When the United States invaded Iraq in 2003 and overthrew the regime of Saddam Hussein, a recurring theme among the supporters of the invasion was that a new democratic and stable Iraq would emerge on the ruins of the Baʿthist system. In December 2011, as the American military mission in Iraq officially came to an end, neither democracy nor stability had been established in that country. On the contrary, hundreds of thousands of ordinary Iraqis have been killed and injured since the country was occupied, and more than a million Iraqi citizens were turned into external or internal refugees. Many vital services, such as electricity and clean water, remain woefully inadequate. The country's university system, which two decades ago was among the best in the Arab world, is now among the worst.
This book, written by an independent scholar of Middle East studies and an Iraqi native, seeks to explain some of the causes and consequences of the disintegration of Iraqi society and the Iraqi body politic. It is divided into fourteen chapters, each dealing with various sociopolitical issues in contemporary Iraq, such as sectarianism, federalism, minorities, and women as well as oil and corruption. Ghanim does not dwell on the U.S. role or the legacy of the American occupation of Iraq. He states that the Iraqi people should be “grateful for American sacrifices that helped to create a unique prospect for Iraqi society” (p. 8). What the author is implying is that Washington's post-2003 policies in Iraq are not the principal contributing factors leading to the current sociopolitical malaise in the country.
The author identifies four major variables that have contributed to the debacle in post-Saddam Iraq. One factor is the full sociopolitical, economic, and psychological impact of years of sanctions that the Iraqis had to endure between the end of the 1991 Gulf war and the overthrow of the Baʿthist government, which had already decimated Iraqi society before the 2003 invasion. The second factor has been the rise of political Islam and of identity (or sectarian) politics in Iraq along with their myriad destabilizing implications. A third factor according to Ghanim is the role of Iranian policies in the continuation of the crisis in Iraq. He accuses Iran of high-handed involvement in Iraqi politics while disregarding the debilitating and destabilizing role of the conservative Gulf Arab states, such as Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, in funding an assortment of anti-Shiʿa extremist groups that continue to pulverize Iraqi society through bombing and assassination campaigns. The fourth and final factor that Ghanim cites is the lack of international support for the invasion and many of the subsequent occupation policies, which were contributing factors to what the author refers to as Iraq's dysfunctioning government.
The overthrow of Saddam Hussein's regime allowed the victims of that system to claim a political stake for themselves in the new Iraq. Both the Kurdish minority and the Shiʿi groups that had been victimized by the previous regime took advantage of the post-Saddam political vacuum to become significant power wielders in the country. Ghanim argues that although many individuals and groups were in fact victims of Saddam Hussein's regime, the Kurds and Shiʿa have institutionalized their sense of victimization by pushing for a political system that has created new victims. This has led to what the author argues is dwindling minority rights, debasement of women's rights, and the perpetuation of the politics of revenge in the country. This politics of exclusion, Ghanim contends, was further solidified through a series of purges under the rubric of de-Baʿthification.
Iraq's constitution, which, among other things, established a federal system, has unwittingly contributed to the sectarian gap that has bedeviled Iraqi society. Furthermore, the constitution does not provide a clear mechanism for determining the basic principles of any political order. As a consequence, the relationship between the Iraqi central government and the Kurdish Regional Government, for example, remains for the most part acrimonious, and the Kurdish Regional Government's prime minster has on several occasions threatened to establish an independent Kurdish state in the north. Likewise, some oil-rich southern regions (e.g., Basra) have demanded more autonomy from the central government. The author provides a refreshing analysis of how sectarianism and its divisive proportional representation electoral system have added to the democracy deficit in Iraq despite the holding of regular elections in the country.
Iraq's judiciary, moreover, remains woefully inadequate, demonstrated by the flawed trials of many Iraqis in the aftermath of the demise of Saddam Hussein's regime. Ghanim explains how the trial of Saddam Hussein and his associates lacked many of the basic attributes of impartiality. This does not bode well for establishing the kind of robust and independent judiciary that any democratic system requires. Partly due to purges of the Iraqi judiciary, there is no longer an adequate number of trained and qualified judges in the country.
Pervasive corruption and general unaccountability of the governing elites are among the other issues examined in this book. The author concedes that the post-Saddam regime inherited a legacy of corruption. However, he argues that in today's Iraq, corruption has become more serious than it was before and that the “culture of corruption” has now “spiraled out of control” (p. 214). Ghanim provides several examples of corrupt practices by almost every ministry and government bureaucracy in the country. He cites figures from U.S. financial investigations that put the amount of money lost to corruption of the Iraqi government at $4 billion a year, which is equal to 10 percent of the country's national income.
All in all, this is a hard-hitting critical analysis of Iraq's post-2003 political order and a welcome addition to the growing literature on post-Saddam Iraq. Policymakers as well as scholars and students of Middle East politics will benefit from this well-researched and cogently argued book.
