Scholarship that goes beyond the well-worn narratives of enslavement and darkness is still a rarity in the historiography of southeastern Europe during Ottoman rule. For a multitude of reasons ranging from the practical to the epistemological, the intellectual vigor and theoretical sophistication that have recently transformed the field of Ottoman studies with respect to the empire's Arab periphery are yet to come to fruition on the Balkan front. The present volume by itself does not represent, nor does it purport to be, the complete reversal of this unfortunate trend, but it is a welcome addition to the rather meager inventory of scholarship promising better times for those of us who would like to see the Ottoman Balkans move out of the academic ghetto they currently inhabit. Many of the articles in the collection reveal the emergence of a new research agenda that would incorporate the Ottoman past as an integral part of local history as opposed to an aberration best left for the pursuit of Turkish/Muslim historians searching for traces of their now extinct presence in the area.
However, this agenda is not entirely followed through in the book: it offers new lines of inquiry, but most of the articles travel only part way down the suggested path. I hasten to add that although this might have been a serious flaw in an edited volume of original articles, the fact that the contributions do not pretend to be anything but conference proceedings mitigates this problem. In fact, the collection offers an encouraging picture of what shape the field might take in the near future.
The conference organizers state their purpose: to evaluate “the process of de-legitimisation of Ottoman rule in the Balkans in the late 18th and early 19th centuries up to and including the Greek revolution of 1821” (p. ix). This is a project long overdue. Accounts of “national awakening” coupled with the trope of “Ottoman decline” have not yet been replaced by a historiography that might offer a better understanding of the shifts in the interplay between imperial and local bases of power and how those shifts were perceived at the societal level. The chronological focus of the book, the period immediately preceding the so-called Age of Nationalism, is wisely chosen, because this period is crucial in reconstructing the narrative of the long 19th century, the second half of which seems to dominate—and often distort—our vision of what came before. A common theme that emerges from this collection, and arguably its most important contribution, is the failure of ethnic/religious divisions in explaining different forms of resistance to central authority. If we are to appreciate the full range of complex, and sometimes contradictory, influences that were ultimately subsumed under national independence movements, it is imperative that we establish the late 18th-century context of political fragmentation and reconfigured local power relations. Another strong point of the collection is the empirical information it offers in qualifying that complexity.
The articles are grouped in four sections. As is usually the case with collections of this sort, there is some variation in quality and a lack of engagement among the individual articles. The first section, “The Ottoman Balkans around 1800,” includes an essay by Gergana Georgieva on the functions of the vali of Rumelia. Next is an entry by Viorel Panaite, which takes up what the author asserts is the poorly understood administrative status of the Danubian principalities. Antonis Anastasopoulos revisits Karaferye (Veroia) and explores the extent to which kadı sicilleri can be used in order to gauge the impact of Nizam-ı Cedid reforms at the local level. The (in)famous Ali Pasha of Ioannina and his religiously mixed entourage are the topic of Dimitris Dimitropoulos's article, which documents how the pasha used revenue collection and redistribution as a tool to consolidate his power. Rossitsa Gradeva investigates the possible contacts and presumed alliance between a well-known ayan, namely, Osman Pasvantoglu of Vidin, and an unlikely interlocutor, the liberal visionary and “protomartyr” of Greek liberation, Rhigas Pheraios Velestinlis. Osman Pasvantoglu reappears in Rachida Tlili Sellaoutì's paper, which focuses not so much on the motives of Pasvantoglu as it does on the French imperial agenda and the task of reconciling it with republican ideals.
The second part of the collection centers on the prerevolutionary Peloponnese. Depredations of the Ottoman military in the 1760s are the topic of Anna Vlachopoulou's paper. Martha Pylia maps out the clientage networks among the Peloponnesian primates and their relations to the next tier of ayan in the hierarchy of power. What follows is a complementary article by Demetrios Stamatopoulos on the struggle over the office of the Dragoman, who was not simply the interpreter of the centrally appointed governor but also a power broker who mediated between the governor and the ayan in a three-pronged scheme that he calls “the pre-revolutionary structure of power in the Peloponnese” (p. 151).
The third section is dedicated to the Greek revolution. Panagiotis Stathis demystifies entrenched narratives concerning the participation of the klephts and armatoloi in the revolution. Christine Philliou engages these narratives head on by calling into question the very categories of “Greek” and “revolution” and showcasing, inter alia, the career of one “ambitious Ottoman Christian” (p. 193) who managed to cope with the adverse winds of 1821 that many Phanariots did not survive. Christos Loukos underscores the importance of incorporating non-Greek sources to fill in gaps in our knowledge of the revolution. Vassilis Dimitriadis presents scenes of dispossession, displacement, and violence from Crete following the revolution and calls our attention to the fact that it was not only Christians but also local Muslims who wanted some form of deliverance from the interference of the central government. The last article in this section is by Hakan Erdem, an extremely significant contribution concerning the emergence of a distinctly Albanian sense of identity and territory.
Finally, papers by Čedomir Antić and Cengiz Kırlı make up the epilogue. Antić writes about what he calls the “re-Ottomanization of the Principality of Serbia” (p. 248) after 1838. Kırlı introduces an underutilized source, reports of government informers, and captures the disparate commentaries of common people.
The book is not intended for a wide audience: the introduction does not provide sufficient context, the articles assume prior knowledge of the issues discussed, the language and style make it difficult to follow the main arguments in certain cases, and there is no bibliography or index. It will be useful, however, for specialists working on related themes. The contents are somewhat slanted toward regions that formed the core of the Greek nation-state. Although this may be construed as apparent bias on the editors' part, it is also a testament to the impressive distance the current generation of Greek scholars has come in (re)constructing the historiography of Tourkokratia. Of more importance, the collection as a whole presents a compelling counterpoint to the Istanbul-centered accounts of center-periphery dynamics in the era of “decline.” Finally, it is refreshing, at least in this reviewer's opinion, to see that the protagonists of “Ottoman history” do not always have to carry names such as Ali, Midhat, or Osman.
