What do travelers imagine when they plan a pleasure trip to Italy? Stephanie Hom identifies three elements that compose what she calls “destination Italy.” The first, the “sweet art of idleness,” comes from a long-held image of high unemployment in southern Italy. The second, “la dolce vita,” synthesizes the post–World War II romanticization of Italy (enhanced by Italian films) that emphasizes an alluring combination of glamour, design, and sex. The third, “the beautiful country”—which gives the book its title—derives from nineteenth-century images of Tuscany that have come to stand for the whole of the country (pp. 53–67).
With this dream world as the backdrop, Hom offers a rich, complex, and challenging historical study that provides information and insights into tourism as desire, national goal, and business. She reminds us that worldwide tourism generates the equivalent of US$3 billion each day. A professor of Italian at the University of Oklahoma, Hom explores a single country to understand the trajectory over time of its tourist imaginary and to put that in play with the development of Italy as a nation-state. Along the way, she offers delightful excursions into the emergence of the travel industry and its complicated interplay with both Italian unification and the nation's subsequent history. Engaged with present-day aesthetics and politics, Hom also delivers postmodern theorizing and opposition to globalization.
For those resistant to theory in its contemporary formulations, it might be advisable to read the introduction last, once the substantive chapters that follow have put flesh on its bones. Hom's narratives are absolutely fascinating. Beginning with an ancient Greek text, she takes us swiftly through the long history of guidebooks. By the time of the Grand Tour for young gentlemen, Italy is defined for the tourist as a place of leisure, sensual pleasure, and aesthetic contemplation. In 1864, Thomas Cook rose from his beginnings as a planner of temperance excursions in Britain to offer the first guided tour of Italy for his compatriots, an initial ten-day journey; later, his company would offer daily departures for weekly tours of Italy. A strong supporter of Italian unification, Cook introduced practices such as notes (an early version of traveler's checks) and hotel coupons, both of which, before the lira was well established, came to serve as a national currency for travelers native to Italy.
Playing against this story is the difficulty Italy faced in becoming more than a collection of disparate regions. Inspired by sites related to the Risorgimento, the Touring Club Italiano—founded in the 1890s—encouraged Italians to travel, initially by bicycle, in their own country. It came to offer maps, guidebooks, and extensive literature. Travel by Italians within their nation took a dark turn with the arrival of Fascism in 1922, bringing Mussolini's promotion of tourism to bolster his regime. The tourism on a mass scale that began in the 1950s, by Americans and others, partially overcame the horrors of World War II and its aftermath of poverty. The postwar world was ready for the theme that defined Italy as a destination: the lazy, beautiful land of la dolce vita.
What follows these narratives is one of this book's most creative turns: an examination of the simulacra of Italy, found in New Orleans, Las Vegas, Tokyo, Dubai, a suburban California subdivision—and even a fake Tuscan village in Tuscany. Although the author's theoretical language can be a bit off-putting to the uninitiated, the details she reveals about these varied sites of an “Italy” imitated for largely commercial purposes are fascinating and offer insights into contemporary commercial culture across international boundaries.
For this historian, Hom's grounding in literary studies does cause some problems, as current practices within her academic field are at variance with history's traditional norms as a discipline. Contemporary literary studies seem to allow imaginative flights and wordplay. For example, in discussing souvenirs, the author likens tourist clothing, such as a “Ciao Bella” T-shirt, to a “funerary garment” for the “corpse of the tourist as subject who ceases to exist” at the end of the vacation (p. 192). Hom's use of uncommon words where common ones might suffice requires recurring trips to the dictionary. Perhaps due to the author's reliance on authorities, one finds some exaggeration. While Umberto Eco states that Disneyland is an “imitative machine that sustains a hallucinatory confusion between copy and original,” observation suggests that many adult visitors are aware of the fiction and may even take it as a joke (p. 17). Finally, the political thrust of much contemporary literary criticism creates a dissonance between this book's loving description and intelligent discussion of historical developments, on the one hand, and the expressions of antiglobalization that pepper the book and frame its conclusion, on the other.
Nonetheless, the gains to be had from reading The Beautiful Country are well worth the effort of engaging with it, for the book is a fresh and fascinating case study. Hom offers a convincing argument about the power of the tourist imaginary. She provides a rich history of travel to and within Italy. And she makes readers aware of the many artificial environments around the world designed to draw on Italy's allure.
