The author of a series of articles tracking the peregrinations of activists whose roots lie in the Indian subcontinent in the 19th century, Seema Alavi already seems set to make a lasting contribution to the burgeoning field of Islamicate connections across the Indian Ocean and the interrelated Indo–Persian world. In many ways this volume is the summation of work that posits an Islamic cosmopolitanism founded in the world of “gentleman-scholars” (as Alavi terms them) literate in Urdu, Persian, and Arabic. Not only did they cross between empires, as they sought refuge and patronage, but in later instances they made active use of the presses of Istanbul, Cairo, and Bombay to make their arguments about what constituted attested Islamic practice, how Islam trumped allegedly mistaken Western understandings of Christianity, or even how the properly educated Muslim subject belonged to a greater community.
Having thrust us into a convoluted world where reformist scholars were intimately linked to rulers and merchants with connections well beyond any imperial boundary, Alavi commences her survey with Sayyid Fadl of Malabar (1820–1901), who was exiled by the British in the 1850s and later sought Ottoman sanction to claim the port of Dhofar from the Omanis. Next is the dispossessed Rahmatullah Kayranawi (1818–91), who sought shelter in Mecca after the Indian Uprising of 1857. There he wrote anti-Christian polemics in praise of the Ottoman sultan and established a school with the support of Begum Sawlat al-Nisaʾ of Mysore. This school also served as a refuge for the erstwhile ascetic of Bayana, Imdadullah Makki (1817–99), who would write numerous tracts in the Holy City that Alavi announces in her chapter title to be the “cradle of Muslim cosmopolitanism.” Then comes the advantageously married Nawab Siddiq Hasan Khan (1832–90), whose position as prince consort of Bhopal allowed him to publish works defending what the British saw as “Wahabi [sic]” polemics that enshrined the principle of jihad. That said, his defenders claimed he was merely quoting the works of others in which jihad was discussed and subsequent editions would be redacted in light of British charges. Next in line for treatment is Mawlana Jaʿfar Thanesari (1838–1905), whose links with the mujahidin of Afghanistan in the 1860s would lead to years of exile (and scribal employment) in the Andamans, where he produced an interesting autobiography. The conclusion, meanwhile, is largely a cloak for a discussion of the brief and ineffectual schemes of the deposed Sikh Maharaja of Punjab, Dalip Singh (1838–93), who plotted a return to power from Moscow.
On the face of this we have a story of great potential, charting the emergence of a distinctive South Asian school of exilic anticolonial thought born of interactions with Salafi thinking in the wider Middle East and drawn from a rich body of sources in Islamic works and Foreign Office files alike. Before turning to these sources and their deployment, however, I should state that I was unsure of the conceptualization of Muslim cosmopolitanism and the seemingly paradoxical role played by European power in facilitating its spread. While it is true that print hastened a new culture of reading and personal approaches to scripture, the linkages were often there before or even regardless of European intrusion. Sometimes this was a story of fight and flight, to be sure, and several of the individuals described by Alavi did flee British power in India and remake their careers in Ottoman territories. Even so, in her hands the chronologies are so loose and the geography so amorphous that it is hard to follow the story or indeed to trust the information that is presented, particularly as it relates to Southeast Asia, which was not South Asia writ small. Alavi seems unaware, for instance, that the Acehnese were not rebels against the Dutch before 1873 and that few Southeast Asians in Mecca and Cairo were “runaways” (p. 224). In many cases the Europeans had nothing whatsoever to do with the story of connection across the Indian Ocean. Setting aside the fact that Muhammad bin ʿAbd al-Wahhab was not a freedom fighter against British aggression as Alavi claims (p. 294), much of the narrative arc of the volume depends on a blanket claim about 19th-century thinking in the mold of Shah Wali Allah (1703–62). As Alavi has it, there had been a shift “to the idea of the individual Arabicist Naqshbandi tradition of Shahwaliulla” who “signatured [sic] a specific brand of Arabicism that stressed Muslim exclusivity via unity and compromise between the more liberal Sufi saint Ibn-i-Arabi and the conservative Naqshbandi Sufi sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi” (p. 33).
I am not sure that this is proven. Indeed there is seldom clear attention paid to the discursive contents of the texts written by Alavi's unitarians, though the wilder misconceptions of Kayranawi (including that there were three original manuscripts of the Bible) are adduced as evidence of cosmopolitan thinking by a man who believed that he was versed in the chapters of Polius (assumedly Paul) and the writings of the mysterious “Kini Scott” (p. 203). This seems odd. Indeed the notion of a cosmopolitanism founded in explicit opposition to religions other than Islam seems to undermine the power of the argument. Are cosmopolitanisms now as multiple as modernities?
Setting this larger question aside, the volume is hampered by a density of repetitive prose that make it hard to determine chronologies. Sayyid Fadl, who appears as an archetype in some respects, seems to annex Dhofar at several points and one has little sense of his religious, let alone reformist, proclivities. One might also wonder whether the paranoid writings of officials concerning the existence of secret societies in Mecca should have been elevated to the level of evidence. Certainly the work would have benefitted from a more cautious attitude toward literary and archival material.
Part of the problem lies in the overlapping British sources in which officials worried about any destabilizing contagion, be it cholera or fanaticism. One might speculate that the colonial nomenclature of the 1860s that saw Wahhabism in evidence stemmed from the critiques of reformists by anxious local Sufis, though Alavi drops the scare quotes around the word Wahabi [sic] by the end of the book and offers the most curious of formulae concerning the salafiyya—namely that they “advocated reason, rationality, and Sufi doctrine” (p. 180). This only lends force to an anxiety already caused by the handling of technical terms and names (biddat for bidʿa, qirrat for qirāʾa, darrs for dars, and Ab-dal Wahab for Muhammad b. ʿAbd al-Wahhab). Setting the hamzas and other orthographic missteps aside, though, book titles are frequently mistranslated, and Alavi seems unaware that the position of Sufi khalīfa is not a claim against the Ottoman office (p. 304), that “Sheikh al Muslamin [sic]” is not the personal name of a Sharif of Mecca (p. 196), that Ibn Saʿud should not be accorded the rank of prophet (p. 281), and that the first words of the shahāda “La Ilaha” cannot be rendered as “One Allah” (p. 236).
What is clear, then, is that this book does not reflect well on the editorial process. Somebody must surely have been in a position to point these errors out, to tighten the argument, and to reign in the excessive prose. But they did not. This is a real pity, as there is a fascinating story in all this.
