No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
In For Home, Country, and Race, Stephen Heathorn sets out to explain the “how” of English nationalism at the turn of the twentieth century. Rejecting the imperial propagandist theme, Heathorn argues that nationalist agendas in English schools were the product of educators. Accordingly, Heathorn's research focuses on the classroom as the site of nationalist education. Heathorn argues that through educational activities, especially school readers, middle-class educators brought the English working class into their nationalist hegemony. As the book's title suggests, this hegemonic view also promoted class and gender subordination. As Heathorn concludes, the proof of the working class's acceptance of this nationalist hegemony is found in their willingness “to sacrifice their lives and loved ones” in the “cataclysmic clash of rival nationalisms that erupted in 1914” (218).
In For Home, Country, and Race, Stephen Heathorn sets out to explain the “how” of English nationalism at the turn of the twentieth century. Rejecting the imperial propagandist theme, Heathorn argues that nationalist agendas in English schools were the product of educators. Accordingly, Heathorn's research focuses on the classroom as the site of nationalist education. Heathorn argues that through educational activities, especially school readers, middle-class educators brought the English working class into their nationalist hegemony. As the book's title suggests, this hegemonic view also promoted class and gender subordination. As Heathorn concludes, the proof of the working class's acceptance of this nationalist hegemony is found in their willingness “to sacrifice their lives and loved ones” in the “cataclysmic clash of rival nationalisms that erupted in 1914” (218).
Heathorn begins with an examination of the educators to explain the reasons for changes in educational agendas and content. By the later part of the nineteenth century, educators—like other professionals—experienced a move toward greater professionalism, which resulted in a demand for academically accredited authors for educational readers, the source of much of the nationalist message absorbed by working-class students. The educators also redirected the agenda of education from the creation of moral individuals to development of good citizens. While many of the working class would not have the right to actively participate in politics through the act of voting, middle-class educators understood the need to ensure working-class loyalty by inculcating their working-class students in the nationalist hegemony. Educators, especially authors of school readers, introduced a middle-class specific vision of nationalism, premised on their values of good citizenship: “duty, discipline, reserve, obedience to superiors” (26). A good working-class citizen would see themselves first and foremost as English, rather than working class.
While giving some consideration to teaching logs, Heathorn's source for determining what was taught is his comprehensive examination of school readers. Heathorn contends that readers can demonstrate what the majority of working-class students were exposed to. While history was not a primary subject, Heathorn's study of readers illustrates that positivist historical stories were common in readers and infused with nationalist messages. These stories promoted military heroes whose good citizenship found expression as “active defenders of the nation” rather than linked to participation in politics, which most working-class students would never enjoy (54). The overriding message of historical lessons centered on loyalty to the nation instead of political parties or factions.
Inherent in the historical lessons found in the readers were a conflagration of nationalism and race. As Heathorn argues, “the boundaries between race, ethnicity, culture, and national identities were cloudy and ambiguous” (94). However, race was now understood as biological, rather than simply cultural. The glorified race was English rather than British, which became relegated to Empire. Also absent from the nationalist-racial construction were the Celtic minorities. Instead, middle-class educators found the roots of Englishness in the Anglo-Saxons, whose values they proclaimed as the basis of English racial traits. Having centered the Anglo-Saxon English as the most advanced race, the authors of readers developed a concentric circle of racial hierarchy with non-Europeans occupying the outer circles, those reserved for the least evolved/advanced.
It was through the oppositional “Other,” according to Heathorn, that the English defined their evolutionary success as a nation. The superiority of the English became a “naturalized” part of the nationalist hegemony. Heathorn argues that the radicalized nationalist identity worked to minimize differences within English society, especially class differences (118–119). Heathorn points to the widespread use of geography lessons in readers to convey the message of the racial and cultural inferiority of the “Other”. These selections promoted racial explanations of cultural development, or the lack of them in the non-European world. Correspondingly, the readers implied that the English had the right to colonize the unmanly non-Europeans, or, as in the case of the Australian Aborigines, to remove them to allow for the expansion of English civilization (140).
Nationalist constructions also worked to reinforce class and gender inequality in England. Authors of school readers modeled English society on the family, a social unit familiar to students. In the patriarchal family, all members were not equal, instead each had their “own special places, roles, responsibilities, and duties” (143). Class divisions were naturalized, as the obedience of subordinates was necessary to promote the good of the family and society as well. The analogy was continued through the metaphor of England as home; the love of home being described as a uniquely English value. The readers also reinforced female inequality within the family, but stressed the vital role women played in the family as good mothers. Women contributed to the national well being by producing healthy Englishmen who in turn would be productive workers and soldiers. Educators promoted gendered visions of citizenship with working-class men expressing their nationalism through their active defense of and duty to the nation, while working-class women were conceived in terms of biological and maternal importance. Instead of promoting equality, the nationalist agenda of educators worked to reinforce class and gender inequities already present in English society.
In addition to the nationalist themes promoted through school readers, Heathorn argues educators used symbolic messages to bring their working-class students into the nationalist hegemony. Throughout the educational process, the naval heroes were celebrated as symbols of English superiority. Through stories in readers and Empire Day activities, educators used the British flag to remind students of English nationalist superiority, core values, and sense of community. Educators also used physical activity, especially military drill, to instill in students the belief that national duty required them to be healthy citizens. Heathorn argues that these symbolic representations reinforced the nationalist messages found in basic educational activities.
In his conclusion, Heathorn argues that educators not only wanted to teach students “their letters” but also to produce “good Englishmen” and “good English wives” (200). The nationalist agenda in education was primarily the work of educators, and not the sole product of imperial elite propagandists. Nationalist agendas bubbled from the middle instead of trickling down from above. But Heathorn cautions that the actions of middle-class educators were not designed to bring about social control, but rather reflected their values (211). Heathorn further argues that through the classroom experience these values were accepted by the working class. Decrying a paucity of sources that illustrate real working-class views of nationalism, Heathorn concludes that their willing participation at the outbreak of World War One demonstrated their acceptance of the nationalist hegemony (218).
What Heathorn has produced is a well-researched study of the nationalistic agenda of middle-class educators in England at the turn of the twentieth century. His broad examination of the content of the readers used by working-class students, as well as surviving teaching logs, demonstrates that a nationalist agenda existed in English classrooms. He also shows that educators themselves controlled the content of what was taught. Less convincing is how much of this was accepted by working-class students. The link between what was taught and what was accepted merits further exploration. As Heathorn argues, hegemonic beliefs involve the negotiation and active consent of the subordinated (212). Yet, Heathorn's model illustrates only middle-class agency. Absent from the negotiation are working-class agents such as families, neighbors, and co-workers, all of whom had an influence on working-class children. Also ignored are any forms of working-class counter-hegemony, especially regarding class subordination. Despite this issue, Stephen Heathorn provides a solid look at how middle-class educators envisioned English nationalism, and how they actively worked to bring their working-class students into their vision of what it meant to be English.