Since the 1980s, Brazil has been a testing ground for the confrontation between authoritarian and market forces against social movements promoting civil rights and democracy. The reform of public health has been part of this confrontation. This book is the result of sound ethnographic fieldwork on the challenges and limitations of reforms in health-care services for the urban poor in north-eastern Brazil. Its organising principle is the contrast between the comprehensive and radical Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS), created in 1988, and the multi-layered health experiences of favela dwellers of Pirambu (located within the city of Fortaleza, the capital of the state of Ceará). The SUS emerged when most Latin American nations were privatising public health and insurance systems and it was praised by experts around the world. Although the criticism of the SUS is not completely new, the book adds new materials and perspectives on how the poor react to the deterioration of public health services and provides useful insights into the health expectations and the changing meaning of citizenship in Brazil.
The first two chapters provide a panorama of the interaction between grassroots social movements in Ceará, public health activists and the Brazilian State during the twentieth century. All of them pursued the foundation, expansion and control of basic services, health programmes and welfare systems and contributed to questioning the idea that medical treatment and prevention were government favours. The following four chapters examine major changes which occurred after the end of the military dictatorship in the early 1980s when health reforms appeared more closely associated with progressive activism. The third chapter analyses the formation of health-care councils, mainly at the municipal level, that sought to democratise and decentralise the health system. These councils where formed under the Primary Health Care premise of the World Health Organisation that civil society should participate actively in the definition of health priorities and in breaking the link between poverty and disease. However, in Pirambu, as in many other locations around the world, community participation occurred under the paternalistic supervision of medical doctors who frequently blamed patients for their lifestyles and lack of care for their own environment. A fourth chapter examines the unfolding of Farmacia Viva, a public pharmaceutical programme aimed at promoting the scientific use of traditional medicine (also encouraged in a World Health Organisation proposal). Unfortunately, the programme promoted a restricted type of traditional medicine that operated under the guidance of biomedical experts that validated and standardised medicinal plants according to pharmaceutical and chemical criteria. Chapters 5 and 6 have a nuanced discussion of how social class, gender and age influence people's medical decisions or health-seeking behaviour. According to the author, younger residents of the favelas who were moving upwards in society, take for granted that health is not a right as the SUS intended, but poor medicine for the poor. For them better health, as well as individual progress, is associated with access to private medical services. They seek these services for their expected benefits, as a symbol of prestige, and as part of their effort to become members of a consumer culture and a clientelist political system.
I would like to underline three important ideas of this book. First, the Brazilian medical and social activism that sought health as an obligation of the state, a right of all citizens and a marker of social equity is presently seriously undermined, if not in a profound crisis. Second, during much of its existence in provincial favelas such as Pirambu, the SUS was precarious, underfunded, managed with a biomedical perspective that obliterated social and cultural explanations of health and disease, gave more importance to treatment than to prevention, and expected patients not to dispute medical treatment. Third, the author suggests that is impossible to consolidate citizens’ right to health in a neoliberal economic order because health services become a commodity in such an order. The first two ideas are observations sustained by convincing evidence and confirm previous findings that the struggle for the extension of civil rights and democracy in Brazil has been losing its pace and dynamism. The third conclusion is part of a political and ideological debate that raises significant questions. Is public health an epiphenomenon of political and economic developments? Can universal health-care systems, eagerly promoted today by major agencies such as the World Bank and the World Health Organisation, be sustainable in developing countries with acute social inequalities or neoliberal economic policies?
The book would have benefited from a map and some images. Additionally, interviews concentrate on official professional providers and lay recipients. Lay, traditional and religious healers, so important in other Brazilian favelas, are almost absent from the narratives. Another criticism is that the historical and the ethnographic dimensions of the book are not even. The historical investigation is based on secondary literature, oral histories and information collected from newspapers. Some crucial Brazilian historical works like Gilberto Hochman's A era do saneamento; as bases da política de saúde pública no Brasil (São Paulo: Hucitec-Anpocs, 1998) and Nísia Trindade Lima's Um sertão chamado Brasil (Rio de Janeiro: Revan/IUPERJ, 1999) are missing from the bibliographic references. The ethnographic side is, to the knowledge of the historian of medicine writing this review, coherent, lucid and based in the analysis of illuminating life stories and fascinating interviews. What is most noteworthy in this book is the author's ability to depict and examine how members of a low-income neighbourhood in provincial Brazil understand, perceive, consume, and portray public health reforms and official health programmes. This study will be very useful to scholars and policy-makers interested in socio-medical sciences and in contemporary Brazil.
