Drawing on such disparate materials as courtship letters, honeymoon diaries, sexual conduct books, phrenological charts, and writings on pregnancy and childbearing, this multidisciplinary study scrutinizes the different discourses that record the transformation of the honeymoon from a nation-building ritual into a ubiquitous cultural practice with lasting sentimental and consumerist connotations. Its author contends that both during the 1820s and the 1830s honeymooning initially played an important part in the symbolic construction of America through the public display of affection and the planning of trips to sights drenched with aesthetic or morally instructive significance. However, over the decades the nationalist overtones of the earliest bridal tours gave way to a more complex and conflicting view of post-wedding practices in which the private celebration of love, domesticity, and procreation often collided with public allusions to promiscuity and open displays of luxury. Honeymooning, this book claims, was not a manipulative strategy designed by nineteenth-century capitalist and patriarchal superstructures, as some might be tempted to believe, but rather a positive ritual that “promised change, knowledge and experience to be gained through the journey and beyond” (231).
An engaging part of Penner's study is devoted to explaining how the patriotic stance of the first bridal tours shifted towards a new sentimental notion of honeymooning that achieved visibility during the 1850s with a half-idealized and half-mocking representation of newlyweds in many popular publications and prints. Vis-à-vis analyses of contemporary artworks, Penner offers an insightful reading of Howells's Their Wedding Journey, a novel that, she asserts, in spite of showing the lovers' failures and stereotypical behavior, “does not seek to cast doubt on the powers of affect” (100). Another relevant section investigates the nexus between honeymooning and the discourses of the emerging capitalist marketplace, exemplified through a detailed analysis of the prominence that bridal chambers enjoyed in many American steamboats and hotels. Penner argues that these bedrooms, whose luxury was widely advertised, epitomized both a private and a public space where wedded love often became a commercial issue that sensation novels like George Lippard's The Quaker City – lucidly discussed by Penner – rapidly exploited.
Penner's meticulous research deftly shows that moral reformers, aware of the threat that such scenarios might pose to middle-class female morality, soon proposed alternative honeymoons with back-to-nature retreats to villas or sojourns in the wilderness in which the daily chores of camping served as a prelude to domestic marital life. She also draws on contemporary caricatures, Alcott's Little Women Married, and the work of architectural reformer Alexander Jackson Davis, among other sources, to assess the value that honeymooning increasingly attached to the act of homecoming; it was precisely in the notion of home, with its inherent affective bonding and its accumulation of consumer goods, where newlyweds finally attained what she terms the “reconciliation between the world of the self and the world of the market” (189). Notwithstanding all the changes it suffered, honeymooning still maintained its iconic presence in many turn-of-the-century publications, Penner remarks, thus proving its currency as a significant cultural practice well into the following century.
The strength of this theoretically sound book lies in its ability to successfully examine a hitherto underexplored topic by resorting to a wide-ranging group of academic disciplines. Penner is at her best, for example, when she comments on the influence of architecture and interior design on honeymooning, but in her analysis of its connections to tourism she focusses too narrowly on the northern tour, principally to Niagara Falls, thus leaving little room for discussing the cultural role played by those newlyweds who traveled abroad. For a study avowedly devoted to surveying the field, one could also wish for more information about the post-wedding practices of underrepresented social and minority groups; nevertheless, this is a fresh and wonderfully informative book that opens new avenues of research in American studies.
