The Zapatista uprising captured international headlines on 1 January 1994, the day the NAFTA free trade agreement was to go into effect, as a well organised group of insurgents from Chiapas went public. Taking over five county seats and holding the town of San Cristóbal de las Casas for some ten days before the government came to the negotiating table, the Zapatistas won wide attention for their stand against neoliberalism and globalisation. Over the course of the next decade, Chiapas and the Zapatista movement drew many admirers and supporters, at the local level through politically astute governance based on ‘ruling by obeying’ decisions made by community consensus, and at the global level by means of astute use of communications including the internet.
While Subcomandante Marcos received the greatest media coverage, the names of indigenous leaders began to surface. Prominent among them were the names of women – Comandantas Ramona, Esther, Rosalinda and others – who played an important part in advancing Zapatista objectives. From early on, it was apparent that gender politics would be central to the concerns of this social movement, as social justice and political and economic rights were shown to have special meaning for Mexicans who were both indigenous and women.
This edited collection, Dissident Women: Gender and Cultural Politics in Chiapas, will be of interest to Latin Americanists generally, and particularly to those concerned with social movements, opposition to neoliberalism, and gender and race in the Americas. Moreover, it should capture the attention of participants in anti-globalisation initiatives who wish to understand the historical context from which the Zapatista uprising emerged. The contributors include scholars and activists who have had a long association with the Chiapas region and its complex politics.
The book is organised usefully if unconventionally, with the preface followed by key women's documents of the Zapatistas, before the editors' introduction to the volume. The preface is vital to readers' understanding of indigenous organising in the context of Zapatismo and neoliberalism in Mexico. In it Stephen, Speed and Hernández Castillo map the historical events leading to the 1994 uprising as well as the theoretical and political questions that drive the volume. The editors and contributors speak to feminist scholars and activists, cultural anthropologists, and others who stand to benefit from the engaged research presented here. The translation of the Women's Revolutionary Law, announced on 8 March 1993, thus predating the Zapatista uprising, and referred to as the First Uprising, along with other statements of women's rights to health, education, reproductive decision-making and social participation, is very useful. The translation of Comandanta Esther's speech before Mexico's Congress in 2001 presents a particularly eloquent appeal for the government to respect difference and end the marginalisation of indigenous people; her repeated refrain as ‘a poor, indigenous, Zapatista woman’ powerfully conveys her impact on that historic occasion.
The introduction by the co-editors theorises these indigenous women as new social actors and as dissidents who have joined their male counterparts in claiming ‘Never again a Mexico without us’ (p. 34). Challenging assimilationist notions of the mestizo Mexican nation, Zapatista women go still further to point out that social citizenship and belonging elude indigenous women even more than men. Moreover, these women do not hesitate to make it known that their own men have opposed their political participation. But fundamentally this is a collective movement that draws together women and men who insist on cultural rights as much as on economic redistribution.
The rest of the book is divided into two sections which offer broad background discussion and close ethnographic case studies. In the first, Hernández Castillo critiques the twin problems of feminist ethnocentricism and indigenous machismo, and argues that Zapatista women are confronting both. At times, the invocation of ‘hegemonic feminism’ seems to set forth still another of the stereotyped notions that the authors wish to avoid, yet it is clear that the contributors are self-reflective as they call for a transformation of academic feminism to a more inclusive form. Márgara Millán Moncayo presents rich interview material as she examines how women came to join up with the Zapatista movement and what resistance they met from their husbands and families; the struggle for democracy is shown to have profoundly personal – and gendered – dimensions in these accounts.
In the contribution by Sonia Toledo Tello and Anna María Garza Caligaris, there is discussion of what has been called ‘strategic essentialism’ by social movement analysts examining ways that subordinated groups may elect to make use of stereotypes to subvert oppression. In this case, women are shown to have become increasingly active political subjects even as they continued to be represented by the dominant society as ‘poor, indigenous women’ who would be unlikely to rebel or assume leadership. As such, discourses of ‘helpless victims’ could enable women quietly but persistently to undermine traditional expectations and make political gains. Contradictory notions of indigenous women as naturally weak, yet holding prominent positions in the Zapatista struggle, have destabilised any easy expectations of them. Maylei Blackwell uses feminist geographers' concept of ‘scales of power’ to investigate women's participation in Zapatista politics from the local to national and transnational levels. In so doing, she discovers the new political subjectivities that evolve as women develop organising skills and are empowered. Here again, the personal narratives of women are the most compelling form of evidence presented to illustrate the hybrid political identities and strategies that are emerging from local to global scales.
Stephen's chapter considers women's activism in both Chiapas and Oaxaca, looking at their histories of civil-religious participation and asking ‘how have women's roles changed significantly in Zapatista communities?’ (p. 162). Noting the exclusion of women from traditional positions of authority and women's complaints that it was not only ‘custom’ but ‘machismo’ that kept them from political participation, Stephen shows that it is not simply ‘outside influence’ that accounts for the attention to women's rights. She argues that it is necessary to examine ‘community-specific gender roles’ to see that women draw on some traditions even as they reject others they deem restrictive. This is what Melissa Forbis suggests as well, as she presents the ethnographic case study of a Zapatista autonomous community in which women became active in an herbal medicine training project. The women were empowered through their participation in the work, which sought to overcome the very poor health conditions characteristic of Chiapas. As part of the campaign for the ‘right to have rights’, these women proclaimed their right to cultural difference, in this case alternatives to Western biomedicine. Offering examples from the experiences of health promotoras, Forbis relates that they had to overcome cultural obstacles within and outside the community in order to find collective solutions to health care needs.
Speed provocatively examines the tension between individual and collective rights, a theme also taken up by other contributors. She is not alone in occasionally falling into the binary view of gender/individual and indigenous/collective, rather than recognising that both gender and indigenous identities can have individual and collective dimensions. When the authors at times describe feminism as a form of hegemonic individualism, this has the unintended consequence of marginalising some strains of gender politics that it seeks to support. Following on earlier divisions in Latin America between women's rights and human rights, and between feminist and women's movements, Speed points to a current split between those supporting ‘women's rights’ and those supporting ‘cultural rights’. The debate over such positions may be inevitable, though the ‘cultural’ need not always trump ‘gender’, particularly since, as several authors note, indigenous women are a diverse group holding various political perspectives.
The volume ends on a positive note with a piece by Violeta Zylberberg Panebianco that offers an ethnographic case study to illustrate the daily life experiences of women in Zapatista base communities. Like other authors in the volume, she brings her personal experience to the account, recalling her first visits to the community just after she finished high school; in fact, after many more visits there, her piece was prepared as an undergraduate paper, giving us a sense of the promise of a new generation of scholars. She describes the everyday meaning of military occupation, displacement, and violence among women who have made extraordinary efforts to carry out basic family and community needs. She relates powerful stories of women who, as she writes, ‘turn discourses of women's rights into daily practices’ (p. 236).
There is occasional repetition in this collection as several authors cover similar ground in introducing their subjects, and it would have been helpful to have notes on the contributors. But these are minor matters and this book stands to make a significant contribution to the growing literature on Latin American social movements and particularly to discussions of struggles over cultural differences and gender relations in the context of neoliberalism.
