This book makes the case that Israel must address the needs of its increasingly mobilized Palestinian minority, who currently make up about 20 percent of the country's population, in order to safeguard its own future. Peleg and Waxman wish to “sound an alarm” by bringing to readers’ attention the deteriorating relationship between Israel's Jewish majority and its Palestinian minority (p. vii), and they offer proposals they hope “will at least stimulate new thinking and encourage creative and bold action” (p. ix) to improve the current situation.
This book is divided into two parts. The first part lays out some of the social, economic, and political conditions of Palestinian citizens of Israel. Peleg and Waxman highlight Israel's policies of marginalization and exclusion, as well as the increasing political activism of Palestinians in Israel. They trace the rise in the 1990s of Palestinian calls for Israel to become a “state of all its citizens,” and the growing friction between Israel's Jewish and Palestinian communities since October 2000, when large Palestinian demonstrations in Israel and subsequent clashes with police left thirteen unarmed protesters dead. Since then, a number of Palestinian groups in Israel have stepped up their calls for Israel to become a binational state, as reflected in the 2007 “Vision documents.” While the authors criticize the Vision documents, they argue in Chapter 3 that overall Palestinian demands for greater rights are not extreme by international standards and are pursued through legal means such as voting and establishing NGOs. Therefore, they argue, Jewish Israelis should not fear a “radicalized” Palestinian minority—at least not yet.
Those who study Palestinian citizens of Israel will not find much new in this section, as Peleg and Waxman do not undertake any original research. Nonetheless, they synthesize well the existing literature on this community, particularly sociological studies, and provide a useful overview for those seeking an introduction to this community and the challenges they face.
The second part of the book consists of the authors’ specific policy proposals, which are aimed at “transforming the relationship between the Jewish majority and the Palestinian minority in Israel, and through this transformation enhancing the quality of Israel's democracy and its long-term political stability” (p. 167). Most interesting is Chapter 7, in which Peleg and Waxman seek to delineate a “middle ground” that is “neither ethnocracy nor bi-nationalism.” Their grand strategy includes a new rights regime with several laudable suggestions, including establishing greater Palestinian autonomy in the realm of public education; ensuring equal allocation of resources to Arab and Jewish municipalities; recognizing “unrecognized” villages; including Arab parties in government coalitions; and introducing a Basic Law that would guarantee the citizenship of all Israelis as inviolable (pp. 183–7). These suggestions reflect some of the demands made by Palestinian rights groups in Israel, and the authors correctly note that they would help redress some of the injustices that have taken place over the past six decades. Curiously absent, however, is any proposal that addresses the demand of internal refugees (so-called “present absentees”) to return to their homes and villages—many of which stand empty—despite the salience of this issue among Palestinians in Israel. Nonetheless, the authors’ proposals would constitute a step in the right direction if adopted by Israel.
Yet Peleg and Waxman also insist that the Jewish nature of the state must be preserved. Despite their acknowledgement of the “bi-national nature of Israeli society” (p. 168), they firmly reject the idea of transforming Israel into a binational state as “unjust, unnecessary and destabilizing” (p. 192). In order to move beyond the vagueness of Israel's current self-definition as “Jewish and democratic,” the authors seek to redefine Israel as “a Jewish homeland and a state of all its citizens” (p. 179). This formulation, they argue, recognizes the historic Jewish connection to the land and adheres to the principle of majoritarian democratic rule while also recognizing non-Jews as full and equal citizens. Of course, Palestinians in Israel—not to mention millions of Palestinian refugees—also consider this territory to be their homeland, yet the Palestinian connection to this area is defined only in terms of those who are citizens of Israel. Thus, while claiming to have found a balanced approach, the authors nonetheless continue to privilege Jewish claims to the land over Palestinian ones. Given this fundamental imbalance in their definition of Israel, it is difficult to see how true equality can be attained within this framework.
Beyond the question of definition, there is a more practical question that the authors try, but ultimately fail, to answer adequately. Given Israel's rightward shift in recent years, how can these policy suggestions be contemplated, let alone implemented? Peleg and Waxman are under no illusions about the current trajectory of Israeli politics. In Chapter 4 they highlight some recent developments, including the rise of Avigdor Lieberman's Yisrael Beiteinu Party and the introduction of Knesset bills aimed at curbing the rights of Palestinian citizens. In Chapter 8 they address these challenges head-on, acknowledging that most of the Jewish-Israeli majority will likely reject their proposals at first. Peleg and Waxman argue that in order for the proposals to gain ground, a wide array of Jewish Israelis need to establish a broad consensus that addressing the grievances of the Palestinian minority would be in Israel's own best interests. The authors warn that if none of their suggestions are implemented, Israel could face the prospect of an intifada within Israel, Palestinian citizens who become involved in terrorist acts, or the fusion of internal and external Palestinian demands, including more robust calls for Israel to become a binational state (pp. 213–16).
Peleg and Waxman's approach to this question is problematic in two regards. First, they do not present any suggestions as to how such a broad consensus could be reached, especially given the highly contentious nature of Israeli politics. The implication seems to be that such a coalition would be built primarily around a belief in the need to maintain Israel's Jewish identity, and an agreement that pacifying the Palestinian minority is the only way to do so. Second, this leads to another problem, which is that the authors seem to feel compelled to resort to stereotypical images of violent Palestinians as the only way to shake Jewish Israelis from their complacency on this matter. Peleg and Waxman are correct that a further deterioration of conditions could lead to greater unrest among Palestinians in Israel. But by relying on such visceral, fear-based images as Palestinian citizens carrying out terrorist attacks (and not, for example, suggesting the formation of a broad coalition that could appeal to Israel's democratic ideals), they engage in the very type of exclusionary discourse they argue should be tempered. To some extent, they are confined by Israel's current political climate. Many of their proposals are considered radical by the standards of mainstream Israeli political discourse, and grounding them in appeals to democratic principles would likely doom them from the start.
Despite these rather serious shortcomings, Peleg and Waxman should be commended for laying out a rights regime for Palestinians in Israel that takes seriously many of the demands that Palestinian citizens have been articulating for decades. This book will be useful for students, scholars, and policymakers seeking to learn more about the condition of the Palestinian minority in Israel and its relationship with the state. It could also “stimulate new thinking,” although more creative thinking—and action—is still sorely needed.
