Disasters and catastrophes have been disregarded as subjects of interest by lawyers and legal scholars for a long time. At a time when disasters are increasing both in the number of occurrences and in the number of people affected, this tendency has been inverted due to growing awareness of the legal implications of many extreme events. Law in Crisis by Ruth A. Miller is utterly distinctive in its approach to the topic. The focus chosen to analyse natural disasters is the ecstatic subject and its ambiguous relationship with legal structures in times of crisis. The theoretical background of the book draws mainly on the analyses of ecstasy and subjectification in Judith Butler, Rosi Braidotti and Michel Foucault, with particular attention paid to feminist theory and gendered subjects. It is an attempt to move away from Descartes's rational and bounded subject as the central subject for law and the rhetoric of disasters. According to Miller, in fact the subject in ecstasy is in a unique position to endow the disaster with meaning as ‘[t]he subject in ecstasy defines the disaster, provides a link between the world of disaster and the world of law’ (p. 17).
In the theoretically rich introduction, Miller offers an understanding of disaster law quite different from the usual emphasis put on legal institutions and the procedures relevant in a disaster context. According to her, disaster law should be understood as ‘the simultaneously legal, cultural, political and literary production of the subject in crisis’ (p. 25). This definition illuminates one of the peculiarities of this approach, her consideration not only of legal materials but also of cultural and literary objects. Throughout the book there are plenty of examples of how these materials can become relevant in a disaster law study, inviting the reader to follow unusual paths guided by the author's mastery of several European and also Middle Eastern languages like Turkish. The theoretical analysis is grounded in four case-studies: the 1894 Istanbul earthquake, the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, the 1923 Tokyo −Yokohama earthquake, and the 1999 Istanbul/Marmara earthquake. The geographical extension of the case-studies allows the author to go beyond Western world assumptions, opening the way to a post-colonial critique that plays an important role in offering a different understanding of the relationship between disaster and law.
The book is divided into four major chapters, each devoted to a different aspect of subject formation during moments of crisis. The second chapter is a contextualisation of the work in the field of disaster studies and of the choice of case-studies. The author engages in a reading of the development of disasters as political metaphors. Puritan thinking marks an important distinction between natural and supernatural disasters, where only in the latter is there an intervention from God. Drawing on this distinction, the supernatural earthquake was an instrument to give meaning to the disaster, proving the existence of God and thus the existence of natural law. In this way Puritan thinking was responsible for bringing ecstatic subjects into the context of disasters and law, which became real only via reference to the ecstatic subject (p. 37). This was the start of a shift from the rational subject to the ecstatic one as the crucial point of view for giving disaster a meaning. The hypothesis defended is that ‘a disaster comes into existence when the ecstatic subject becomes the normative figure of law and politics’ (p. 45). This assumption challenges and sometimes overlaps with three assumptions in contemporary disaster writing on how disasters become disasters: (1) when they occur at some commonly accepted centre; (2) only upon their articulation as well-worn narratives; and (3) when the everyday or daily life becomes a template for politics. The critique of these assumptions lies in the fact that all of them are linked to the bounded rational subjects, and fail to notice the marginal and eccentric who can never become central or bounded.
The third chapter deals with bodily integrity and ecstatic life. It is based on an influential case in the jurisprudence of bodily integrity in the US, Schloendorff v. Society of New York Hospital,Footnote 1 decided in 1934 by Benjamin Cardozo for the New York Court of Appeals, making justice in the case of Mary Schloendorff, a woman subjected to medical treatment against her will. Interestingly, Miller uncovers the story behind the case, the ordeal of Schloendorff in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, which influenced the doctor's decisions and affected the credibility of her testimony during the trial. For Miller this is another illustration that it is the eccentric subject that gives meaning to the disaster. Distinguishing her work from biopolitical theories about the regulation of life and death, the chapter illustrates the construction of the ecstatic subject, the subject beyond herself, analysing the cultural and legal implications that matters like blood transfusions, organ transplants or disease control assume in a time of crisis. With an intriguing analysis of the Turkish Health Minister's rejection of foreign blood donations in the aftermath of the 1999 Istanbul earthquake, Miller opens the way for an important insight into the hidden relationship between blood, disaster and the construction of political subjectivity. In this alternative understanding of the gift of life, the chapter also deals with organ mafia fear, viruses and disease control as elements that contributed to the creation of eccentric subjectivity in different extreme events. This long chapter concludes with comment on another case in which Judge Cardozo took part, namely Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad.Footnote 2 Comparing Judge Andrews's dissenting opinion in this case with that of Cardozo in Schloendorff, Miller is again successful in unveiling how the ideas of negligence, cause and responsibility are constructed around shattered bodies and a rational bounded subject that becomes ecstatic because of the interaction of ordinary law and disaster law (pp. 82−84).
Miller's interest in the significance of the body for disaster law continues in the fourth chapter, where she deals extensively with the dead body as a bearer of rights. Such an approach departs from a straightforward biopolitical analysis, as she looks instead at ‘the ways in which the rights bearing individual and the healthy population together give rise to dead people with rights’ (p. 88). Assuming her object of study as a ‘politics of ecstasy’ where its subjects are dead if nonetheless active (p. 89), she focuses on the extension of rights to corpses and dead bodies. The chapter shows how death tolls and declarations of death are instruments that move continuously on a thin line of an everyday/extraordinary law dynamics. The (ecstatic) endpoint of such a dynamic is the recognition that the dead body not only can have rights that contribute to rendering meaningful the disaster but that can also exclude the living citizen from the political scene of a disaster. The study of the regime of prohibition of internment, the regulation of such an activity in a confined space in a disaster area, the intervention of military law that favours the rights of the dead over the rights of the living in protecting property rights in a catastrophe context all show the hidden link of democracy with the dead body as a bearer of rights, a normative subject of disaster law.
The fifth chapter is about seismic space as ecstatic space, the type of space that is produced and demanded by the politics of disaster. This part of the book examines the contributions to the politics of space by such diverse authors as Achille Mbembe, Antony Anghie and Henri Lefebvre. The emphasis in the first part is strongly oriented in the direction of a post-colonial critique of the politics of space. Post-colonial space is an ecstatic one, as borders and legal rights are not defined once and for all but kept in a constant uncertainty. In this regard, Miller proposes a reading of the post-colonial space that is not only linked to the paradigm of exceptionalism but rather to the spatial analogy with the effects of walls, enclosures and façades (p. 127). Law in a disaster area operates through division, categorisation and compartmentalisation: the camp-refugee, concentration or work camp, is one of the examples of such a space (p. 135), as is the cemetery, a political space protected by dead bearers where living bodies seek aid in a disaster area (p. 145).
The book concludes by arguing that the politics of the everyday and the politics of disasters are identical in many ways, and that ‘the disaster represents a quite normal, or normative form of democratic engagement’ (p. 177). Miller's journey through the politics of disaster is a fascinating one. One of the merits of the volume is to show a different way of understanding disasters in their relationship with law. As a quite unique contribution to the existing literature, the book opens the way for a more complex reading of cultural and legal materials than is usually offered in disaster literature related to law. Notwithstanding these positive aspects, some criticisms are worth noting. The variety of sources Miller works with is sometimes hard for the reader to follow. While the author's mastery of the material is not in question, its relevance for the topic of disasters is at times a bit difficult to grasp, as is the case with the comments on the Öcalan case at the end of chapter 4. This is because the focus of the book privileges the subject in ecstasy in its various implications, and disaster seems more to provide an intriguing context in which to discuss subject formation rather than a constant application of such theories. In fact there is not so much space devoted specifically to issues like risk, vulnerability or the social impact of catastrophes, which are of general concern in disaster studies. The book chooses an ‘oblique’ reading of crises and disasters that could confuse some readers interested in the recent law and catastrophe trend. Still, the enterprise is worthwhile, as Miller's unveiling of the ecstatic politics of disaster is an important contribution for all scholars interested in the various implications that disasters can have for law and politics.
