This book is about “the law governing relations inter se among international organizations”. It focuses on the organizations named in its title and its contents list runs to fifteen pages with detailed tabulation, thus facilitating referencing to the precise area required by the reader.
Patel notes that the rationale for the book is the lack of attention to the responsibility between international organizations (IOs) not “only in policy-circles but also in the academic and scholarly community” (p. 1). According to Patel, the context of the IOs’ “expansion of their mandates and scope of activities, their rights and obligations appear to be commensurate with those between two States” (p. 2). However, the growth of IOs can perhaps be better categorized not simply as an expansion but as an explosion. The current Yearbook of International Organizations Online 2014–2015 notes that it covers “over 38,000 active international organizations … from 300 countries and territories … [and] [a]pproximately 1,200 new organizations are added each year”.Footnote 5
A perusal of the twenty-page bibliography illustrates that numerous articles or texts have been written about IOs, but only in more generalized contexts; in analyzing in detail the four nominated IOs, this book consolidates the current law in this area. Patel concludes that more explicit rules and principles are required not only because of the aforementioned expansion but because “there is a danger that if this issue is not addressed, then the conflicts between IOs will be concealed which will have financial, political and legal implications”. Further “the IOs as responsible actors of [the] international system cannot remain outside the ambit of responsibility for the breach of obligations or accountability among themselves” (p. 325).
Patel suggests that “there is no need for a treaty but that model rules are imperative at this stage. A UN General Assembly resolution would be very helpful. Alternatively, the work of the International Law Commission (ILC) on responsibility of IOs should address inter-organizational relations and obligations as an integral element of its discussion … in other words, these rules can be considered as [a] code of conduct” (p. 326). Patel further “concurs with the current opinion of the ILA and the writings of several authors that the Draft Articles on State Responsibility are patently inapplicable to the IOs; however the fundamental legal philosophy which underpinned the State responsibility should guide the debate on inter-organizational relations” (p. 328, note 1). Patel hopes “that the current work of the ILC will broaden its scope to include this issue so that Draft Articles on the Responsibility of IOs (DARIO) will cater to the solution of the problem” (p. 328, note 1).
Patel’s book covers in detail an emerging area of international law that impacts on the converging areas of international and national law and lays a foundation for further analysis.
