The passing of the Trump presidency has left much of the academic world in a state of PTSD. “How could this have happened?” we ask in delayed shock. “Has the virus merely been suppressed?” It seems the right moment to ask ourselves fundamental questions, and the publication of The Routledge Companion to Theatre and Performance Historiography, a collection of twenty-four essays meticulously edited by Tracy Davis (Northwestern University) and Peter Marx (University of Cologne), is a handy prompt to think about what our discipline is offering to the world. If indeed discipline it be. Tom Postlewait published in 2009 a methodological Bible for theatre history, considered as a subset of the broader discipline of history, that is, “the pursuit of truths about the past within the conditions and constraints of possible knowledge.”Footnote 1 Claire Cochrane and Jo Robinson, in their 2019 Methuen Drama Handbook of Theatre History and Historiography, were less confident, suggesting that theatre historians should abandon the term “discipline” in favor of “discourse,” provided always that rigor and self-reflexivity are maintained, because too many different kinds of knowledge are entailed.Footnote 2 In order to lay bare the project of the Routledge Companion, I will begin by unpacking its full title.
The. Not just any old companion. Will this be the Routledge companion, offering a suggested way into the subject overtly different from, say, the Methuen alternative? Or does the voice fall more authoritatively upon the last word, Historiography, saying, as it were, “Hey, students, it's the 2020s, and this is what you now have to do?” The emphasis can perhaps be found in the Introduction in which the editors seek “to recreate wholesale what will be the next generation's received narrative” (25).
Routledge. An imprint of the Taylor & Francis publishing group, which is in turn part of Informa PLC, a multinational information company based in London with offices in Australia, Singapore, Switzerland, Hong Kong, China, South Korea, Malaysia, Netherlands, South Africa, Taiwan, Vietnam, the UAE, and the United States. Informa shifted its tax liabilities to Switzerland in protest against the tax policies of the last Labour government but has now returned, unlike the holding company of Palgrave Macmillan. Given these structures of economic power and the lack of hold national governments have on our lives, it makes sense for historians to adopt a perspective that reflects the globalized postnational environment in which they are forced to operate.
Companion. Back in in the eighteenth century I could have bought a pocket companion to carry around architectural sites, catch up on songs from light opera, or even flick through a geographical overview of “the habitable world.”Footnote 3 The word “companion” suggests a held-in-the-hand object (like the cognate term “handbook”) that will steer me through complex terrain. To handle a physical copy of the Routledge Companion now feels an odd thing to do, since the book is designed to be consulted onscreen and will normally be consumed piecemeal. How could I afford to buy such an object? Why would I bother to pull it off a library shelf? No copy landed on the desk of the Theatre Survey Book Review Editor, and his persistence was needed to secure one, while I persisted in asking for one because the printed format yields a different form of reading. The context was similar for the six-volume Bloomsbury Cultural History of Theatre, where Christopher Balme and Tracy Davis, as general editors, were obliged to follow an ingenious formula devised by the publisher that allows the online reader to read diachronically across time frames as well as synchronically within a time frame.Footnote 4 There is a seductive freedom in study that allows readers to go anywhere they choose, but there is a price in terms of losing any one sustained linear narrative. Editors today are tied to frameworks not of their making.
Theatre. While Peter Marx works with an expansive German definition of Theater (within the academic tradition of Theaterwissenschaft),Footnote 5 Tracy Davis engages with a narrower US understanding of “theatre” rooted in text-based curricula and activities contained by Broadway or campus arts centers, and for that reason reaches out for “performance” as a category that is not theatre and is culturally more inclusive. Much of the spark in this volume derives from the encounter between these European and American cultural perspectives. Cochrane and Robinson, like Christine Dymkowski and me in our Cambridge Companion to Theatre History (2012),Footnote 6 strove to internationalize while holding resolutely to the anchoring concept of “theatre” in what may in hindsight look like an impossible British attempt to square a circle. The term “theatre” was used in antiquity for the auditorium and not the artistic medium, and only subsequently accrued connotations of genre in English and European languages, which could seem like an imposition when foisted on the rest of the world. Steve Tillis in The Challenge of World Theatre History (2020) takes his cue from economic and political historians to insist that a global history of theatre can indeed be written, but he is able to do this only through starting from the premise that there is a constant called “dramatic theatre.”Footnote 7 Tillis's concept of theatre as “make-believe” can be tracked back to Aristotelian assumptions about mimesis, assumptions contested by Davis and Marx, as also by actors who say that “acting” is more a matter of presence than pretending (5).
And. This conjunction is the most important word in the title, because every essay tries to conjunct the obstinately singular category of “theatre” with the obstinately expansive category of “performance” to create a multifarious but singular field of study. The editors identify an “Oedipal tussle” between two existing modern disciplines of theatre studies and performance studies, but never make clear the nature of the brave new academic world toward which this companion hopes to guide them (7). For Davis, the disciplinary schism first sparked in the 1970s and then flared in the 1990s, and she celebrates the present “historiographic opportunity that arises from the resulting pluralism” (119). However, when Marx writes that “performance and theatre are privileged places for societies to act out the impact of time passing, to highlight changes, or to provide anachronistic elements as a consolation against time and change,” he seems to argue less for disciplinary pluralism than for an updated version of Theaterwissenschaft (344).
Performance. Davis grounds her definition of performance in the spatial metaphor of “setasidedness,” extrapolated from Victor Turner, and anthropology becomes the parent discipline that supplants literature and history as the preferred interlocutor for scholars of theatre/performance (119). Although Turner famously inspired and collaborated with Richard Schechner, Davis does not follow Schechner's route, which drew performance studies from the idea of reperformance back to his own favored forms of radical theatrical practice. Because Davis and Marx focus on connections rather than definitions, I found myself searching the book as a whole in an effort to grasp what the word “performance” means for the scholars gathered in this enterprise. Marvin Carlson's Performance, now in its magisterial third edition, pulls together many different intellectual strands caught up by this contested word, and some resonate in this volume, although some do not.Footnote 8 Broadly, the volume is not concerned with the interface between text and performance and the related art of the actor, the terrain that I have dug for most of my career, nor is it concerned with performance in private life in the areas explored by such diverse figures as Erving Goffman, Judith Butler, and J. L. Austin, which raise ontological questions about human identity. Its focus lies rather in festivals and other forms of social drama acted out in the middle ground of public life, with theatre sitting at one end of a spectrum.
Historiography. Cochrane and Robinson opted for two separate terms, history and historiography, to catch the complex relation among events in the world out there, the human activity of describing those events, and the metareflection of historians upon their activity. Davis and Marx assume there can be no simple separation of these terms, and each chapter explores a historiographic issue by, so to speak, doing a bit of history. The editors in their joint-authored Introduction speak “as historians” about what is gained by “re-examining a past with greater performative inclusivity” (7) and Davis subsequently describes herself thinking “as a historian with the insights of ethnography,” with the proviso that performance complicates intelligibility, and thus the ability to weigh evidence, reconstruct, and narrate, which “are part of the art and craft of history” (126–7). For Daniel Woolf, in A Global History of History, postcolonial concerns throw up the fundamental problem that “the European-descended Western form of historiography, complete with its academic and professional institutions, has achieved dominance over other forms of writing or thinking about the past.”Footnote 9 Although there are hints in this companion that performance might open a new mode of historiography, as distinct from a new object of historiography, the academic idiom in which this book is written is, in Woolf's terms, “European-descended.”
Christopher Balme's valuable contribution to the volume describes an “epistemic community” in the late 1940s that embraced theatre scholars, practitioners, and many others while committing to the modernist principle that theatre is an art form capable of transcending national boundaries. He explores both the power of that conceptual model and the strains it has undergone. Balme's phrase is a useful one, and prompts the question: What epistemic community is constituted by the scholars gathered for this volume? What kind of knowledge do they want to produce? Although I sense a commonality of concern, I discern no gurus, nor indeed a common enemy. There have been periods when academic fashion dictated that all arguments should be referred back to the seminal work of, for example, Michel Foucault, or Pierre Bourdieu, or Schechner, a demand that felt on the one hand oppressive and on the other useful because it created a common vocabulary that allowed debate. Today there is no longer any such reference point, a feature shared by other disciplinary domains.Footnote 10 One could say that the contributors to this volume have all sought their own preferred products in the rich marketplace of ideas. Or we might do better to pick up Carlson's prophetic vision that any attempt to write global theatre history must henceforth be rhizomatic rather than linear. There seem indeed to be invisible common roots feeding what we see on the page, stimulated in real terms by Internet conversations and flights to international conferences. But what kind of episteme is being produced by this community?
The two most compelling chapters, for me, were those written by Bishnupriya Dutt and Rashna Nicholson, two scholars of Indian theatre and performance, because from their perspective the issues addressed by this volume have a deep urgency. The colonial legacy of theatre has become part of secular liberal modern India and cannot simply be discarded, even as the centralizing government in Delhi has an investment in the traditions of non-Western Sanskrit theatre and local communitarian interests press another idea of performance that is at times hostile to the values embedded in the received procedures of academic reasoning, so the search for a “theatre of roots” necessarily becomes contentious.Footnote 11 In the United States and Germany, the stakes seem less high than they are in India. In the United States, over and above turf wars in the academy, the diversity agenda cries out and on one level relates to the material question of who gets academic jobs. In regard to the culture wars that have been tearing the United States apart, however, both the contributors to this volume and “traditional” historians beavering away at the dimensions of the Globe Theatre are likely to find themselves on the same liberal, cosmopolitan side of the front line. German contributions to the volume, like Stefan Hulfeld's on the 1848 uprising on the streets of Vienna, suggest a more time-honored battle by resisting the elitist values of Kultur in favor of a more inclusive popular culture. In contrast to the moral confidence that drives the American politics of diversity, Dutt and Nicholson express a certain anguish that they have no straightforward answers to the predicament they face. The issue for Dutt is that the study of performance, as manifested by communal folk forms, seems to require an ethnographic methodology, whereas theatre lends itself to historical analysis; Dipesh Chakrabarty's critique of historicism as a product of “Europe” lies in the background.Footnote 12 How then do you do a historical ethnography in order to break down the intertwined binaries of performance–theatre and ethnography–historiography? Oral history, perhaps? Dutt only has space to scratch the surface of an answer.
Chakrabarty repeated the principle in 2018 that “Doing history ideally is like doing anthropology of people who are gone, except that you don't have native informants, you only have these written fragmentary sources. But the same hermeneutic struggle goes on: you're trying to understand somebody from their point of view.”Footnote 13 In a classic essay of 1980, the anthropologist Bernard Cohn mapped striking cultural differences between the inhabitants of Anthropologyland and Historyland.Footnote 14 Although the historian's continuum of time and reliance on the archive is not easily reconciled with the ethnographer's continuum of space and reliance on observation, preeminent historians—E. P. Thompson, Natalie Zemon Davis, and Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, for example—have in a sense been practicing the ethnographic method for years. It all depends how you define ethnography, with local ethnographic studies needing to be harnessed to anthropological theory in order to have wider application. The epistemic community sampled by this volume does not seem to me much engaged by epistemological conversations going on in other disciplines, which is understandable enough, for academia is becoming ever more tribal. Everyone declares a belief in interdisciplinarity, more or less a synonym for liberalism, but at the end of day, why would you ask a historian or an anthropologist to adjudicate a publication or a research grant that falls in “our” territory? Would you trust them? Would they understand?
Nicholson explores in her essay how the Ford Foundation has subsidized and fostered within India, alongside intercultural artistic activity, a series of historicizing agendas. She explains that European and US agencies have engaged in “the performance of a liberal sensibility,” and that in consequence, “In this fetishisation of an individual rights-based approach to development through culture, structural inequalities are dissociated from regional conflict, broader economic growth, uneven power formations, and political causes. Local intellectuals are deflected from the roots of social and territorial injustices to the externalities” (200). Nicholson goes on to describe how her own efforts to write a history of Parsi theatre catch her up in procedures that she condemns. When set up as “minority history,” she explains, “Parsi drama becomes yet another symbol of liberal democracy's potential for inclusiveness and plurality and therefore loses its subversive potential, neither exposing the limits of history-writing nor calling the discipline into question” (202). She thanks the editors for “pushing me onto ground that I hesitated to tread,” and her hesitation is understandable because, of course, it calls into question the inclusivity and plurality of the present volume (202). Nicholson's research into Parsi theatre relied on German funding, and could not have been accomplished otherwise, and there seems no obvious way to break out of an enclosing circle in order to function as a historian in the modern academy.
I pull from Nicholson's analysis a fundamental problem for the modern historian of theatre/performance. How do you subscribe to the values of liberalism, individual human rights, and the politics of identity while simultaneously catching the big picture that embraces “regional conflict, broader economic growth, uneven power formations, and political causes” (200)? How do you pass beyond a mythical theatre of roots to “the roots of social and territorial injustices” (200)? The well-trodden practice of writing “microhistories” assumes the existence of a macrostory that makes these microstories signify paradigm shifts (32). The retreat from macrohistory has been driven by many factors, not just the collapse of the Whig narrative of progress, the Marxist counternarrative, and the flowering of postmodernist philosophy, but also digital technology, which demands modular volumes for students following modular syllabi and facilitates global linkups but also turns groups into self-affirming echo chambers. If I want to research “Parsi theatre,” Google will lead me unerringly to Nicholson's new monograph and a host of other relevant publications, which I must perforce read if I am to hold my head high as a professional historian, but it will not take me to the roots of social injustice. As I learn to source ever more material online during lockdown, my computer discovers more about me in order to recommend academic articles it thinks I might want to read. My choice, of course. But hard to resist.
Balme (sometime supervisor of Nicholson's Ph.D.) is the one contributor who attempts a broad sweep, and he apologizes for his “hubris” in doing so (269). His essay, “Theatre-Historical Patterns in the Global South 1950 to 1990: Transnational and Institutional Perspectives,” escapes nation-based historiography by focusing on transnational networks, and against the backdrop of the Cold War he exposes important operations of financial power. Balme's employment of the quasi-metaphorical term “Global South” gets him off the hook of having to evoke a contested dichotomy of East and West, the “developed” versus “developing” worlds, or the long discredited First World versus Third World. His use of the fashionable term of the moment blurs the uncomfortable division between an “us” and a “them,” a “we” who have the money to fund international theatre festivals and write scholarly books about theatre history, and a “them” who may be invited guests or recipients of the ethnographer's gaze. Balme's distinguished international career has given him the life experience needed to write this chapter, but the rules of academic prose mean that he has to erase himself from his narrative, and this, it seems to me, is one of the key problems when anthropology seeks to marry historiography. Having described transnational funding, Balme records in a footnote the necessary credit that “this chapter was generated with funding received from the European Research Council” (287). The historian “models” history (to use a term elaborated in Pavel Drábek's contribution), but history also models the historian.
Writing history entails a reciprocity and personal point of view that the traditions of historicism demand we obscure in the name of academic rigor. Margaret Werry tackles the issue of disciplinary conventions in the context of Maori performance and other Indigenous “worlds” by optimistically setting out how a New Zealand museum has tackled “ontological pluralism” (208, 210). Historical writing is not unlike a museum, a monument customarily set up by the empowered to fix in perpetuity a certain relationship of subject and object. Stephanie Nohelani Teves addresses the same problem from the perspective of “Native Studies” by citing Schechner's indignation when told he was engaged in an imperialist project and his protestation that “Performance Studies is an ‘anti-discipline’ founded on ongoing debate and dissent” (253). Davis and Marx are plainly open to the same charge when they claim that their “polyphonic historiography is more likely to account for cultural multiplicity that queries, rather than inscribes, hegemonic concepts” (6). Hegemony is not at the end of the day a concept but a lived experience. Any dyed-in-the-wool US Republican who happened to stumble across this book and leaf through it would, I surmise, instantly protest that the book was hegemonic (or words to that effect) and that it celebrated the culture of others while ignoring or despising her own. When the Introduction speaks of “theatre/performance history as cultural history” (5) and claims that theatre/performance orders and explains “what a given culture reveres” (6), my hypothetical Republican reader asks, “Where is my culture? Why have I been passed over here?” The concept of a “culture” is the foundation stone for any anthropological method, and it needs careful unpacking to avoid the dangerous attitude that “they” have a culture whereas “we” don't. I imagine this Republican, being something of a theatre buff, leafing through the Introduction and reading that “The idea of a singular life in art . . . has become an unfashionable unit for book-length historical writing” (19). As she casts her eyes over all the biographies lining the theatre shelf of the bookstore, she wonders, “Who are these people?” And as she slams the book shut, she is heard to mutter something like: “It's a monoculture. I can smell the DDT.” Exit the store pondering: “Plain darned truth: Where to go for that?”
Concern about hegemony drives the editors’ resistance to “the logic of any teleological or evolutionary grand récit” (5), and they explain in parenthesis that “These master narratives, such as the Renaissance or the Age of Exploration, quite common in cultural histories that focus on innovation and propel ‘progress,’ classify historical phenomena in relation to what is often tacitly set as an ideal vantage point” (5). More surprising is their rider that “Counter-histories are scarcely more defensible historiographically,” the reason being that they “eclipse the complex interplay between cultural minorities and hegemonies” (5). Counternarratives have been the stuff of historiography for centuries, and this volume both does and does not propose its own counternarrative by wanting to offer a story of the excluded while showing reluctance to weave a narrative that obliges it to define its own “vantage point.” The editors proffer the metaphor of “history as collage” to catch their ideal of a polyphonic, fragmented, and always incomplete account of the world (1). To pursue the metaphor, I understand the collage as a modernist art form that refuses flat surfaces and single-point perspective but nevertheless creates aesthetic unity through imposing a frame, often an invisible frame created by the wall of the gallery. Odai Johnson's chapter meditates on the importance of frames for historiography. Any act of writing history necessarily creates a frame, a wrought structure that sits on the flat surface of the printed page, now normally retrievable as a file onscreen.
To escape grand narratives is easier said than done. Johnson's quest for holes in the form of years omitted by the chronicler, or forgotten actors, or missing walls in 2-D images, presupposes a surface that has been holed. Natasha Korda's title, “Gyno ludens: A Doll House Redux,” assumes familiarity with Ibsen. Erith Jaffe-Berg provides a classic counternarrative by reinstating the place of Jews in the story of Italian Renaissance theatre. Michael Bachmann elucidates German radio drama in relation to the emergence of psychological interiority, which he identifies as a “cultural formation” of something called “modernity” (167), confident that this term will resonate with his readers, and he draws inspiration from the big historical pictures drawn by people like Michel Foucault, Norbert Elias, and Charles Taylor. Peter Marx tackles the issue of narrative in his chapter, “On Circulation and Recycling,” which draws on Stephen Greenblatt's concept of circulating social energies and more particularly on Hans Blumenberg's more focused concept of “reoccupation.” Blumenberg deployed the term to argue that modernity did not secularize but rather reoccupied spaces vacated by religion in a process marked by disjunction rather than continuity. Marx takes for his case study the famous climax to Kyd's Spanish Tragedy (ca. 1586), where a bereaved father sets up a play-within-a-play at court and ends by drawing back the curtain to reveal his murdered son. Traditional accounts of English theatre history mark this as a turning point: a popular hit on the new commercial stage, written by a university dramatist who drew on his classical education to write a tragedy that helped to shape Hamlet and the future course of English dramatic literature. Although the speech that Marx quotes alludes to a notorious reveal scene staged by Greek tragedy, Marx presents it as the recirculation or reoccupation of something that predates Renaissance scholarship, the resurrection rite performed in churches when a curtain covering the altar was drawn back (328–35). If we accept this interpretation, leaving aside any argument about evidence, we remain on traditional ground because it is a common trope that Shakespeare incorporated medieval elements. The recirculated motif merely emphasizes what has changed, for death no longer brings the old certainty of cosmic justice in the afterlife. Marx uses his case study to point out “the epistemological, cultural, and political change that came with the Reformation” (335). When he turns from The Spanish Tragedy to popular eighteenth-century puppetry, his reference point is inevitably “the Enlightenment” (336–7).
I conclude, therefore, that readers of this journal can rest in their beds if they are worried that this Routledge Companion sounds a death knell for their time-honored craft as theatre historians, for there is still evidently room for the old organizing concepts of Reformation, Renaissance, and modernity. In my experience, and I have undoubtedly been guilty of this myself many times, theatre historians like to preach to their students about the iniquities of the received narrative even though those students have no grasp of what the narrative is that they are supposed to have received. The obvious answer, envisioned by this volume, is a retreat from the old discourse of contestation, so students no longer feel disempowered by their ignorance and vulnerable to the charge that they may have accidentally reproduced some morally unacceptable populist narrative. It is an obvious answer, but does not feel like an empowering answer.
The problem with retreating from the grand récit is that we live in a troubled world that needs big historical stories. To understand European and American racism requires a narrative that covers slavery (among other things), which in turn tracks back to mercantile imperialism. The way to break patterns is to understand how they are repeated in the present. The rise of the ethnonationalist Right needs an explanatory narrative if it is to be addressed rather than cast aside as mere stupidity. The mob that invaded the US Capitol on 6 January 2021 must have either lost its moral anchor in collective historical memories of how democracy was once secured, or else reprocessed as a malleable fiction the heroic history of the founding fathers. Ethnonationalism depends upon a dehistoricized sense of the past, so the “folk” can be constructed as a timeless entity untouched by migration. I am troubled, from that point of view, by the way Davis places Carl Niessen as a pioneer of performance studies because of the huge archive of materials from diverse cultures that Niessen assembled in Cologne as manifestations of Theater (130–6). Niessen also contributed to theatre history by devising the Thingspiel, a form of choric folk theatre set up by the Nazis to transpose history into Germanic myth.Footnote 15 By collecting archival objects and images from across the globe, Niessen drained them of their historicity, and that perspective can feed into real-world consequences.
Chakrabarty looks set to be a seminal figure in moving the historian's agenda onward from postcolonialism to the truly big story of climate change and the survival of our species.Footnote 16 This historical narrative potentially stretches back before the Anthropocene, and might feature the human race as a single actor in the drama, or might focus on the battle between rich and poor for wealth or survival. It is not immediately clear how theatre/performance history is going to be part of this big story, and the ecologically themed virtual conference of the International Federation for Theatre Research in 2021 may or may not have provided answers. We don't yet know. My point is that human beings need to place themselves within big stories based on the weighing of evidence in order to address their future successfully. Women's liberation, the class war, colonialism, climate—the big story moves on with increasing speed. I see history as a kind of public memory, memory being an adaptive evolutionary function that evolved not to record everything that happened but to retrieve key information relevant to fitness and survival.Footnote 17 The editors have a vision of “history as collage,” which emphasizes multiplicity and fragmentation, but it seems to me there is a danger if historians lose the confidence, permission, or professional incentive to pass through complexity and join up data to mold a bigger story.
Confidence is an important part of it. When I entered the world of theatre studies some forty years ago, a sense of moral urgency led many of us to set off in search of a thing called “authentic popular theatre,” defying complaints about the way we ignored “good plays.” That movement rested upon a solid Marxist philosophical tradition and a plausible analysis of the world as it then was in terms of social class. In the Routledge Companion, diversity has substituted for class in a world that has manifestly changed. I recognize a similarity of ethical drive but a difference in the lack of any shared philosophical foundation, liberalism and humanism being neither accepted nor openly contested as shaping ideals, and I don't discern any hopeful vision of how a more democratic world might, in practice, function. The discipline of “rigorous” academic standards provides security in this uncertain world, but also feels like a straitjacket because it imposes a singularity that overwhelms any celebration of polyphonic diversity. In a text that has inspired many modern anthropologists, Paul Stoller observes that “models and metaphors constructed by the likes of Foucault and Butler powerfully deconstruct the Cartesian edifice. But concomitantly their bloodless language reinforces the very principle they critique.”Footnote 18 Exponents of practice-as-research in theatre studies have done much to open up Enlightenment assumptions about what constitutes an appropriate scientific or rational language for academic discourse.Footnote 19
I am of course caught up in the predicament that I'm describing here, and although I see no clear answers, something in my gut (a product of evolution?) tells me I need to insist on the importance of history, that is, telling stories about the past so we can adapt to the future. This volume insists, rightly, that the term “theatre” needs to be challenged repeatedly because of the cultural assumptions and power relationships embedded in it. Yet there is a paradox here: it is the very constancy of the term “theatre” that permits historical analysis precisely because it allows us to trace how its meanings and practices shift, contest earlier frameworks of thought, and use theatre as a lens upon wider cultural shifts. “Performance,” as used in this book, is a term that invites comparative ethnographic analysis (“let's look at how these people see and conceive the world”), but is resistant to historical analysis (“here's how and why situation A changes into situation B”). The ideal that we should submit the past to an ethnographic gaze is a fine one, but insufficient until we shine a light on the person of the would-be authoritative anthropologist and the disciplinary premises that govern her work. Is empathy allowable? Is agency individual or collective? To invoke “ethnography” is just a starting point.
I have attempted in this review to use The Routledge Companion to Theatre and Performance Historiography as an artifact that serves as the access point for a brief ethnographic study of the inhabitants of Theatreperformanceland. I have reflected on the authority structures and cross-border forays of these inhabitants and asked what common language they use to converse with the people or peoples of Historyland. Because of my disciplinary bias, I have striven to read this book as a record of performances, including oral performances at symposia and rites of doctoral passage, and as a rubric for future performances. I have found myself often exhilarated by the way the imaginations of these inhabitants extend to all corners of the globe. The precise nature of their core belief system continues to elude me, and it may be that I'm using an inappropriate academic discourse. I look forward to future research in this field.
