Well researched and well written, Discipline and Desire: Surveillance Technologies in Performance provides an innovative study of surveillance art and performance. Elise Morrison carefully documents and analyzes a broad set of examples organized into chapters that map both physical and conceptual spaces. Morrison's introduction offers a short history of surveillance technologies “in overtly disciplinary projects” (4), such as those of the military, law enforcement, and corporations. She connects these more formal practices to the “‘soft cage’ of surveillance society” (4), in which employment, socializing, traveling, and shopping demand our complicity. She notes, however, that despite widespread interest in the media and academia, “alternative, creative responses to living in a rapidly expanding surveillance society have been harder to find” (5). Discipline and Desire addresses this gap, arguing that “surveillance art generates creative and critical alternatives to dominant, mainstream applications of surveillance technologies rather than simply reacting against them” (5).
Chapter 1, “Stages,” addresses surveillance theatre, which “challenge[s] paradigmatic constructions” by “fail[ing] to provide fixed points of representation and reception that align neatly or remain secure” (62). The productions Morrison analyzes include Theater of the Eighth Day's The Files (2007), with its bizarre look at one's own secret police files; Edit Kaldor's Point Blank (2007), with its troubled evidence of spyware; Shunt Collective's Contains Violence (2008), with its “rooftop espionage” (53); and Branden Jacobs-Jenkins's An Octoroon (2013), with its meditation on the ever-present historical relevance of Boucicault's The Octoroon. Her argument is that, although sometimes flawed, such work has the potential to upend the “habitual subject positions” (63) that audience members carry with them into the theatre.
In her second chapter, “Streets,” Morrison focuses primarily on the work of Jill Magid and Surveillance Camera Players but brings in Hannah Price, the Yes Men, and Sophie Calle. The author's sophisticated analysis explores what it means to be watched, who gets to watch whom, and how and when the camera can be turned around. Since the Surveillance Camera Players began performing in front of CCTV in the 1990s, the search for “alternatives to the more familiar models of discipline” (71) has grown. In Evidence Locker (2004), Jill Magid sources the archive of footage amassed through CCTV to remap herself within the city of Liverpool after surveillance. Like Sophie Calle, whose The Detective subverts the (male) gaze of surveillance while playing between fact and fantasy, Magid critiques “the typical disciplinary narratives of a victimized female subject under surveillance” (89). The tension between truth and lies emerges as well in the Yes Men's 2001 performance of fake public relations at the Textiles of the Future conference in Tampere, Finland, at which they exhibited their “‘Employee Visualization Appendage,’” a wearable device complete with a phallus-monitor to allow managers to “comfortably go about their daily leisure activities … while easily watching workers on their monitors, which extended upward from their groins” (80). Finally, Hannah Price's The City of Brotherly Love (2013), photographic portraits of men who catcalled her on the street, aimed not simply to turn the lens on the harassers but to serve as “means of interrupting habitual actions and reactions” (93) between men and women in public. All these, Morrison argues, aim “to disrupt systems of surveillance and reassert ethical imperatives within them by seeking to humanize faces, experiences, and desires across the typically anonymous surveillant interfaces” (99).
In “Screens,” Chapter 3, Morrison reveals how works such as Wafaa Bilal's Domestic Tension (2007) engage audiences on an interactive and critical level. Bilal's durational performance used the artist's real body to demonstrate the virtual and physical effects that videogamelike remote technologies have on both actual and metaphorical levels as player-spectators “‘shoot an Iraqi’” (101). These and other examples “stage (via the screen) the sometimes subtle, sometimes glaring differences in mobility, access, and connectivity” (105–6) that social subjects experience. Morrison breaks down performances into two categories: the more disruptive “‘user-unfriendly in(ter)ventions’” (106) and “‘re-visioning rights’” (106), actions that operate within dominant systems. The final section of the chapter examines Blast Theory's Rider Spoke (2007) and the online film I Love Alaska, which mined leaked AOL user data, to offer a new dramaturgy of the surveillance screen dependent on viewer participation.
More conceptual than the earlier physical or spatial categories, “Sex” defines Chapter 4, allowing Morrison to “refer to the complex interplay of gender identity; normative and transgressive sexual desires; visual, aural, and embodied eroticism; and the anxiety over controlling these as they are manifested in bodies of and under surveillance” (145). Artists in this chapter include Steve Mann, Jill Magid, Giles Walker, Mona Hatoum, and Janet Cardiff. Chapter 4 ties in directly with the exploration of “Skin” in Chapter 5. Morrison looks at performance artists and activists who “investigate the relationship between the corporeal body and its digital double” (186). Keeping this tension close throughout the chapter, Morrison's three categories—“‘masking,’ ‘mirroring,’ and ‘mapping’” (186)—enable a rigorous study of how surveillance and theatre, skin and biometrics, create opportunities to use and subvert the body of surveillance.
The final “S” is “Skies,” a chapter about drones and the havoc and art they wreak. Artists like James Bridle are known for, yes, the genre of “drone art” (234). Bridle's Drone Shadows (2012) theorizes the massive weight of the shadow of the drone on the ground, even as work such as Angel Nevarez and Alex Rivera's Lowdrone (2012) recasts the threat of the drone as a border-crossing free agent. Morrison admits that drone art doesn't have the answers; however, such work poses “important ethical and aesthetic questions that challenge the presiding arbiters of drone use in military, state, and commercial realms” (267). Drones, we all have to agree, aren't going anywhere, and Morrison suggests that artists “must continue to use drones to create vital new forms of activism, mobility, storytelling, empathy and ethical witnessing” (267).
The book ends with a forward-looking “Coda” in which Morrison acknowledges the difficult task of keeping up with technology in/and performance. She welcomes new studies of surveillance art, the “critical and invaluable genre of performance within surveillance society” (268). Morrison's vivid descriptions and sophisticated analyses have certainly set a high bar.
