Among urban sociologists and comparative historians, few issues command as much attention as the uneven development of global capitalism. Scholars continue to debate contentious topics such as the rise of the world capitalist economy, the exploitative nature of globalization, and the rapid emergence of hyperurbanized cities characterized by widespread poverty. Mohammad A. Chaichian, a professor in the Department of Sociology at Mount Mercy College, attempts to contribute to these discussions by studying the effects of commercial capitalism in modern Iran and Egypt. The author organizes his book into four discrete sections that trace different patterns of spatial development, urban hierarchies, and the growth of petty commodity production in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Part I discusses the theoretical and methodological considerations of comparing dependent urbanization in both countries and formulates a hypothesis based on the historical specificity of rural–urban migration in different time periods. Part II focuses on the nature of dependent urbanization in Iran from 1800 to the 1979 revolution. It concludes with a discussion of uneven development and hyperurbanization in Tehran by evaluating the historical conditions that paved the way for Iran's capitalist development. Part III explores the complexities of dependent capitalism and urbanization in Egypt from 1798 to 1970. The four chapters in this section are devoted to an analysis of socioeconomic and spatial changes before and after the 1882 British occupation, with an emphasis on the distorted urban development of Cairo and Alexandria. Part IV concludes with a comparative analysis of the divergent paths of Iranian and Egyptian urbanization as well as the emergence of capitalist markets in both countries since 1970.
Chaichian is an ambitious scholar who is deeply interested in the internal and external processes of social change and the deleterious effects of globalization. The case studies in this book highlight conflicting patterns of capitalist development for Tehran and Cairo and their convergence in the employment structure of the petty commodity production sector. The author shows how the occupational categories within this sector helped facilitate the distribution of consumer goods in the marketplace. Detailed statistical tables, maps, and census figures make the case that different types of dependency have contributed to differences in the timing of Iran and Egypt's incorporation into the world capitalist economy. By focusing on Tehran and Cairo as the two countries’ capital cities, Chaichian contends that dependent urbanization in both countries played a significant role in displacing rural populations and inducing their migration to major urban centers. This sweeping overview of Iranian and Egyptian history is suggestive but ultimately unpersuasive due in large part to the deterministic formulation of this book.
As a sociological study, Town and Country in the Middle East does not contribute to existing debates in Egyptian and Iranian social history. Because Chaichian refrains from seriously addressing the lived realities of urban Iranians in Tehran and Egyptians in Cairo, the theoretical contributions of his work are limited. Instead, the author confines his theoretical framework to Karl Marx's writings on urban development and David Harvey's more recent studies of globalization. With respect to 20th-century Cairo, incorporating the contributions of scholars who write about urbanization, such as Farha Ghannam, Kamran Ali, Diane Singerman, and Homa Hoodfar, could have provided this book with nuance and critical insight into the processes that drive urbanization and its discontents. Chaichian also never explicitly explores the cause and effect relationship between overpopulation, urbanization, and dependent capitalism. How do family planning, birth control, and notions of piety factor into this relationship? Although the author writes succinctly about historical patterns of rural–urban migration and petty commodity production, his examples are schematic and do not draw on the secondary literature in English, Farsi, or Arabic that addresses many of the issues that preoccupy him.
Likewise, the book as a whole does not provide sufficient rationale for the author's comparison of urban development in Iran and Egypt. Chaichian admits in Chapters 2 and 11 that he is to an extent comparing the incomparable, given the geographical, sociopolitical, and economic differences between the two countries. To be sure, Egypt and Iran did experience somewhat similar processes of urbanization and rural–urban migration in the period under study, but the statistical data that Chaichian marshals in defense of his thesis is either incomplete or questionable. This results in a truncated survey of the historical and sociological factors that contributed to the massive urban development of Cairo and Tehran over the 19th and 20th centuries. The flawed data that the author uses (most notably, with respect to census data) prompts the reader to question why he selected Tehran and Cairo as joint case studies. Why not, for example, examine comparative processes of dependent capitalism and urbanization in Tehran and Istanbul from 1800 to 1970?
Given these theoretical and methodological limitations, I find it difficult to recommend this book to colleagues in the fields of Egyptian and Iranian social history. While there is an urgent need for comparative scholarship that untangles the complex history of colonialism and capitalism in Iran and North Africa, Town and Country in the Middle East fails to fill this gap. Chaichian's dated approach does not effectively utilize original primary sources and recent secondary literature nor does it provide a fresh interpretation of dependent urbanization. Instead, more expansive theorization that takes into account the contingent nature of globalization and incorporates comparative archival research can help expand the fields of urban sociology and history in Middle East studies.
