Marc Blitzstein (1905–64), composer, performer, lecturer and writer, has become—in the five decades since his death—the poster boy for the American left-wing musical movement. This portrait was a result of his professional activities in the 1930s, a decade characterized in the arts by an increasing sensitivity to the needs and struggles of a rising working class. In an attempt to engage workers in musical and dramatic pursuits, Blitzstein at first enthusiastically embraced the view of a modern artist who could, in his own words, “reach greatness combining the new discipline with an ideology that more truly reflects the reality of the day.”Footnote 1 Ebullient statements such as these match the now-established image of Blitzstein as a rebel who, on 16 June 1937, ignored an injunction by the federal Works Progress Administration against his trade-union musical, The Cradle Will Rock, and insisted on performing it from an upright piano onstage, without scenery or costumes, and with the actors speaking and singing from seats in the audience. Indeed, most scholarly writings on the composer mainly, or even solely, address his agit-prop theater works. For example, Eric Gordon divided his biography Mark the Music: The Life and Work of Marc Blitzstein (1989), into two parts: the first ending with the production of The Cradle Will Rock, the second starting with other agit-prop works that Blitzstein wrote soon after. The reader may get the impression that Blitzstein's life and output gravitate almost only around his leftist theatrical works of the 1930s and may consign the rest to oblivion.
Against this background, Howard Pollack's new biography offers a veritable breath of fresh air, for it introduces clearly and exhaustively the multifaceted qualities of this enormously inventive and surprisingly prolific composer. The book, divided into an introduction and twenty-five chapters, smoothly connects artistic contributions and personal events in Blitzstein's life. Pollack not only broadens the wealth of factual detail beyond that found in Gordon's biography, he also adds an in-depth engagement with the composer's creative work and addresses issues that underlined Blitzstein's life and career, such as his homosexuality, his marriage with Eva Goldbeck, his Jewish–Russian background, and his love-hate relationship with Kurt Weill's musical theater.
Particularly noteworthy, nonetheless, are the two chapters on the one piece that many music and theater lovers are likely to know: The Cradle Will Rock. In chapter 9, Pollack focuses on the genesis of the piece, meticulously demonstrating the composer's creative and thinking process while offering factual information. In chapter 10, he discusses the production history of the work, from the first contacts with Orson Welles and Hallie Flanagan, the director of the Federal Theatre Project, to the dress rehearsal of the banned production, the stripped-down premiere at the Venice Theatre in New York City, and the run at the Mercury Theatre in the 1937–38 season. Pollack's well-arranged account shows that even though Blitzstein asserted that the elaborate staging planned for the Federal Theatre's original production would enhance the play, the Cradle has remained associated with the transgressive minimalism of its premiere. In fact, for almost a quarter of a century after the Mercury production, the Cradle appeared on amateur, student, and labor stages (mostly for just a handful of performances in each instance) with only piano accompaniment. The most significant production in those years, as Pollack reveals, was a concert version in 1939 at Harvard produced by a young Leonard Bernstein with reduced orchestra and trained singers. Not until 1960 was the show produced as originally conceived (with orchestra, costumes, and scenery) by the New York City Opera with Lehman Engel conducting, Howard Da Silva as director, and David Hays as set designer. I would argue, however, that the Cradle seemed to have been insulated against major criticism as, instead of analyzing the play from a musical point of view, most reviewers of the 1960 production tended to focus on the past, the circumstances of the infamous premiere, and its socio-political message. Indeed, the Cradle has not yet acquired the dramatic and artistic realization Blitzstein hoped for because the myth that the leftist theater created around its premiere became not only its legacy but also a part of its content. One wonders, would a negative critique of the Cradle have been perceived as an implicit endorsement of government censorship? Not surprisingly, the sporadic revivals of the production, continuing to this day, pay homage to the show as part of U.S. history, not as a piece of theater-for-theater’s-sake.
Another valuable chapter of the book addresses Blitzstein's critical writing, an activity that he pursued especially in the 1930s, and a side of his professional involvement that has not always received the attention it deserves. The composer's political and social commitments during the 1930s included not only composing, but also teaching and writing. Blitzstein taught at the Downtown Music School and the New School for Social Research in New York City, and he was one of the most sought-after lecturers on contemporary music and musical theater. As a writer, he contributed to Modern Music, The Musical Quarterly, New Masses, The Daily Worker, the French Revue musicale, and—from its first issue onward—Unison, the official organ of the American Music League. Some of his reviews and articles, along with less formal statements, articulated his ideas about music's social function and are among the most vivid testimonies of the intersection between music and politics in the 1930s. Unfortunately, as was (and remains) true of most other left-oriented composers—one thinks of more recent cases such as Luigi Nono, Hans Werner Henze, and Frederic Rzewski—Blitzstein was unable to reconcile theory with practice or merge the workers’ quest for revolutionary content with his own aspiration for a distinctive American musical style. His political commitments, as well as his fascination with vernacular idioms and musical theater, often put him at odds with what was expected of a “serious” composer, and he never assumed a leading role in U.S. art music.
Aside from his socio-political view, Blitzstein's contributions as a music critic also offer a detailed and lively picture of European and American contemporary music. In chapter 7, Pollack introduces some of his most relevant music reviews, which show not only the composer's knowledge in music, but also his erudition and familiarity with artistic endeavors outside of the musical field. In a direct and quick-witted manner Blitzstein addressed the tensions between modernism and popular music (Weill was often a target of his harsh opinions) and delivered brilliant and at times sharp comments. His commentaries on the works of his contemporaries indicate a deep understanding of the many directions music took between the two World Wars. For instance, in 1931 he argued in Modern Music that Alban Berg's Wozzeck “belongs in the post-war German period, loosely termed expressionism, that period of morbid and neurotic art … the fruit of shock” (vol. 5, no. 6). He claimed that classical forms (such as the rondo) “were probably valuable to Berg as an arbitrary plan in composing music which constantly ran the risk of going off at a tangent.” This far-reaching view of music appears also in the unpublished scripts of the lectures prepared for the series “Form in Music” (1933) and “Masterworks in Modern Music” (1935), material that in handwritten and typewritten form is available in the Blitzstein Estate at the Archives Collection of the State Historical Society of Wisconsin in Madison. If, as Pollack argues, these lectures were to a large extent dictated by financial necessity, it is also true that the scripts are an invaluable source for understanding Blitzstein's ideas on modernism and his varied opinions on the future of American music.
By the end of the 1930s, when the dream of socially relevant music vanished in the face of a growing concern about unstable international political conditions, many composers tried to hide or deny their “revolutionary” involvement. Yet Blitzstein, as noted by Copland in an interview for Muriel Balash's 1976 television program on the composer, persisted in his belief that art music had to be of social relevance, and that its role was to build good citizens. In fact, Blitzstein adjusted his agit-prop protest to better fit social issues associated with the new generation, such as the denunciation of social decay (Regina) or of social injustice (Sacco and Vanzetti), but he never achieved the success of other contemporaries who turned their backs on the leftist idea of socially engaged music. Nonetheless, as Pollack claims, the composer's legacy should not be associated only with his leftist works, because he is at least also responsible for the creation of an idiosyncratic form of American theater that employs vernacular idioms for dramatic purposes, particularly social commentary, by incorporating features from such American genres as minstrelsy, vaudeville, and revue.
With its detailed discussion of musical sketches and compositions, its insightful use of archival sources, its ethnographic approach based on new interviews with Blitzstein's friends and family, and its wonderfully selected collection of photographs, Pollack's biography significantly deepens our knowledge of a charismatic composer whose effect on American musical theater, according to Leonard Bernstein, is incalculable.
