Baetens’s curated volume of conference papers, written by a strong cast of contributors, “scrutinises how concepts, principles and rules developed in the context of other subfields of international law could, or should, inform the content of investment law” (p. xxvii). With a growing number of investor-state disputes that involve international obligations other than those which protect and promote incoming foreign investment, it has become increasingly difficult to study the development of investment law in isolation from other fields of international law. Viewing investment law through, for instance, the optic of human rights, environmental preservation, or the concerns of developing countries is not, however, new. Notable earlier works include Human Rights in International Investment Law and Arbitration, Footnote 1 “Foreign Investment and the Environment in International Law: An Ambiguous Relationship”,Footnote 2 and The International Law on Foreign Investment.Footnote 3
The book comprises twenty-one chapters and is divided into six parts. Part I examines the interaction of investment law and the law of armed conflict over three chapters, Part II considers the impact of human rights on investment protection over four chapters, Part III discusses sustainable investment protection over four chapters, Part IV takes up the perennial issue of striking a balance between investor rights and host state developmental needs over four chapters, Part V analyses the interplay between investment treaty law and European Union law over three chapters, and Part VI offers projections on the trajectory of investment treaty arbitration and of international investment law over three chapters.
Given the breadth of topics covered, the book is an ambitious addition to the cross-fertilization literature. Baetens informs the reader in the Preface that “the authors of each part have had the opportunity to examine each other’s ideas so as to guarantee a coherent approach to the matter, thereby avoiding a fragmented discussion” (p. xxviii). While Baetens’s familiarity with the chapters she edited may equip her to notice some level of engagement between the authors of each part, the variety of issues canvassed, and the very different analytical approaches and writing styles of the authors, infuses the book as a whole with eclecticism, rather than coherence. Any engagement between authors appears inadvertent. Calamita’s (pp. 164–84) and Gourgourinis’s chapters (pp. 298–329), despite being located in Parts II and IV respectively, and thus addressing different topics, clash on the determinacy of treaty language in articulating standards of investment protection. Both Calamita and Gourgourinis plead a convincing case, and the reader will be reluctant to take sides.
The eclectic tenor of the book does not in any way detract from the high quality of various chapters. In addition to Calamita’s and Gourgourinis’s contributions, Hernández’s nuanced elaboration of how situations of armed conflict may affect a host state’s treaty obligation to provide full protection and security to qualifying investments (pp. 21–50), Weiss’s and Steiner’s as well as Yotova’s thorough accounts of the competing tensions between compliance with intra-European Union investment treaty obligations and European Union law (pp. 355–74, 387–414), and Prislan’s call for states to retake control of their treaty obligations and decide how investment-related obligations should fit alongside non-investment obligations (pp. 450–81), showcase the current diversity and depth of scholarly reflection on “integrationist perspectives” in investment law. On this account, the reader will be tempted to overlook the fact that the individual chapters do not coalesce into an orderly narrative.
