Political power is omnipresent in this ambitious volume. But, as its subtitle indicates, the main target of Machtfragen is the authority of representation. A fundamental premise is that text, images, and ritual should not be reduced to bare reflections of and reactions to political mastery. Rather, as clearly stated by Arweiler and Gauly in their introduction, cultural expressions are in themselves powerful constructs and deserve to be analysed as such.
Machtfragen is a collection of nine papers presented at a colloquium held in Kiel in 2005. The contributions appear in chronological order, with a majority of papers discussing Roman Antiquity, followed by analyses of medieval and early modern times. The book concludes with abstracts in English, notes on contributors, and a general index.
One aspect duly stressed throughout this up-to-date volume is power as a social act. Hence, communication and participation form key issues. In an excellent paper, Karl-Joachim Hölkeskamp underlines the importance of ritual participation in the Roman culture of spectacle. Hölkeskamp analyses ways in which the triumph, the funeral and the circus procession mirrored, formulated and strengthened the political Republican system, which embraced both an extreme hierarchy topped by an aristocratic élite, and a forceful inclusive idea of res publica. In the one article concerned with images, Rolf Michael Schneider also points out the importance of communication. His paper explores three quite different fields of Augustan artistic innovation: cityscape, portraiture, and images of Orientals. Among other issues, Schneider stresses the extreme launching of one man's face that occurred with Augustus in all media and all contexts. How did people react to the constant meeting with the emperor's never-aging countenance? Despite recent years’ massive interest in the power of images in the age of Augustus, Schneider's essay suggests that there is still dynamic potential in the question of communication between portraits and people of this time.
Helmut Krasser argues that Horace uses participation as a forceful tool to construct his own role as literary architect. By setting out, in the fourth book of the Odes, to describe the Roman triumph from the view of a humble spectator, Horace, according to Krasser, invites the reader into a poetic experience that both commemorates and reshapes the celebration. Gerhard Fouquet also underlines participation as an active force in Machtfragen. His essay analyses the sixteenth-century chronicle of the Zimmern family. Fouquet shows how the chronicle worked with the prime values of that time, noble origins and aristocratic honour, to formulate family power.
In one way or the other, most contributions deal with the power of the text. Alexander Arweiler presents a theoretically elaborate study that strives to define and explore the power of literature in Late Republican Rome. By analysing different political concepts and terminologies, such as authority, sovereignty, and rule, Arweiler is able to propose tactics and strategies that literature employed to reflect, construct, reproduce, discuss and exercise power. Literature also has the power to construct the self. Bardo Maria Gauly contributes an excellent article exploring the self-praising techniques used in Pliny the Younger's letters to build the image of a senator perfectus. Gauly reveals three concepts in force: beneficial munificentia, studia (literary and rhetorical accomplishment), and a rightful political conduct, which Pliny marks by naming opponents of Domitian as friends and his supporters as enemies. Gauly's article includes important discussions on the effectiveness of the text and on the relation between literary constructions, authorship and reception. Thomas Schmitz also studies how text formulates identity. His essay is devoted to Lucian and the complex relationship between power and Bildung in Imperial Greece. Schmitz reads Lucian's writing as an expression of self in a society where Greek paideia was both powerful, as in possession of cultural capital, and powerless, as in limited access to political command.
The dynamic relationship between text and political power forms the central theme in Christel Meier's contribution. By analysing epic texts, she is able to lay bare central medieval poetic discourses on rule: the panegyric, the exhortative, the utopian, and the critical. Meier emphasizes the independent position of literature, by stressing its precedence of interpretation in describing, reflecting and commenting on the ruler. Bernhard Teuber draws our attention to the field of drama. He explores the tragedies of Seneca, Calderón, Corneille and Racine, and proposes that they all present different relations between sovereignty, drama and ethical subject. A major point in this very learned analysis is that seventeenth-century theatre continues to interact with Seneca's plays in a staged discussion of the contemporary ruler.
The essays presented in Machtfragen are all of high quality. Some are rather demanding, and with this huge and multi-faceted topic spanning such a long period, few will probably read the book from cover to cover. Many scholars are, however, bound to find articles of significant interest to their own fields in the volume. This goes especially for literary studies. In fact, one could argue that there is a certain imbalance in the book, with the introduction and the vast majority of essays dealing with the power of the text. Considering the inclusion of a few pieces on images, ritual and drama, I missed a discussion on how all these variant types of representation differed and were similar in reflecting and constructing power. That said, the editors should be acknowledged for having produced an in-depth collection that provides valuable insights into a complex and powerful field.
