Maria Gaetana Agnesi (1718–99) was special, but certainly not unique. As a wealthy woman living in the environs of early eighteenth-century Milan, she was privy to social and political opportunities that had opened up as a result of the Catholic Enlightenment. In The World of Maria Gaetana Agnesi, Mathematician of God, Massimo Mazzotti describes the social order within which supporters of the Catholic Enlightenment (including, key among them, Pope Benedict XIV) sought to extend the Church's influence by bringing within its fold previously marginalized groups, such as women. As a part of this regional Enlightenment and extension, the church lauded female scholars and allowed them to study the ‘sublime’ sciences. In some instances, it even encouraged their entry into the university setting at a professional level. As a case in point, Laura Bassi was appointed as a paid professor of anatomy at the University of Bologna in 1731. The pontiff later appointed Gaetana lectrice honoraria at the same institution following the 1748 publication of her Instituzioni analitiche, a textbook on the differential and integral calculus. Thanks to other similar appointments, Bologna became known as a new ‘paradise of women’.
Similarly, in Milan – where Gaetana had been born and tutored – the Catholic Enlightenment was expressed in social institutions aimed at the education of women. For example, Gaetana gained access to advanced tutoring in her childhood as a result of her father's personal hope that in advancing her intellectual standing he would be able to buoy his own social advancement. Thus Gaetana studied metaphysics, natural philosophy and mathematics, including the new analysis. Simultaneously, Gaetana was involved in social events known as conversazione, which saw her frequently engaged in public disputations on varied philosophical subjects. In addition, a number of Gaetana's written works were published by her father, culminating in the widely reviewed and highly acclaimed Instituzioni analitiche. The fact, therefore, that a female Catholic born in the early 1700s could become the highly celebrated author of a calculus textbook should not evoke surprise or lead to the conclusion that hers was an aberrant career. Rather, it should serve to highlight the key features of the Catholic Enlightenment that allowed for the creation of spaces in which women could participate at an advanced level in natural philosophy and mathematics.
Mazzotti's book is an elaboration of his earlier article ‘Maria Gaetana Agnesi: mathematics and the making of the Catholic Enlightenment’ (Isis (2001), 92, 657–83). Yet, contrary to what the titles of the article and book might suggest, Mazzotti's works are not primarily histories of mathematics. Nowhere in the book, for example, is there a detailed description of Gaetana's actual mathematics, apart from her view (similar to those held by many Continental and British mathematicians at the time) that the Leibnizian differential and Newtonian fluxion were equivalent. Notably, Mazzotti does offer the reader an interesting account of how a particular curve associated with Gaetana's name was poorly translated in a later English edition of her textbook. In his 1801 translation, John Colson mistakenly used the word ‘witch’ (from avversiera) to identify the curve. In fact, Gaetana had used the word versiera, from the Latin versare (‘to turn’). Yet, apart from this account of the mistranslation of her curve, the reader is not given much by way of Gaetana's mathematical writing. In fact, the reader is left wondering what the Agnesi curve looks like – an image taken from Gaetana's text would have been useful – and how it is that Gaetana analysed the curve (one might assume that she applied her typically synthetic geometrical approach, but few details are provided to justify or elaborate upon that likelihood). If there is one fault with Mazzotti's contribution, it is that a more detailed account of Gaetana's mathematics is missing.
In fairness, Mazzotti nowhere claims to be offering a social history of mathematics. As his title suggests, his is a book about the society within which Gaetana lived, operated and developed. Accordingly, he offers his readers an account of early eighteenth-century Milan, with its particular set of political, religious and sexual norms. He also offers an account of the ideology underpinning the Catholic Enlightenment – namely a Cartesian–Malebranchian division between the mind (including the ‘spiritual’ and ‘intellectual’ self) and the ‘body’ (including the woman's reproductive components) – which allowed the Church to support filosofesse such as Gaetana and Bassi.
Furthermore, the subtitle of the book, ‘Mathematician of God’, is well served by Mazzotti's focus on Gaetana's religious interpretations of the new analysis. Contrary to many of her Continental contemporaries, Gaetana presented analytical techniques as fundamentally geometrical in nature. In her opinion, geometry offered a window to absolute certainty and thus a nugget of spiritual truth. Importantly, she refused to include any discussion of the most common physical applications of the calculus, because to have done so would have meant introducing impure empirical elements into a discussion of mathematical certainty. Hers was not only a work in the new analysis, therefore, but also a work in correct religious belief. Mazzotti demonstrates this point poignantly.
As detailed in the final chapter, ‘A new female mind’, the relative academic freedom Gaetana and her female contemporaries enjoyed began to lessen by the middle of the century. As early as the 1720s, natural philosophers such as Antonio Conti had begun to emphasize the physiological weakness of women's reproductive structures, which apparently inhibited their intellectual development. By the 1770s, such misogynistic physiologies had become interwoven with emergent religious and moral philosophies that viewed independently educated women as a serious threat to social order. By the time Gaetana died in 1799, the Catholic Enlightenment that had nurtured her scientific and mathematical interests in the early part of the century had drawn to a close. Mazzotti's account of the rise and fall of a relatively non-gendered intellectual environment in the early eighteenth century thus sheds light on a rare instance in which the Catholic Church actually advocated women's equality. The strangeness of that phenomenon alone renders his work an interesting addition to the history of science.
