Introduction
On 30 March 2018, protesters in the Gaza Strip engaged in a peaceful demonstration for “Land Day,” a Palestinian commemoration of the expropriation of lands for Israeli settlements in 1976.Footnote 1 During the march, Palestinians approached the border with Israel where the Israeli army opened fire with live ammunition and tank shells, killing at least fifteen demonstrators.Footnote 2 Dozens of others were wounded.Footnote 3 In the weeks and months that followed, Palestinian protesters continued to protest at the Gaza border. As this issue goes to print, the International Committee of the Red Cross reports that at least 116 Palestinians have been killed in protests framed as the “Great March of Return” since 30 March 2018, and as many as thirteen thousand have been injured.Footnote 4 This spring's events, coinciding with the seventieth anniversary of the founding of the state of Israel and the US decision to move its embassy to Jerusalem, offer yet another reminder of the violence and dispossession that for decades have characterized Palestinian life under Israeli occupation.
With these recent events in mind, we write seeking a discussion of the role of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions of Israel (BDS) in our discipline of theatre and performance studies. As scholars who have conducted research and attended performances in Israel and the West Bank, we have reflected on the roles institutional bodies within our discipline could play in responding to a call for solidarity in the form of an academic and cultural boycott of Israel. We write urging an engaged debate on the question of the treatment of Palestinian theatre makers by Israeli policies, state structures, and authorities, as well as access for international researchers to the occupied Palestinian territories. As the discourse around Palestine and Israel continues to change internationally, we ask: How might a professional community of scholars and practitioners of theatre and performance studies engage with the Palestinian struggle for justice and visibility?
The conditions we have witnessed in Palestine contravene the basic principles enunciated in several of our professional organizations’ governing language. For example, the International Federation for Theatre Research (IFTR)’s constitution claims in Article II that the organization seeks, among other things, (1) “to promote in all countries international liaisons between organisations and individuals devoted to theatre research, and to assist in organizing societies for theatre research” and (3) “to encourage interdisciplinary studies involving theatre research by promoting relations with other research fields and to collaborate in undertaking works of international theatre research, as well as to aid in every way all other projects to foster theatre research in all countries.”Footnote 5 Similarly, the bylaws of the American Society for Theatre Research (ASTR) state that the organization “fosters scholarship on worldwide theatre and performance, both historical and contemporary.” Importantly, Article XII recognizes the ability of the ASTR Executive Committee to speak for the association on public issues when these affect “academic freedom” and “freedom of access to information.”Footnote 6 In addition, Performance Studies international (PSi) was “founded … to promote communication and exchange among artists, thinkers, activists and academics working in the field of performance.” Ever aware of the complexities of international scope, PSi asserts a commitment “to engage with this multiplication of perspectives and multiple sites of contestation, and [discuss] how to make this situation productive for the further development of the field.”Footnote 7 PSi states that “being international is not a given but a question.”Footnote 8 It is in the spirit of pursuing this question that we write.
The violations of Palestinian human rights and the inability of international scholars to access colleagues, resources, and information in Palestine today represent serious obstructions to the principles above. We write to urge that these should be noted by the membership of IFTR, ASTR, PSi, and other associations, and that action in response should be publicly deliberated and collectively decided.
What Is BDS?
The call from Palestinian performing arts organizations for an academic and cultural boycott comes as part of a wider call from Palestinian civil society for the boycott of, divestment from, and sanctions against Israel. These make up strategies referred to by the acronym “BDS.” In the tradition of decades of Palestinian struggle for the right to self-determination, the BDS movement seeks a unified response to the violations of rights that Palestinians face. The call from Palestinian civil society for expressions of global solidarity via an international boycott comes on the heels of similar, successful campaigns in political struggles worldwide, most famously the South African struggle against racial segregation under apartheid.Footnote 9
The BDS movement is born of the political, cultural, and economic struggle of Palestinians against the Israeli occupation in the years following the Oslo Accords (signed 1993–5).Footnote 10 It is a product of frustration with stalled progress toward Palestinian self-determination, continued occupation, and the expansion of illegal Israeli settlements beyond the Green Line. The initial call upon “international civil society organizations and people of conscience all over the world to impose broad boycotts and implement divestment initiatives against Israel” was issued by Palestinian civil society in July 2005.Footnote 11 The Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI) was launched in July 2004 in the West Bank city of Ramallah and urged the international community “to comprehensively and consistently boycott all Israeli academic and cultural institutions until Israel withdraws from all the lands occupied in 1967, including East Jerusalem; removes all its colonies in those lands; agrees to United Nations resolutions relevant to the restitution of Palestinian refugees’ rights; and dismantles its system of apartheid.”Footnote 12
Since then, support for BDS has steadily grown internationally. A diverse range of organizations, municipalities, and collectives has responded to the call for solidarity, and many have implemented boycotts. It is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore the grassroots movement spreading across North American and European campuses, manifest in increasing activity among chapters of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) and endorsements of student groups and unions of the call to boycott. Scholarly and academic associations of faculty, independent researchers, and graduate students have also joined the academic stratum of the boycott.Footnote 13 Religious societies and cultural communities have voted to divest financially.
Theatre and performance scholars and practitioners are equally interpellated by PACBI's call, though we have yet to respond via our own professional associations. Moreover, in addition, we have also been directly entreated in a more recent letter, written during the Israeli bombardment of Gaza in 2014. This letter, specifically from Palestinian performing artists and cultural institutions, asks for international solidarity with Gaza:
We, cultural workers representing the majority of Palestinian performing art organizations, condemn the current Israeli attack and aggression on Gaza, and the indiscriminate killing and maiming of mainly civilians, among them many children and women. …
Among our companions are institutions that despite all the hardships continue to work in Gaza, using music, theatre and drama to comprehend, process, educate and mobilize. We stand with them and we ask you to do the same.
… We urge our colleagues, friends and partners not to stay silent and join us in our protest.
We call upon the world to put pressure on Israel to stop the blockade of Gaza.
We particularly call upon our fellow artists and cultural organizations to condemn the current aggressions against Gaza and the Occupation of Palestine through petitions, protests and statements. Further to that, we urge you to act by supporting the Palestinian cultural and academic boycott of Israel (PACBI), thereby refusing to be complicit in the ongoing Occupation and apartheid.Footnote 14
In this letter, Palestinian performing artists specifically address the international performing arts community to join the academic and cultural boycott of Israel. We examine here where such a request comes from and what it might entail.
Why an Academic Boycott?
The occupation obstructs research and study in Palestine. Besides the segregated school system available to Palestinian schoolchildren inside Israel, at the university level, Palestinians are consistently told where they can study and when by Israeli forces and Israeli permit-issuing authorities. Palestinian students in Gaza cannot study at Palestinian universities in the West Bank.Footnote 15 The reverse is also true: Palestinian students in the West Bank or inside Israel cannot attend universities in Gaza. Neither can students in Gaza or many students in the West Bank attend the universities of Haifa, Tel Aviv, or Jerusalem.
The occupation also affects and constrains study by Palestinians within supposedly sovereign Palestinian territory. The United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA) records over 542 obstacles to movement in the West Bank alone, such as checkpoints and roadblocks.Footnote 16 These checkpoints frequently bar or severely inhibit students from attending school. The ability to pass checkpoints often depends on the whims of an Israeli soldier on any given day. The summer of 2014 alone saw an invasion of Birzeit University in the West Bank that included more than one hundred soldiers breaking university property, confiscating phones and keys, and removing images of killed Palestinians.Footnote 17 During the same months, Israeli bombardments of Gaza targeted the Islamic University in Gaza City, as well as UN schools.Footnote 18
Moreover, throughout the summer of 2014, many Israeli universities wrote in strong defense of Israeli state operations in Gaza and the West Bank. As institutions, or on the level of departments and individual chairs, many of these universities have strong ties and share research interests with the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF).Footnote 19 Criticism of Israeli policies by Jewish Israelis within these institutions is often virulently attacked and its proponents silenced through threats and shaming.
For international scholars hoping to teach or research in Palestine or send their students to study there, the restrictions imposed by Israeli authorities can also be dire. Scholars and teachers working on Palestine know, often from their own experience, that Israel imposes restrictions on research, study, and teaching. When entering and leaving Israel, or moving through it, researchers and travelers can be subject to intense questioning, refused entry and sent back, or harassed at checkpoints. Such practices of the Israeli state in harassing, intimidating, and denying entry to foreign scholars and students, as well as Palestinian ones, is a serious restraint to academic freedom. Moreover, these restrictions also limit the exposure, academic freedom, and access to scholarly exchange permitted to Israeli students and scholars, whose own academic experiences are weakened through a regulation of discourse with Palestinians—about Palestinian culture, history, and life, and regarding the present or future state of relations with them.
Why a Cultural Boycott?
All of the artists we have worked with in our research have faced and experienced different aspects of the Israeli occupation and its restrictions on their creative and professional work. While the visibility of Palestinian artists on international stages is increasing, like all Palestinians, they continue to face obstacles to their freedom of mobility, both within the occupied Palestinian territories and abroad. These range from waits at checkpoints, denied permits to consulates for appointments for international visas, denied exit permits even once international visas have been secured, arrest, interrogation, administrative detention, physical violence, and abuse. Although accounts of these obstacles are many, the following examples highlight the effect these have on the work of our colleagues.
Generally, Arabic-language theatre productions in Haifa regularly face funding cuts and censure in direct violation of their rights to freedom of expression.Footnote 20 During the summer of 2014, Palestinian artist Khaled Jarrar was denied exiting the West Bank to travel to the opening and showcasing of his work in the United States, despite having obtained a valid US visa.Footnote 21 In 2015, Palestinian filmmaker and cartoonist Amer Shomali was denied a security permit needed to visit the American consulate in Jerusalem and, as a result, was unable to attend the premiere of his film The Wanted 18 in New York City.Footnote 22 In December 2015, Palestinian Circus School trainer and performer Mohammad Abu Sakha was arrested and held in administrative detention until August 2017.Footnote 23 Also in 2015, Palestinian poet Dareen Tatour, a citizen of Israel, was arrested and imprisoned for publishing a poem and two Facebook posts. After her release from prison, she was placed under house arrest awaiting trial.Footnote 24 In 2016, Mustafa Sheta, a senior staff member of the Freedom Theatre in Jenin, was denied exit permits to travel abroad with the troupe for performances.Footnote 25 And in April 2018, the self-taught filmmaker and cameraman Yasser Murtaja was shot in the stomach by the Israeli military while covering the protests in Gaza mentioned at the beginning of this article. He died shortly thereafter.Footnote 26
Even in the West Bank, where the Palestinian Authority exercises limited sovereignty, Palestinian theatre and performance makers and their audiences are regularly confronted with obstacles to their freedom of mobility. In 2012, Nabil Al Ra'ee, the artistic director of Jenin's Freedom Theatre was arrested and detained.Footnote 27 The Freedom Theatre, the Palestinian Circus School, Alrowwad Cultural and Arts Society—places, repertoires, and practitioners who form or have formed the subject of our research—have all been raided or interrupted at various points by the IDF or the collaborating Palestinian Authority.Footnote 28 Artistic collaboration and exchange between artists in Gaza and the West Bank is all but impossible as long as the siege of Gaza continues.Footnote 29
What Does an Academic and Cultural Boycott Mean?
In this context, what does it mean to endorse an academic and cultural boycott? First and foremost, it refuses a culture of normalization with an occupying power. It refuses the notion that business, study, and exchange can pretend to continue as usual while Israeli policy poses obstacles to the same kinds of collaboration with Palestinian colleagues.
It has been argued that a cultural and academic boycott is not an appropriate response to the conditions in Palestine. This argument is inclined to insist that it is better to build bridges and create dialogue. Critically, this reasoning assumes a shared ability to cross bridges. It does not acknowledge that there is a checkpoint on one side and not on the other. The idea of a multicultural gathering where all can discuss their experiences is noble in principle, but impossible in a practical reality where Palestinians are not given the same access to the conversation. In other words, it is politically problematic to collaborate with Israeli academic and arts organizations as long as these institutions remain complicit with the structures that restrict Palestinian access to artistic expression, education, and self-determination. Elaborations of multiculturalism, tolerance, and exchange ring hollow in rooms that our Palestinian colleagues are not allowed to enter.
That said, there is no closed formula for what an academic and cultural boycott might look like. We assert that it should be a coordinated and solid set of actions, inscribed into a broader strategy at different levels. For instance, the plight of Palestinians can and should lead to other critiques of neocolonial intervention in the Middle East and elsewhere. An academic and cultural boycott should engage Palestinian grassroots organizations and international institutions, academics, and practitioners. As proposed here, it responds to a call from Palestinian scholars, artists, and civil society.
Finally, an academic and cultural boycott should not aim at targeting individuals. This would perpetuate bias based on ethnic or religious identity that should be eradicated. The boycott is of institutions, not individuals, and of professional affiliation, not religious or ethnic identity. Exchange and collaboration with our sympathetic Israeli colleagues and mentors continues as long as it is not facilitated by Israeli institutions, grants, or other exclusionary state institutions, and as long as that collaboration does not normalize the occupation and its crimes.Footnote 30 The Palestinian call for an academic boycott
urges academics, academic associations/unions, and academic—as well as other—institutions around the world, where possible and as relevant, to boycott and/or work towards the cancellation or annulment of events, activities, agreements, or projects involving Israeli academic institutions or that otherwise promote the normalization of Israel in the global academy, whitewash Israel's violations of international law and Palestinian rights, or violate the BDS guidelines.Footnote 31
In line with this call, we envision a boycott of: conferences, events, and projects sponsored by Israeli institutions; Israeli government representatives at academic events and in support of research projects; and projects that normalize the occupation and the unequal relationship between Palestinians and Israelis. Such a boycott performs an important political position of solidarity with Palestinian colleagues without violating the academic freedom of their Israeli counterparts. Indeed, we urge discussion of such a stance in the name of academic freedom of both Palestinians and Israelis.
In a 2013 editorial in The Nation, Judith Butler sees “the rights of mobility” in occupied Palestine deeply entwined with questions of academic freedom.Footnote 32 Butler invokes the constraints on Palestinian mobility in her analysis of one common counterargument against BDS: the claim to an abstract, universal “academic freedom.” She notes that this has been invoked only in defense of hypothetically boycotted Israeli scholars, and not in reaction to the ongoing obstacles to academic freedom of Palestinian students and scholars under occupation. Like Butler, we urge a consideration of actually extant threats to academic freedom—like those imposed by the occupation on Palestinians. And we urge debates in public forums to evaluate what might be an appropriate response.
Conclusion
As noted in the introduction, recent events have put Palestine back in the news. The question, it seems to us, is how we, as theatre scholars and practitioners, can respond to the open call from Palestinian theatre scholars and practitioners for actionable solidarity against ongoing violations of Palestinian rights. Palestinian civil society and our colleagues, Palestinian theatre and performance makers, have asked the international community for something that they think would significantly improve the conditions in which they work, live, and make art. The 2014 letter we refer to above is but one of many pleas by Palestinian artists and civil society to the international community to recognize the conditions they endure because of Israeli state policies, and to do something about it. It is time that we seriously consider their requests.
It is true that we can and should continue to deliberate political positions privately and among close friends and colleagues. We can individually read, research, listen to testimony, and make private choices. The diverse nature of our discipline ensures that the paths we each might take in this research are myriad. We write to ask, however, if it is not time to have a public discussion on this issue. We ask for a debate, as a scholarly and artistic community, of the call from Palestinian theatre makers to join them in solidarity. We ask to bring out among us, as colleagues, the individual paths of research we each undertake in exploring the responsibility to answer that call. We ask for a consideration of what is at stake if we do so and why. On a regular basis, we acknowledge in our research and in our classrooms the injustices that have been bred by patriarchy, ableism, colonialism, racism, and classism. We ask that the same careful and empathetic consideration be applied to our contemporary moment and to the configurations of academic freedom, mobility, and censorship that extend to our colleagues in Palestine.
