the interplay of culture and political economics constitutes the social lives of migrants, both those who travel back and forth and those who stay. In considering the relations and circuits of power in which migrants not only locate themselves but also, and necessarily, through which they are located by others, Mai and Badry treat the subjects of their essays, and the migrant condition, with nuance and specificity. Mai's “Errance, Migration, and Male Sex Work: On the Socio-cultural Sustainability of a Third Space” focuses on the experiences of marginality and “between-ness” that characterize the lives of young, male, Romanian, migrant sex workers in Western Europe. The essay encourages the reader to consider “the impossibility of settling or an unwillingness to reterritorialize” (p. 108). In “Positioning the Self, Identity, and Language: Moroccan Women on the Move,” Fatima Badry investigates how migration shapes identity formation through a focus on the use of language by Moroccan women living in the United Arab Emirates. Their choice to speak an Arabic dialect not their own, Badry writes, is an example of not only linguistic adaptation but of language as market commodity, one constructed from a particular social context and utilized in order to achieve particular goals.
Ossman's concluding chapter, “Linked Comparisons for Life and Research,” makes the case for what she terms “linked comparative research” that explores a topic as it moves through space and thus pays heed to shifting contexts, meaningful social locations, and significant contradictions. “We need to pay more attention to the work of time and the different paths taken by people on move,” she contends (p. 201).
Although much of the conceptual ground embarked upon by the contributors to The Places We Share has been well traveled by others within transnationalism and diaspora studies, the book's attention to the subject of mobility deepens scholarly discussion of migration by situating the migrant's identity formations and transformations as neither “here” or “there” but along the paths between and amid two or more places. In avoiding this binary framework and truly considering “lives in motion,” the chapters in this volume think through the way in which mobility shapes social identity and difference. Overall, the book would have been bolstered by a more rigorous examination of the role class and social hierarchy play in the experiences of the very different kinds of migrants the chapters describe. In addition, the text would have benefited from more careful editing.
As a tool for teaching, it might be most fitting in anthropology courses. Many of the chapters would provide undergraduate students with grounded “case studies” for the exploration and critique of the metanarratives that have prevailed in both scholarly and popular discourses about globalization for at least the last decade and a half. There is also fodder here for a rich engagement and debate around concepts like cosmopolitanism, serial migration, and citizenship.
