No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
The role of women in post–Revolutionary Iran has been a widely contested topic. Many have argued that the revolution was a liberating force for Iranian women as they fought side by side with men to achieve the goals of their struggle. Moreover, some have reasoned that the mandatory imposition of the hijab (head scarf) has enabled women to take on more relevance through the amorphous, a-sexual nature of their garb. However, Masoud Kazemzadeh argues the opposite, declaring women to be among the major losers of the revolution. Going beyond the findings of other scholars, Kazemzadeh does not assign absolute blame to Islamic ideology for the declining role of women. In fact, his findings debunk the causal relationship between Islam and anti-feminist policies. Instead, Kazemzadeh deems Islam to be a “contributing factor” to gender inequality where the patriarchy in Islamic countries in general and in Iran in particular has used and abused the tenets of Islam to perpetuate such inequities. Ultimately, he lays blame not with Islam but with Islamic fundamentalists who have manipulated the religion to pursue their own misogynist policies.
Kazemzadeh's work is concise, structured, and methodological. He clearly establishes the direction and goals of his inquiry, never once veering off the track. Moreover, he steers the reader, although often cursorily, not only through Khomeini's anti-feminist policies but also through the various theories of gender relations pursued by Iranian political parties and through an analysis of the role of women in Islam. Perhaps as a result of focusing on the period from February 1979 to June 1981, this work can seem scanty, as the reader often needs more analysis or an expanded time frame of reference. His use of sources and research is thorough and clear, as is Kazemzadeh's audience—undergraduates—as they would benefit most from the review of history, methodology, and the evolution of gender relations in Iran.
Most interesting to the reader is how Kazemzadeh's argument is systematically unveiled to arrive at his conclusion. Initially, he reveals how Khomeini institutionalized gender inequality in the Iranian political, economic, and cultural spheres. Both through de jure and de facto execution, Khomeini sought to protect the patriarchy. Using diversity of tactics ranging from revoking gender protection in the workplace to withdrawing social services and nullifying the family-protection laws, Khomeini and his supporters forced women out of the public sphere and back into their “natural” role of motherhood. Moreover, all previous gains with regards to polygyny, divorce, hijab, sigheh, and education were ultimately reversed. Women were relegated to a subordinate position in society.
From there, Kazemzadeh shows that feminism was a prevailing concern among the divergent political parties contesting power during the 1979–84 period. That gender issues were included in the political debate exposes, according to Kazemzadeh, the reluctance of women to accept Khomeini's anti-feminist, fundamentalist policies. He ascribes the failure of feminists to resist fundamentalist goals to their weakness relative to the powerful Islamist forces in the government. Here again, Kazemzadeh's restricted time frame of analysis constrains his argument. It would be useful for the reader to be updated on the current status and agenda of the women's movement in Iran, not only to support his case but also to provide the reader with a frame of reference on the evolution of the feminist struggle. Ultimately, though, Kazemzadeh illustrates that Islam is not a “necessary condition” for anti-feminism, rather, Khomeini's political decisions are responsible for propagating such gender discrimination.
Finally, Kazemzadeh returns to his examination of Khomeini's manipulation of Islam as a means of enabling an anti-feminist agenda. Having reinterpreted the Qur

an and hadith to redress the gender issue, Islamic fundamentalists have often appropriated what Kazemzadeh refers to as the patriarchal and puritanical nature of Islam and exaggerated it for their own end. He clearly connects the fundamentalist agenda with regard to women to specific passages in the Qur

an. However, to counter the fundamentalist misreading, Kazemzadeh has revisited the issue of sexual Puritanism within Islam and Shi

ism to prove that Islamic fundamentalists have drawn such conservative conclusions from their independent interpretations, not from actual doctrinal policies. Here he reveals that Islam can be used as a “contributing factor” to gender inequality. Despite such a finding, what is most important to note is that Islam has been used to facilitate gender discrimination and has eased the success of Khomeini and his fundamentalist disciples in repressing women in Iran. As suggested by Kazemzadeh, “Islamic fundamentalists…pick and chose from the rich, variegated and contradictory values in Islam whatever suits their interests. This of course is nothing new. In the past 1400 years, Islam has been used to provide justifications for slavery, pre-capitalist mercantile economy, landed property, capitalism, socialism, communism, feminism and anti-feminism” (p. 100).
In spite of this structured analysis, Kazemzadeh diverges by concluding with policy implications. His prescriptions that Muslim women need to strive not only for gender equality but also for secularization of politics and, to that end, achieve such a polity through “do[ing] what the Europeans did: to start a new Enlightenment” (p. 106) is again too cursory and reductionist. Instead, he should encourage women to arm themselves with their own theological arguments to lobby against the religious distortions of the fundamentalists and prove that, in fact, other interpretations of Islam can be used to promote gender equality. Moreover, by expanding the time span of his focus to the present, he could show how the issue of gender inequality is being addressed in Iran's contemporary society, as undoubtedly some gains have been made in twenty years. Ultimately, Kazemzadeh's contribution is an eludication of the misuse of Islam by Islamic fundamentalists, such as Khomeini, to advance anti-feminist ambitions.