Introduction
Progressive, bilateral, sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is not routinely investigated with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). This case report presents a patient with bilateral SNHL for whom MRI was diagnostic.
Case report
A 53-year-old man with bilateral, symmetrical SNHL had been followed at a rural hospital since early 2000 with serial audiometry (Figure 1). He had begun wearing hearing aids later that year. In April 2004, he had reported worsening tinnitus and rapid progression of his hearing loss, and hearing aids were no longer effective.
On close questioning, the patient reported that his balance had deteriorated over the previous 18 months. Several falls had prevented him from participating in his primary recreational activity, cross-country running. He had intermittent, right-sided, temporoparietal headaches and his sense of smell had deteriorated, but he had no other neurological symptoms.
Serial pure tone audiometry.
Examination showed intact and mobile tympanic membranes with apparently normal middle ears. There was no spontaneous nystagmus. The patient fell to both sides during stressed Romberg testing and Unterberger's stepping testing. Rapid alternating movements were slowed in the hands, right worse than left. Heel–shin coordination was moderately impaired bilaterally. Examination was otherwise unremarkable.
Audiometry confirmed rapid progression of the patient's bilateral SNHL (Figure 1).
Due to the clinical presentation, a MRI scan was performed (Figures 2 to 4). On initial T2-weighted imaging, a very low signal was noted (particularly around the basal cisterns, brainstem and cerebellum) consistent with moderately pronounced leptomeningeal haemosiderosis. In view of these findings, we obtained axial T1-weighted and coronal gradient T2-weighted MRI sequences and an intracranial magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) scan. No abnormality was seen in either cerebellopontine angle or internal auditory canal. The VIIth and VIIIth cranial nerves were normal, as was the remainder of the central nervous system. The MRA demonstrated a small (less than 2 mm) side wall aneurysm from the cavernous portion of the left internal carotid artery. No bleeding point was identified.
Axial, T2-weighted magnetic resonance image demonstrating a hypointense rim surrounding the cerebellum (arrow).
Axial, three-dimensional magnetic resonance image demonstrating a hypointense rim surrounding the cerebellum and the right VIIth/VIIIth cranial nerve complex.
Coronal, gradient-echo magnetic resonance image demonstrating a hypointense rim on the posterior aspect of the midbrain (arrow).
A neurology opinion was obtained. A cerebral angiogram and MRI scans of the temporal bones and spine were performed but did not pinpoint a bleeding source. The patient was commenced on tranexamic acid.
Further audiological testing showed absent distortion product otoacoustic emissions bilaterally. HINT (Hearing In Noise Testing) sentence testing was undertaken; the results were auditory visual 41 per cent, auditory alone 17 per cent and visual alone 12 per cent.
Cochlear implantation was decided upon, with appropriate counselling of the patient regarding a variable outcome of the procedure. The surgery was uneventful.
When the implant was switched on, the patient was able to distinguish sound and to achieve 25 per cent on HINT sentences (audiovisual). This improved to 46 per cent two months later.
Unfortunately, approximately four months after the procedure there was a significant reduction in implant performance. This coincided with a deterioration in the patient's balance and a fall from his bicycle.
At six months post-surgery, he had a further fall from his bicycle, and noticed further hearing deterioration at around this time. For some time, he was unable to detect sound at all. Integrity testing at this time confirmed a functioning implant, and imaging confirmed no change in electrode position. Progressive neural deterioration was assumed to be the aetiology of the hearing loss.
At the patient's most recent follow up, it was possible to map six electrodes at the basal end of the array only, and he was able to use sound as an adjunct to lip-reading.
Discussion
Haemosiderosis is an uncommon disease characterised by the deposition of haemosiderin in body tissues. When it occurs in the central nervous system (CNS), it is known as leptomeningeal haemosiderosis or superficial siderosis of the CNS. Leptomeningeal haemosiderosis was first described in 1908 when an autopsy case report was presented to the Chicago Neurological Society.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 The first ante-mortem diagnosis was made on surgical biopsy in 1965.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 There have been just over 100 cases reported in the literature to date, with more published since the advent of non-invasive ante-mortem diagnosis with MRI. The best estimate to date of the prevalence of symptomatic leptomeningeal haemosiderosis is 0.05 per cent.Reference Offenbacher, Fazekas, Schmidt, Alexandra, D Scott and Philip A2
It is generally held that leptomeningeal haemosiderosis results from recurrent or chronic bleeding into the subarachnoid space.Reference Grunshaw, Blanshard, Hussain and Grace3–Reference Koeppen, Dickson, Chu and Thach7 This is only symptomatic in 37 per cent of cases.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 Some authors hypothesise that leptomeningeal haemosiderosis may occur due to an inability to metabolise blood in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).Reference Offenbacher, Fazekas, Schmidt, Alexandra, D Scott and Philip A2, Reference Longridge8 The condition is potentially treatable when a bleeding point is located; however, approximately half the reported cases had no known bleeding source.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference Hughes and Oppenheimer4, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Stevens, Peterson, Grodd, Poremba and Dichgans10 The most commonly identified aetiologies are dural pathology, tumours and vascular anomalies.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference Grunshaw, Blanshard, Hussain and Grace3, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Mascalchi, Salvi, Pirini, D'Errico, Ferlini and Colli11–Reference Li, Haroun, Clatterbuck, Murphy and Rigamonti13
The leptomeninges comprise the pia and arachnoid mater. The pia mater is firmly adherent to the glial capsule of the CNS. In leptomeningeal haemosiderosis, microscopic changes (including both intracellular and extracellular haemosiderin deposition) occur on the surface of CNS structures, with resulting neuronal loss, reactive gliosis and demyelination.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference Hughes and Oppenheimer4, Reference Koeppen and Barron5, Reference Revesz, Earl and Barnard14 Haemosiderin formation occurs mainly within microglia as they synthesise ferritin, so Haemosiderin is taken up selectively by CNS areas rich in microglia and areas close to CSF flow.Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9
This accounts for the particular vulnerability of the leptomeninges, subpial and subependymal tissue of the cerebral hemispheres, cerebellum, brainstem, spinal cord and cranial nerves.Reference Hughes and Oppenheimer4, Reference Koeppem and Dentinger6, Reference Koeppen, Dickson, Chu and Thach7, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Revesz, Earl and Barnard14, Reference Anderson, Sheffield and Hope15 The VIIIth cranial nerve has a long glial segment, which may predispose it to involvement in leptomeningeal haemosiderosis, compared with other cranial nerves, which have their glial Schwann cell junction close to the brainstem.Reference Koeppem and Dentinger6, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Courville16 In contrast, systemic haemochromatosis (due to overloading of red blood cell breakdown products in the bloodstream) results in haemosiderin deposition in the epithelium of the choroid plexus, tuber cinereum and area postrema, but not in the subpial tissue or leptomeninges.Reference Hughes and Oppenheimer4
The most common clinical presentation of leptomeningeal haemosiderosis is a male patientReference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 with asymmetrical SNHL, progressing variably to profound deafness.Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Kwartlet, De La Cruz and Lo17 Hearing loss is reported in 95 per cent of patients.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 Imbalance is the next most common feature (88 per cent), usually cerebellar ataxia.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 There are case reports of complete vestibular failure.Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9 Myelopathy, or pyramidal tract signs, such as weakness, spasticity, hyperreflexia and loss of discrete finger–hand movements, occurs in 76 per cent of patients.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 Anosmia occurs in at least 17 per cent of cases.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 However, leptomeningeal haemosiderosis may have few symptoms or signs. In a review of 8843 brain MRI scans, Offenbacher et al. showed that only four of the 13 patients with evidence of leptomeningeal haemosiderosis on MRI scanning had hearing loss, and only two of these had cerebellar ataxia and myelopathy.Reference Offenbacher, Fazekas, Schmidt, Alexandra, D Scott and Philip A2 The development of symptoms seems to be proportional to the amount of haemosiderin deposition. This supports the theory of a pre-symptomatic phase to the illness. The differential diagnosis of leptomeningeal haemosiderosis includes neurosyphilis, multiple sclerosis, autoimmune hearing loss and allergy.Reference Kwartlet, De La Cruz and Lo17
Rapidly progressive SNHL was the first symptom in our patient. His maximal progression of hearing loss was 13–28 dB per year (for 250 Hz to 6 kHz), which compares with the 12–24 dB per year loss reported by Weekamp et al. Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9
The differential diagnosis of progressive, bilateral SNHL in adults is shown in Table I.
Differential diagnosis of progressive, bilateral, sensorineural hearing loss in adults
HL = hearing loss; ESR = erythrocyte sedimentation rate; ANA = antinuclear antibody; Abs = antibodies; HLA = human leukocyte antigen; HB = Haemoglobin; VDRL = venereal disease research laboratory test; Ca = carcinoma; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; Hx = history; CT = computed tomography
In our patient, the rapidity of progression, combined with neurological symptoms and signs, led to suspicion of intracranial pathology.
Cerebrospinal fluid xanthochromia is present in approximately three-quarters of samples taken from patients with leptomeningeal haemosiderosis.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1 Computed tomography scanning may show a hyperdense rim over the brain surface or atrophy of the cerebellar vermis. However, the ‘gold standard’ investigative tool is now MRI. Gradient-echo and T2-weighted images show the haemosiderin as a pathognomonic, hypointense rim around the brainstem, cerebellum, cranial nerves and spinal cord.Reference Offenbacher, Fazekas, Schmidt, Alexandra, D Scott and Philip A2, Reference Stevens, Peterson, Grodd, Poremba and Dichgans10, Reference Kwartlet, De La Cruz and Lo17 This is secondary to susceptibility artefact from the haemosiderin, which is most evident on the gradient-echo images. The susceptibility artefact is less pronounced on T2-weighted images and is not usually visible on T1-weighted images.Reference Offenbacher, Fazekas, Schmidt, Alexandra, D Scott and Philip A2, Reference Grunshaw, Blanshard, Hussain and Grace3, Reference Patel, Edelman and Warach18, Reference Wehrli and Atlas19 A source of bleeding should be sought. Magnetic resonance imaging of the spine should be performed to exclude tumours, root avulsions and arteriovenous malformations. High resolution cerebral MRA should also be performed to screen for intracranial aneurysms.
Where possible, treatment should be directed at eliminating the bleeding source. The benefit of iron chelation therapy has been debated.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9, Reference Stevens, Peterson, Grodd, Poremba and Dichgans10, Reference River, Honigman, Gomori and Reches20 The anatomical aetiology of hearing loss in leptomeningeal haemosiderosis is controversial and affects potential therapeutic options. Retrocochlear pathology is suggested by delayed brainstem auditory evoked potentials.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference River, Honigman, Gomori and Reches20 Other authors have found evidence of isolated or concurrent cochlear pathology, in the form of increased cochlear microphonic thresholds or absent stapedial reflexes.Reference Fearnley, Stevens and Rudge1, Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9 As yet, MRI scanning is not detailed enough to detect localised uptake of haemosiderin by the cochlea. Some argue that involvement of the cochlear aqueduct, alteration in perilymph composition or hypoxia of the cochlea may be present.Reference Weekamp, Huygen, Merx, Kremer and Cremers9 Symptomatic treatment of hearing loss may be possible through cochlear implantation.Reference Haferkamp, Schabet and Plinkert21 However, many patients are so neurologically debilitated at the time of diagnosis that implantation is not appropriate.
Irving and Graham reported significant benefit from cochlear implantation in a case of leptomeningeal haemosiderosis, up to two years following implantation.Reference Irving and Graham22 Further, informal contact with this patient more than 10 years after insertion confirmed that the implant was still functioning.
Although our patient had an encouraging start, his implant performance progressively deteriorated over a six-month period, presumably secondary to ongoing neural deterioration.
Conclusion
When presented with a patient who has progressive, bilateral SNHL, features such as cerebellar ataxia and spinal cord dysfunction should be sought. Leptomeningeal haemosiderosis should be included in the differential diagnosis, and MRI scans of the CNS should be obtained.
• Haemosiderosis is an uncommon disease characterised by the deposition of haemosiderin in body tissues
• When the condition occurs in the central nervous system, it is known as leptomeningeal haemosiderosis or superficial siderosis
• Progressive, bilateral, sensorineural deafness is the most common presentation of this condition, in association with central neurological symptoms and signs
• Early diagnosis with magnetic resonance imaging is important in order to facilitate treatment
