To dwell in a house is to inhabit the world.
—Christian Norberg-Schulz, “The Phenomenon of Place”
We understand little of Harriet Martineau, I am convinced, if we do not see how roots and wings formed the coordinates of both her subjectivity and writing, affecting all the choices she made and all the reasons she gave for those choices. Inextricably bound together like the knot in a rope, her attraction to houses as signs of self must be given equal weight with the experiences of move and travel she wrote of again and again. Emblematic in this sense was perhaps Martineau's own emphatic assessment of herself in a March 1844 letter to Mrs Romilly written during the monotony and impotence of her Tynemouth confinement, in which she described, in terms of a symbolic geography, her sense of being apart and undeniably privileged: “a sort of pioneer in the regions of pain,” this is how she termed herself, “whose mission is to make the way somewhat easier, or at least more direct to those who come after” (Martineau 2007, 2: 262).
But a closer look at her Autobiography will possibly evidence an even bolder stand, rich in developments and tonal variations. Recalling her first prospect of – and struggle for – reaching independence, an attempt she made only in her late youth, Martineau reflected: “I was outgrowing my shell,” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 148) thereby giving expression not only to her own symbolic perception of self but also to that of dwelling. Interesting that she casts it that way, describing it in spatial terms through a metaphor that draws inspiration from the animal world – in this respect, a critical parallel is soon established in the reader's mind between, for instance, Martineau and the turtle with its mobile home; or, going deeper, between her and the hermit crab, the mollusk famous for carrying a protecting shell around on its back that it does not belong to it, and that it smartly switches to a bigger one when, as Gaston Bachelard has cogently noted, “it feels too cramped for space” (126). Though only embryonic in its symbolic underpinning, Martineau's pivotal expression is not the workings of pure chance, but a dominant preoccupation and a precise rendition of the way she encourages us to read her space – a space she pragmatically saw, conceptualised, wrote and used to achieve her ideal domestic dimension as well as to build her inner and outer self. In this sense, I would dare to say, the shell involves a conscious identity strategy on her behalf: denoting at once the interdependency between inner psyche and outward aesthetics, it is imagined to entail both the physical and emotional walls that the writer lavishly constructed, sustained, tore down and eventually re-built all through her life in an endeavor to ascertain her personality and motives.
That a combination of biographical significance and environmental implication is traceable through Martineau's awareness of her own conflict between subjection and autonomy is precisely what I would like to explore here. As it has compellingly theorised, sense of self and space are not isolated entities – instead, they are likely to become integrated, to be related to each other, and not only do they mesh, but they tend to change together over time. Thus, in my spatial reading of Martineau's dialectics of unhortodox domesticity I will be adopting terminology and discourses prevalent among anthropologists, philosophers and geographers to further emphasise the importance of the writer's own deployment of genuine space imagery – home mainly, but also travel – in articulating her deeply felt shell-house experience.
In search of an epigraph for the first chapter of her friend's biography, Maria Weston Chapman decides to look to children literature for insights seeing an analogy in Hans Christian Anderson's famous fairy tale of the poor ugly duckling that eventually becomes a beautiful swan. “Anxious, nervous, and timid from ill health, plain in feature and awkward for lack of self-esteem, her great powers found neither recognition nor sympathy” (6), writes Martineau's Bostonian friend and literary executrix. Actually, the similarities are very strong and constant need for love and approval seems to be as much in the air in Andersen's animal world of failure and inadequacy as it was in Martineau's gloomy infancy and youth.
But Maria Weston Chapman is not the only one who speaks about the writer's home-based problems. Admittedly, other biographers reveal – indeed even more openly – how the deeply impressed emotions of her childhood were always present and felt over again through life, wrapping her up like a second skin; Martineau's own family environment, scholars declare, was a place of coldness and isolation for the love-hungry child, and the strain would be evident in transmuted forms throughout her adult life. To pick one example out of many, Valerie Kossew Pichanick has shrewdly observed that “the frightened, lonely child whom Harriet Martineau had been never entirely disappeared from the consciousness of the assured woman whom she became” (15). And while Shelagh Hunter regards Martineau's childhood “as a miserable longing for escape into autonomy” (191), somebody else, more significantly, has gone so far as to see her works as closely related to her conflicting bond with her mother – “The key elements of Martineau's struggle with her mother,” Mitzi Myers cleverly argues, “are mirrored in her mature work, from the demand for equality of treatment to the conviction that communication between, mutual education of, inferiors and superiors is the key to progress” (77).Footnote 1 Therefore, seeing that by all reports Martineau's “domestic sphere becomes the site of pain, not a refuge from it” (Peterson, Reference Peterson and Peterson1999, 62), it would seem appropriate to examine carefully the extent to which the author reshapes in her texts the bond with her kin – and in particular with her mother – in a way that finally suits her needs and at the same time slakes, in the broadest sense of the term, the very roots of her democratic thirst.
As Juhani Pallasmaa's phenomenological approach to the home concept has fully displayed, home is not simply a roof over one's head; nor is it a mere notion of architecture, “but of psychology, psychoanalysis, and sociology” (132):
It is evident that home is not merely an object or a building, but a diffuse and complex condition, which integrates memories and images, desires and fears, the past and the present. A home is also a set of rituals, personal rhythms and routines of everyday life. And a home cannot be produced at once; it has its time dimension and continuum, and it is a gradual product of the dweller's adaptation to the world. (133)
The relevance of his statement becomes more evident if we consider, in particular, that Victorian people saw the home as “omnipresent” (Flanders xx), clearly as a “social unit which admitted no rival” (Newsome 191). Much could be – and has been – said in fact about the house as an expression of both personality and worldly success. In her introduction to The Victorian House, for instance, Judith Flanders deals extensively with this constant interplay to explain how the household life was structured in this period: “In theory, home was the private space of families. In practice – unacknowledged – houses were another aspect of public life” (xxvi). In a different vein, in his groundbreaking philosophical investigations on the anthropological structures of the imaginary which are far from obsolete or worn out today, Gilbert Durand claimed, as early as 1969, that the “whole house is more than just a ‘place for living,’ it is a living being.” And he further assured: “The house doubles and overdetermines the personality of the person who lives in” (236). Another pointer worth thinking about is the interior-exterior dichotomy distinctive of nineteenth-century thought, both in practical and symbolic terms; in his careful study of the decorating practices of bourgeois interior in France in the 1880s, German philosopher Walter Benjamin has rightly, I think, remarked: “Ornament is to th[e] house what the signature is to a painting” (154).
Now, Martineau was undoubtedly aware of the spatial worth of a dwelling, as houses in her writing are so regularly a symbol of her emotional and physical well-being or distress. From the outset the “plain brick house” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 184) of three stories with its distinctive round tower on Magdalen Street in Norwich is the place where Martineau's family of ten lived and where the writer's own consciousness first dawned. In the early nineteenth century, when English society was characterised by an extreme social mobility and the middle-class home took on a key role as a marker of acquired social status and acceptability, Martineau, the sixth daughter of a successful Unitarian textile manufacturer, significantly described her native house as encumbered with none of the ornaments typical of the Victorian bourgeois people's aspiration to appear tasteful or fashionable.Footnote 2 Instead, she said, it was “prosaic to the last degree” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 184), thus inviting a reading of domestic interior which externalises and overtly reflects herself. Seen from this perspective, it was the utterly painful sense of void and insecurity of her own early identity with all its resonances that she was intent on representing when she told of the lack of décor, comfort and graceful furniture of her first frugal dwelling.Footnote 3 As it can be inferred, it is a double-sided process: on the one hand, the characteristics of the poorly equipped Martineau house worked on Harriet nurturing figuratively her spirit; on the other hand, it is Harriet's being that projected and reflected her specific mood and plainness on her first home, shaping and darkening its interiors.
Phenomenologist theory of perception and its findings can further help extend and clarify this perspective. In his widely acclaimed study entitled The Poetics of Space, French philosopher and historian of science Bachelard goes beyond a mere architectural perspective of the house to take its archetypal image as a tool to persuasively analyse the human soul. Part of what it is to be human, he decides, is inextricably linked to this intimate space. Many of Bachelard's connections between literary houses and radical exploration of identity, it seems to me, are transferable to the sobriety and the unease of Martineau's dwelling scenarios, as they echo the little girl's weakened sense of homeness and sour taste of unfulfilled love. Actually, the wretched story we learn from the adult writer's posthumously published Autobiography vividly elucidates the child's terrified realisation that her self, no less than her house, is alien and empty, a place of cold intimacies. Houses, it has been theorised, contribute to the selves that we are: “A house that has been experienced is not an inert box” – Bachelard incessantly repeats – “the house remodels man” (47). Inside those walls young Harriet developed a sense of distrust for people and place which gradually grew and strengthened so that she became absolutely unable to make a place for herself in her own environment; and in the long run the house became increasingly remote to her. Coldness, unkindness and ugliness were thus part of her extreme experience of physical and social separation from place and of radical “not belonging” that Edward Relph has called “existential outsideness” (51).
The mother is a crucial figure in a daughter's life, as the forward-looking autobiographer had sensed prior to psychoanalysis. Unfortunately, Elizabeth Rankin, the eldest daughter of a wholesale grocer and sugar-refiner of Newcastle upon Tyne, must have suffered, one biographer has ruthlessly asserted, from “a fretful and domineering temper which claimed continually what it was absurd and wrong in the daughter to yield” (Weston Chapman 90). She was probably no more than a daughter of her time, no better and no worse than other women of the patriarchal Victorian society, mothers who might have tried to balance their lack of power outside the home with an excess of dominance and control towards their children within the home. Whatever the reason, she could only exacerbate her daughter's self-loathing and body dissatisfaction, increasing her haunting sense of physical ugliness and providing her with no healthy way of being female. Therefore, instead of finding a model that she wished to emulate, Harriet found one that she feared, and thus grew with both an unconscious, undefinable dread of being overwhelmed by the maternal and a more ambivalent angst of separation strengthened by never having felt solidly connected in her first place.
It does not take long for the reader to realise that the harsh criticism and severity of Martineau's unsympathetic family, above all the hostilities of some of her siblings as well as her mother's sarcasm and scornful looks, suffocated her enthusiasm and energy, crippling her emotionally for the rest of her life. The retrospective sensibility which shapes Martineau's two-volume Autobiography explains in fact that at 24 Magdalen Street everyone included Ayton, the nurse, seemed persuaded that Harriet was “a dull, unobservant, slow, awkward child” (Martineau, Autobiography 1: 23). It was precisely on their disapproval and want of tenderness that the other-defined child based her entire self-worth: Harriet looked at the house in the same way that her folks looked at her. How to restructure such a harmful imagery in the tall flat-fronted Norwich house of uncomfortableness that could not move up the ladder of decorum having provided its weakest member with neither roots nor wings?
Taking the reader on a journey of healing and self-discovery, Bachelard optimistically proposes that “by remembering ‘houses’ and ‘rooms,’ we learn to ‘abide’ within ourselves” (xxxiii). Properly applied to Martineau's earliest phase, the powerful epistemology of the home results as a sort of symbolic death and rebirth ritual – a maturation process which involves the interplay between meaninglessness and completeness, restraint and growth, outsideness and insideness. As I will prove, in restorying the places she inhabits, Martineau will also restore her very identity. Thanks to her reminiscences and writing for instance, the rooms of her first place will be converted into “abodes for an unforgettable past” (Bachelard xxxii) where she will slowly but surely experience – and express – the regenerating nothingness that precedes awakening. So, little by little, like Andersen's ungainly ugly duckling, she will give voice and meaning to her younger self that was silent and silenced. And through this process she will able to undergo her substantial transformation into individual and social adultness so as to emerge gradually, as a solar bird,Footnote 4 from her Norwich unsupportive eggshell, ready to discover, finally, “how big the world is” (Andersen 379).
The first alterations in this picture are to be seen in Martineau's transitory homes in London. In the winter of 1829–1830, at the age of twenty-seven, Martineau had been invited to work for a few months in William Johnson Fox's study to do some proof-reading and other literary drudgery. That this first trip to London's stimulating and vibrant urban environment was a turning point for her is all too transparently obvious, for it is clear that these were days of important personality changes. When in June the editor-proprietor of the Monthly Repository proposed her to extend her stay in town with the purpose of continuing their partnership, Martineau was immensely happy, and promptly wrote to her mother asking for permission. But to her enormous disappointment, she received “peremptory orders” to return home immediately, apparently to be protected from the outside world, actually to be kept as her possession. So, Martineau recounts with resignation, “the instinct and habit of old obedience prevailed, and I went home, with some resentment, but far more grief and desolation in my heart” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 149). Later in her life, recognising her own ambiguous behaviour that oscillated between wanting to be independent and wanting to be cared for, the woman writer focussed at once on her inability to mature and on how unreasonable her mother's demand had been:
I rather wonder that, being seven and twenty years old, I did not assert my independence, and refuse to return, – so clear as was, in my eyes, the injustice of remanding me to a position of helplessness and dependence, when a career of action and independence was opening before me. (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 149)
At any rate, I would suggest, Martineau's capitulation to her mother's directives represented a leap forward – the first step to gradually overcome her family's pressure and intimidation. Thus, it was not so much a renunciation as a transformation, because despite the fact that the young woman appeared conciliatory and ineffective, she was actually more aware of herself and of the fact that “In the same way that there are ambush-houses, there exist trap-shells” (Bachelard 125). The reader, in effect, encounters more than one passage that contradicts to some extent her self-assertive tone and gestures – words that reveal how, in reality, she did not totally succumb to passive victimization and, even more significantly, that she was no longer determined to grow up dutifully: “I went down to Norwich, without prospect, without any apparent chance of independence; but as fully resolved against being dependent as at any time before or after” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 150). “I was outgrowing my shell” (1: 148), is the telling observation, resonant with meaning, she allegedly makes a few lines earlier. By analogy, when Bachelard points to the dynamism of mollusks coming out of their shells – emblematic, he asserts, of all initial actions on the world – he articulates in plain and powerful terms that
these extravagant figures come alive in the dialectics of what is hidden and what is manifest. A creature that hides and ‘withdraws into its shell,’ is preparing a ‘way out.’ This is true of the entire scale of metaphors, from the resurrection of a man in his grave, to the sudden outburst of one who has long been silent. (111)
Revelatory here of the stark contrast between a feeling of inhibiting imprisonment and her newly “deep-felt sense of progress and expansion” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 147), Martineau's reference to the shell – a fitting metaphor for the form of enclosure and protectiveness that any house should offer – is assumed and given new sense in order to find not only a symbol of fixity, intimacy and repose, but also an outlook of possible directions in which to move: a promise of mobility as well as a measure of openness and metamorphosis. As Durand would tell us, the shell with the emotional force that it carries stands for Martineau's most eloquent sign and ability “of being within change” (Durand 303); it is the passport through which she escapes the prison of imperfect destiny and bad luck so as to enter a healthier, larger life; it duly represents the permeable boundaries between home and world that she will be able to construct for her own well-being and wholeness in her fulfilled middle-age years at the end of a protracted process of longing and suffering – a process of growth in which she could reconsider and reorient her future only after excruciating face-to-face confrontations with her own tensions, limits and contradictions.
Among Martineau's letters – a rich source of information often providing unexpected details – I have found a couple of direct references to her 1829–30 London stay which might help us develop a better understanding of the power that the first home has to leave its traces and to shape all successive places. From a Bachelardian point of view in fact, our first abode suggestively becomes inseparable from what we are, it is a reference point against which all our subsequent experiences of place are measured, in that it “has engraved within us the hierarchy of the various functions of inhabiting. We are the diagram of the functions of inhabiting that particular house, and all the other houses are but variations on a fundamental theme” (Bachelard 15). Indeed, outcomes of Bachelard's core statement that “the house we were born in is physically inscribed in us” (14), are traceable in two subsequent letters written to Fox in 1830, which testify to the evolution of Martineau's perceptions in relation to Norwich and London.
That winter, during her beneficial cooperation with Fox, Martineau resided at her uncle John's great Brewery house at Stamford Hill, a place in the north of the London Borough of Hackney that her careful spatial structuring and form of intuition soon converted, in a March missive to her mentor, into a deeper sense of emotional life and growth which came to gain a wider cosmic dimension. On the surface she described these suburban surroundings as full of natural beauties, a rural scenery evoking immensity, calm, peace and freedom in order to link her own small self with cosmic possibilities: “Fields, lawns, flowers, St Paul's & the Abbey dusky & grand,” she listed vibrantly and with great precision, “& Orion & the moon to talk to at night” (Martineau 2007, 1: 65). But on a deeper level, the open sky and the far, immeasurable horizon recurring through the letter could be intended not only as an attempt through which a girl still living at home in her late twenties beckoned her roving spirit, but also as a chance she had to satisfy her need of dramatising complexities of distance between people and places – respectively, she and her mother, London and Norwich.
A second epistle to Fox written after her forced return home may substantiate my assumption. Four months later, in fact, in a letter of early July, the quiet and provincial Norwich comes to be thoroughly identified by Martineau with her obstructive household, and thus rejected; since it personifies its restraining, repressive inhabitants, it is repeatedly said to have “nothing but narrow streets” (Martineau 2007, 1: 184). More than focussing on a direct description of the city and its space, the composition of the letter centres on a suspended conflict between freedom and boundary; above all, in her note the writer depicts Norwich as a loathed cathedral city with negative anthropomorphic features: the so-called “Athens of England” (Bosanquet, passim) is credited herein with having harmful humanlike purposes, it is “meaner” (Martineau 2007, 1: 67) than ever, is Martineau's own plaintive outburst. And if we consider, to use Stewart Elliott Guthrie's helpful formulation, that anthropomorphism “far from stemming from conscious intellection, is rooted in a strategy that usually is out of our awareness and always is out of our control” (58), we can easily surmise why Norwich continued to play an active part in Martineau's desolate experience of place – why, I would say, it still resided within her, infinitely repeatable, over and beyond her memories.
The second of Martineau's relocations inside London took place two years later, in 1832, when the instant, amazing success of the first twelve tales proclaiming the gospel of political economy set the “little deaf woman at Norwich” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 176) on the road towards financial independence. Now a public figure, Martineau could easily come back to wider London on a November morning of yellow fog to take lodging at 6 Conduit Street, in the house of a tailor, where she stayed till the end of August of the following year, when her controlling, intrusive mother decided to join her.
Initially, they were two dark and modest lodgings up two flights of stairs – “a respectable sitting room to the front, and a clean, small bedroom behind” – but once spring arrived, she could move down to larger, lighter, remarkably “handsomer” (l: 183) rooms on the first floor. Certainly, this was not the writer's house of dreams; however, for the first time in her life home proved to mean some serenity and esteem, a condition capable of extinguishing for a little while the confinement, anguish and alienation that she had to experience when she was trapped in the bare yet suffocating interiors of the old Norwich house, suppressed by patriarchal restraints embodied mostly by her mother.
Moreover, the depiction of the house here stands once again for a metonymical presentation of this “girlish figure” (Weston Chapman 482) who had audaciously started to make her free choices in order to find bits of a new self in growing up and writing with innovative form and content, familiarising herself with data and social documentation and wielding considerable influence among public policy makers. Once she gained literary celebrity her popularity was so great, Martineau's biographers point out, that she could not walk in public places without being followed by a genuinely interested crowd. In this sense, 1830s London represented to her a set of broken family ties she could gladly recount in her chronicle of those years: “The change from my life in Norwich to my life in London was certainly prodigious” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 185).
In September 1833 Martineau moved to 17 Fludyer Street, Westminster, where “dingy red walls rose up almost within reach, and idle clerks of the Foreign Office lolled out of dusty windows, to stare down upon their opposite neighbours” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 114). We know from her autobiography that she was satisfied with the “lowliness” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 249) and the “smallness” (1: 250) of her sober rented home on the verge of St James's Park, also because the park, she made plain, was “like our own garden,” (1: 248) and somewhat compensated for both the want of air of Fludyer Street and the overall dust-polluted atmosphere of the metropolis.Footnote 5 Most importantly, her accomodation recorded another sort of rebellion from what Elizabeth Rankin stood for. Before the new residency began in fact, the daughter had started to find her own form of resistance by warning her manipulative parent “who loved power and had always been in the habit of exercising it” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 249) that she would have been welcome in her London house together with her aunt Margaret Lee – Harriet's father's sister – only if she had been ready to accept radical adjustments in their relationship. There is nothing lighthearted in the daughter's letter:
I have no doubt we shall make one another happy, if we at once begin with the change of habits which our change of position renders necessary. I fully expect that both you and I shall occasionally feel as if I did not discharge a daughter's duty, but we shall both remind ourselves that I am now as much as a citizen of the world as any professional son of yours could be. (Martineau 2007, 1: 202)
But history demonstrates that the picture emerging at the end will be, again, that “of a passive, impotent daughter in the punitive hands of a domineering mother” (David 90). In fact, despite Harriet, for her own part, seemed at first more determined than ever to assert her own identity and resist the monolithic force that was trying to break her will, her mother, conversely, decided to react to this new situation by the pretense that life was unchanged.
Reflecting the nineteenth-century increased emphasis on privacy and self-possess as well as the individual life as opposed to extended communal family relations,Footnote 6 the daughter's letters and memoirs of this period proved her uttermost need for a “little study” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 114) a true home of the artist that ought to provide an ideal of physical isolation yet spiritual wealth in which to reflect and write – a condition difficult to attain, since at that time Martineau was offered up five invitations to dinner for the same day, tickets to concerts, museums, libraries and fancy-balls at Willis's rooms. The young lady evidently detested the duty of attending parties, her only desire being to preserve the litereary side of life: plenty of “hours of solitary work” (Martineau 2007, 1: 202) and the most stubborn “independence of thought and speech” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 250). She knew instinctively, Bachelard would say, that this “solitude [was] creative” (10); not only the sense of privacy was intimately connected to her writing production but, she perceived, such moments of insight and intuition had the latent potential for regeneration and vitality, preventing her from losing “the very germ of freedom” (Bachelard 17).
What a longer inspection will reveal is that whereas on the one hand the daughter unconsciously began to recognise that reclaiming homes meant to reclaim one's history and control over one's life, on the other hand the mother's authoritative intent was to move to “a larger house in a better street” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 249) which was more suitable to entertain her several acquaintances. Thanks to her daughter's success in fact, the mother was now moving distinctly in high society, planning to change her life-style in line with upper-class beliefs about proper social relationships. This implied, as a consequence, the obligation to live in a place which could become the emblem of her newly commodified middle-class respectability. In this sense, the bigger house Mrs Martineau craved for was charged with significance, meaning a great emphasis put on appearance, an extension of her sheer egotism, and a synonym, so it seemed, of social pretension and frivolity.
The struggle with the mother, thus, could only evolve, and the situation became uneasy for both. The threat posed by Elizabeth Rankin's pressures to move to a more ornamental and entertaining house was definitely an uninhabitable proposal for Harriet, convinced as she was that “it is the inner life which originates and interprets the outer” (Martineau 1844, 196). Hence, the overall impression conveyed by Martineau's experience of Fludyer Street is one of limits and restrictions, an impression that it is clearly confirmed by the author herself when she says: “Each period of my life has had its trials and heart-wearing difficulties, but in none had the pains and penalties of life a more intimate connexion with the formation of character than in the one which closes here” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 180). And if one assumes herein the Heideggerian approach according to which place confirms man in the world in an irreplaceable, unique way – “‘place’ places man in such a way that it reveals the external bounds of his existence and at the same time the depths of his freedom and reality” (Kluback and Wilde 19) – then, Martineau's 1833–34 life in London in such a lodging of comfortless over-exposure and over-stimulation turns out to be a patent demonstration that the shell of her newly articulated self was still frail, and that Elizabeth Rankin with her overbearing personality was admittedly the major driving force, in a negative sense, in her life.
This is why on the conclusion of her third series of economic tales Martineau undertook a two-year American tour which turned out to be her own declaration of independence in several respects. Not mere travelling for pleasure, but inward journey, courageous escape from the walls that enclosed her – a revolutionary attempt to both transcend her fears and get rid of her feelings of tormented vulnerability. And yet it is important to notice that when she got back to England on 26 August 1836 her relishing outward journey “from house to house” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 79) in the New World was completed, but her most beneficial journey inward was still in progress.
In fact, though at this point the push toward self-enhancement resulted ineluctable, the pull back toward family was however powerful. And back in London a “growing domestic anxiety” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 134) was to disturb her life, since Martineau was now called to live again under the same roof on Fludyer Street with her ever-interfering mother who, even if in her seventies, “was not a woman easily to brook losing her position at the head of the household” (Wheatley 94). Unable either to break free or remain tied, Martineau offers in her 1839–1845 life span her most profound tribute, in words and deeds, to the ambivalence of following the Victorian ethos of the house and the biblical command to honour one's parents.
Hysteria, the “quintessential female malady” (Showalter 129), as the name implies, or “the daughter's disease” (145), as it has been otherwise called when patriarchal culture felt itself threatened by its rebellious daughters, is the way in which the dilemma was framed for Martineau, and the way she sought resolution – in other words, it was her shrewd strategy for survival at best primarily unconscious.Footnote 7 As David Morris puts it, “The pain and numbness of hysteria during the nineteenth century in effect expressed the conflicts of a society in rapid change where women now glimpsed a freedom that their male-centered culture was nevertheless still mostly unwilling to grant” (121).
In conflict with the role she was expected to fulfill, the only respectable way out of domestic obligations for a deferential daughter like Martineau was to fall ill. And the “blessed change”Footnote 8 (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 151) that could eventually exonerate her from her household duties came in 1838, in Venice, while she was travelling in Italy with some friends. She collapsed and was immediately brought back to England; then, she was removed from London to Newcastle to remain under the care of her brother-in-law and doctor, Thomas Greenhow, at a time when the depths of the psyche were still far from coming into clear focus. He diagnosed her, significantly, uterine displacement and extreme tumour, so that her recovery was pronounced hopeless. Hence, by spring 1840, hysterical Martineau was taken to Tynemouth, in the south-east corner of Northumberland, for five long years of debilitating illness in a tomblike house on 57 Front Street furnished with a “thick window curtain” (Martineau 1844, 29) and “flower vases” (Martineau 2007, 2: 173) which Greenhow could easily reach by railway within twenty minutes. But despite the inertia and seclusion of such an incarceration, “Martineau's uterus became a matter of public debate” (1989, 197) amongst the most eminent leaders of the male medical establishment in England, and her writing output, too, was far from limited since in 1844 she could accurately relate to the world her own “history of an unknown trouble” (Martineau 1844, 154) from her sick-room couch. As a consequence, not only Life in the Sick-Room, the little volume she hastily undertook in a dreamlike state, was widely acclaimed as her most significant and influential work – “a blessing to humanity in all English-speaking lands” (Weston Chapman 243) – but, as Alison Winter has correctly detected, Martineau herself “became one of the most celebrated ‘sickly’ intellectuals of her day, and self-consciously constructed a career for herself as Britain's exemplary invalid” (599).
Nightmares and dreams were among late Victorians the royal road to a knowledge of hysteria, while hypnosis, one cannot forget, was its recipe.Footnote 9 During her long days of self-imposed solitude that, she provocatively wrote in 1855, were largely abscribable, at once, to “flagrant violations of the laws of nature” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 152) and to “the result of ignorance in a person whom I need not point out” (2: 150) Martineau was haunted by nightmares in which, as a result of her negligence, she had to assist petrified at her old, blind mother's fatal fall – “I rarely slept without starting from a dream that my mother had fallen from a precipice, or over the bannisters, of from a cathedral spire. And that it was my fault” (2: 151). Indeed, guilt did paralyse her: it was as if she believed in the destructive ability to wound her mother merely with her dreams, thereby feeling herself at the mercy of powers beyond her control. The fact was that Martineau, in her state of heightened sensitivity, could no longer close the door to the so much deplored “‘night side of Nature’ and the sphere of ghosts” (Atkinson and Martineau 268). Therefore, until she decided to try a series of successful experiments with the mesmeric therapy that engendered so much public dispute and estranged her mother and most of her siblings, she was forced to spend long years in unconscious matricidal rage and solitary invalidism, indulging in complacent martyrdom – she was a prisoner of her own destructiveness, relegated to her bed and sofa within the heavy and oppressive atmosphere of her sickroom, which she overtly compared with the “dungeons of Spielberg” (Martineau 1844, 148) for she did not have enough self-identity to leave what confined her. She lived, she recounts, facing her worst fears, “with merely the change from one room to another, – from bed to sofa, – in constant uneasiness” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 170), hitherto caught in the culturally constructed anxiety and inhibitions of her day. “I am a prisoner,” she definitely informed a friend, “laid on the sofa for life” (Martineau 2007, 2: 194). But once she realised that her nightmares were, in the end, all she really possessed, she could cast off her old self, and the confines of her prison cell turned into an unexpected point of departure for an engagement with the natural world and a newly gained emotional balance. In a little while she acquired the ability to respond sensitively and imaginatively to the outside landscape, shaping a slow but sure mental reconception of space and resoluteness which proved to be essential to her own survival. Henceforth, as if to prelude a crucial revelation, we can begin to see the “monarch of the sickroom” (Gómez Reus and Usandizaga 24) obstinately and silently sat by the window on her “couch of pain” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 146) to seemingly enjoy a new freedom simply by watching the outside world through “the inestimable help of a telescope” (Martineau 1844, 52), a gift by her close friend Elisabeth Jesser Reid no less than a therapeutic instrument. Gardens are especially overlooked by this “far-seeing” author (195), a fact which encourages symbolic reading: with her eyes that reached out as far as they could, she gazed at green trees, flowers and larks which nestle in all the furrows of the down; from the radish-sowing in early spring, to the latest turnip and onion-cropping, she characteristically insisted, “I watch the growth of everything” (56), a phrase which may itself be interpreted as a sign of rebirth, of renewed life through health and vitality.
There is ample evidence to suggest that Martineau's Tynemouth lodging is the place where powerful and absolute binary oppositions are at work, comfortably cohabiting in their oscillating effect: reflected in its walls is an insistence upon both tomb and womb, darkness and flashes of insight, repression and revelation, surrender and resilience, unescapable isolation and fame, entrapment and flight. To catch the house's double nature, for instance, it is possible to say that whereas the dominant metaphor of Martineau's condition here is that of the most passive imprisonment, her focus is however on escape. In particular, not only she felt attracted by yellow butterflies and the unflinching strength and gaiety of several “troops of boys flying their kites” (Martineau 1844, 54), but in a July 1843 letter to Richard Monckton Milnes she made explicit reference to the “flying Machine” (Martineau 2007, 2: 179) designed by Lady Lovelace; and what is more, her iconography of flight is widely displayed throughout Life in the Sick-Room, showing consistently positive connotations of transparency, openness and true perception. Again, what Durand clarifies, is that representations of flight are essentially angelic, explaining both moral virtue and spiritual elevation – the underlying archetype of flight, he claims, “is not the bird, but rather the angel” (129). Interestingly, the fourth chapter of Martineau's Tynemouth book entitled “Life to the Invalid,” is deftly opened with a symbolic comparison between the invalid and such a celestial creature, “a seraph, poised on balanced wings” (Martineau 1844, 68), her inward guidance, for in Martineau's view of those years the divine work that sick people had to carry out was to “reveal the angel growing into its immortal aspect” (Martineau 1844, 68149) – again, a crucial sign which encapsulated a more figurative rebirth, a “benign mistery” (144), an icon that clearly foretold untrammelled freedom.
Then, at last, came the awakening: Martineau was now capable of accepting the raging, inarticulated part of herself signified by the initial confusion, dirtiness and “untidiness” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 155) that she registered “within the narrowest recess of those thick walls” (Martineau 1844, 148) on her arrival at Tynemouth in 1840, and that increasingly irritated her. The fact that the opening chaos, disorder and filthiness of the house left the way little by little to impeccable order and cleanliness so that she no longer saw “a needless grain of dust on the furniture, nor a speck on the window panes” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 155) means, I would imply, that her very spirit remained healthy despite, or perhaps because of, the hysteria on the surface. Further, courtesy of her “bodily flight” (Martineau 1844, 156) she was able to imaginatively extend to a space where she was not only unfettered from her confinement in illness but could escape the demands of social recognition. In Winter's words, “throughout her five-year convalescence she managed to extricate herself from the custodial role of her family, friends, patrons and readers by the way she ran her ‘sick-room’ and constructed for herself a career as an invalid” (602-03).
Having found her personal creative force in the “pregnant truth” (Martineau 1844, 147) of nascent self-awareness, Martineau's maturity definitely triumphed over her own fears, and her sense of environmental oppression ceased. Therefore, in 1845 she could give up the self she was and leave her Tynemouth grave – now, significantly embellished with “pictures” and “pretty furniture” (Martineau 2007, 2: 173). In 1845, at last, she wrote one after the other of the immense energy, audacity and capacity for renewal that such an alternate world of knowledge and form of perception had freed in her:
On the sofa where I stretched myself after my drive to Tynemouth, on the sixteenth of March, 1840, I lay for nearly five years, till obedience to a newly discovered law of nature raised me up, and sent me forth into the world again, for another ten years of strenuous work, and almost undisturbed peace and enjoyment of mind and heart. (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 153)
Evidently, Martineau's connection between feminine life force and house indicates that Tynemouth was another of her shells, within which she became a changed person in the intense experience of pain. And now, having duly assessed losses and gains in the process of forging her new identity she was physically and psychologically ready to leave the world she had known to build inward, finally firm and rooted to one place.
Creatively engaged in alternative understandings of the environment, geographer Edward Relph once remarked: “To be human is to live in a world that is filled with significant places: to be human is to have and to know your place” (1). If we look at Martineau's biography, we can strongly say that only in later life, after her 1845 astonishing “resurrection” (Hall 74), the author was able to set up a household on her own terms where she could express herself most fully. The Knoll – “a house of my own,” as she relates delighted in her Autobiography (2: 225), or “my perfect paradise of a home,” as it reads in an insightful portion of letter to Fanny Wedgewood (Arbuckle 90) – is the dark grey cottage in the fashion of the houses of the Elizabethan time that Martineau built in 1846 with her earnings on a rocky outcrop in the Lake District in full “disobedience to the laws of nature” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 150) to subvert spatially the dominant order of things. More crucially, it was the safe island of domesticity from where she could eventually and successfully illustrate, as an alternative, her (r)evolutionary ideology of reinvented maternal love, thereby re-generating herself into the ideal, comforting mother she had always wished to have. What is a female parent, she made plain in Household Education – the practical guide on the proper role of mothering and little children's upbringing where her voice became more and more personal – if not “the cheerful guide and comforter that her child needs”? (220).Footnote 10
At The Knoll Martineau experienced the most intimate sense of place, conceptually, geographically, socially and figuratively. Her distinctive home did provide an especially favoured site for empathy and “existential insideness” in the particular sense that Relph employs such a phrase (55). The Knoll's interior decoration enriched by memorabilia of journeys, family remembrances and tokens of friendship aroused a very special feeling of ease; as expected, the internal was duly complemented and marked with the health-giving properties of outdoor spaces, such as the “large bay-windows, gables, and clustering chimneys” (Weston Chapman 262), the terrace, a little rustic grotto quarried into the knoll itself and, to conclude, the costly sun-dial of light-grey granite with the words “Come, Light! Visit me!” emblazoned upon its octagonal base to which Martineau felt most attached and that instantly distinguished The Knoll from the other dwellings in the region.
“To live means to leave traces” in physical and psychological sense, is Walter Benjamin's tempting hypothesis (155). In her “paradisy valley” (Kintner 1: 459) among Westmoreland lakes and mountains, green fields, forest trees, rocks and waterfalls, hills and streams, Martineau's cottage was rising surpassing with its comfort her best expectations, while the roses she had planted were climbing up fast as well, making “a harbourage for the birds” (Weston Chapman 262): she had truly inhabited a wilderness – both literally and metaphorically – and made it fruitful. “Whoever grows anything feels a new interest in everything that grows,” was her motto (1859, 100). The impact of both The Knoll's garden and the whole local geography of the Lake District on Martineau's life and career have been amply discussed elsewhere in recent years by eminent scholars such as Alexis Easley, Diana Postlethwaite and Barbara Todd.Footnote 11 It suffices to say at this point that The Knoll's stony ground became a blossoming garden resembling that of Eden where the writer could move freely before either house or driveway were completed: she had set almost immediately about planting a charming variety of hedges, trees, shrubbery and little copses; she weeded, came rain or sun, and put her hands in the mold to farm her own flowers, fruits and vegetables, thus soothing, in part at least, her incessant “thirst for foliage” (1877, 2: 212).
Ultimately, The Knoll could be also understood as the most faithful mirror of her own proprietor's outward look and soul. Since Martineau aimed at transposing the natural and the physical into the moral and the psychological, it is interesting to examine the manner in which she employed the magnificent nature by which she was surrounded so as to render it a very fertile soil for the growth of her emotional, social and intellectual roots as well as the prelude to an equally evocative exploration of her new physical beauty. We have already learnt from her Autobiography how Martineau looked when she used to live in the hostile, intimidating environments of her childhood and youth, places that she had often liked to tinge with a striking sense of discord: “The frown of those old days, the rigid face, the sulky mouth, the forbidding countenance, which looked as if it had never had a smile upon it” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 148). Thus, it was in no way accidental that Maria Weston Chapman's biographical portrait did reinforce her friend's peculiar assessments of the connection between architecture and identity. This would be demonstrating, as Martineau loved to demonstrate, that the house-body-and-soul metaphor was the means by which she hoped to render a truer account of her evolved inner nature than that attempted in reviews and misleading comments about her. Representative of her own most considerable changes, this “little paradise” (Weston Chapman 271) is thus suggestive of the way in which Martineau systematically projected both her best laborious industry in the outside world and a construction that could supremely contain her inner self whole and untroubled within.
There was a remarkable change in her appearance in mature age. Every one noticed it. “How handsome she looks!” “One of the handsomest old ladies I have ever seen!” “Doesn't she look like a sovereign princess!” and such like notes of admiration were continually heard; and, indeed, as she sat in thought at her daily hour of rest, with her Berlin embroidery by her side, and her beautiful hands (“hands that the rod of empire might have swayed!”) folded across the newspaper on her knee, her whole presence instinct with high thinking and goodwill, her whole expression so full of restful activity, it would have been difficult to find so impressive yet fascinating a presence. (Weston Chapman 262)
A guest at The Knoll for one week, Charlotte Brontë gave her sister Emily such an account of her visit: “I am at Miss Martineau's for a week. Her house is very pleasant both within and without; arranged at all points with admirable neatness and comfort”(quoted in Weston Chapman 289). Interestingly, the word “comfort,” which we use today in the context of domestic well-being to signify a level of household amenity, in its origin had nothing to do with enjoyment or contentment. Instead, if we seek for the Latin root of the word – confortare – we find it indicating “to strengthen,” “to console” (Rybczynski 21). Significantly, when the restored writer decided to buy two acres of ground in the little town of Ambleside to design and supervise The Knoll fashioning it “after her own likeness” (Weston Chapman 262), she seemed to be referring, from conception to completion, to all the meanings associated with comfort. Solid and dignified with its thick, dark-grey Westmorland stone walls, “rocky on the outside as an oyster shell”(130), The Knoll provided her with the atmosphere of fortitude, interior calm and stability which is an essential part of comfort, and attested to Martineau's career-long evolution of a consciously constructed feminine self. Embodying at once “a field of care and concern” and “a point of orientation” (Relph 142), The Knoll was really all about the possibility of change.
Martineau soon realised that the interior scheme of a house could affect how easily or difficultly some of the work would have been done; for that reason, not only the interior of her multi-roomed home had to be fine-looking but its furniture proved to be well adapted to the human form. Both the beautiful carpet and the curtains which supplied the large windows in Martineau's study, for instance, were of red velvet with a touch of gold, well in harmony with its panelled red pine walls that conferred a purely physical intimacy, as if they were to express, in Bachelard's own words, “the function of inhabiting in terms of touch” (131). Most importantly, having always written on blotting paper on a flat table and with steel pens, at The Knoll she firmly fixed on starting “a new and most luxurious method” providing herself with “a proper business-like desk” which she valuably described as “a first-rate regular Chancery-lane desk, with all manner of conveniences, and of a proper sanitary form”(Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 411); besides, she obtained for herself some French paper of various sizes, ink to correspond, a pen-maker and quill pens. More to the point, I would add, the interior layout that Martineau had created for her “dwelling of the utmost convenience and comfort” (Weston Chapman 262) was a process which involved a close knowledge of self as well as an acute understanding of the cultural and familial forces which had defined her, weakening her own self-image. In particular, it can be argued, the narrowness and darkness she had experienced when she was mostly confined within the four walls of her previous abodes were replaced here by refinement, graceful furniture, brighter and generously proportioned spaces where light and air were much more in evidence as a necessary requirement to keep the ugliness and the “long gloom” of her early days at bay (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 205).
Notably, Elizabeth Rankin was blind when she died at Edgbaston in August 1848 at the age of seventy-six, a physical expression of her unwillingness to see her daughter's renovated powers and regained sense of selfhood. Yet, at Martineau's admirable insistence, the two women met at Liverpool “in comfort and satisfaction” on Martineau's return from the East – the writer in fact considered her mother's prejudices against mesmerism a cause of separation “too absurd to be perpetual” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 317). Coincidentally, 1848 was a crucial year for Martineau, more determined than ever to prove her life-giving, creative capacity to make the transformation from woman to mother in order to build a strong inner life and a sign of completeness. In fact, as for her more particular maternal aspirations, Martineau, not surprisingly, did not silence the mother within herself in her new home, though she actually gave up to her biological motherhood. Despite the fact that she never married and was childless, she nonetheless played the part of the mother by gathering around her recovered self at The Knoll her beloved niece Maria and a group of young devoted servant women as daughters-surrogates whom she would have consciously, gently and zealously educated: “I have two good maids who are very dear to me, – charming girls, who are like daughters to me,”(Martineau 2007, 3: 140) she wrote to Hannah Mary Rathbone.Footnote 12
Even if at first sight all this insisting upon her role as mother might be taken for self-centered narcissism, The Knoll, I would point out, was no egocentric womb, but the place where Martineau's never-ending obsession with motherly duty and influence was traded for her unreserved need to become something other than her mother: here in fact, the old way of Elizabeth Rankin's power over her children was transmuted into the much more gratifying possibility of a real democratic family style. There's no denying that devotion of both mistress and servants was the rule at The Knoll, as Charlotte Brontë, one of Martineau's most impressed visitors could contend: “No sort of carelessness or neglect is allowed under her rule, and yet she is not over-strict, or too rigidly exacting; her servants and her poor neighbours love as well as respect her.” (qtd. in Weston Chapman 290).
Though her writing had undeniably revealed the destructive result when maternal nurturing is silenced in a daughter's life, however, at The Knoll Martineau no longer lamented but celebrated, ceasing to see her mother as either a threatening force or the focus of her universe. The consequence was that her acceptance of – and care for – her vulnerable, frightened self changed in some measure the helplessness and insecurity of her infancy into empowerment, and finally allowed her to acknowledge that she did not have to be her brother, James, or Rachel, her next elder sister, to learn from the primal maternal power or to feel herself a worthy woman.
In fact, the version of motherhood she chose to articulate in the valley of the Rotha truly offered a selfhood which was gained first in relation to her inner mother and then, gradually, to others. From her maids whose “devoutedness was the natural fruit of her loving care” (Weston Chapman 283) to the Ambleside workers who formed her broader social environment, home and domesticity were not tied to the house but resonated far beyond The Knoll, which itself transcended scales from the familial to the worldwide both tangibly and symbolically. Without doubt, these people were for Martineau the first step towards her mothering of a whole community which took place, through material practices of helping and sharing, in the social sphere of a more concrete and busy everyday life setting. Thus, she raised domesticity to a social art without which the literary could not exist so that The Knoll established a straight line between her success as a housekeeper and her success as a writer. After all, Martineau had been – and still was – the educator of the masses with a lifelong ambition to do something useful in the practical sense. While in her youth she assumed that the working classes ought to be aroused to awareness of their condition by didactic stories and simple articles, now in the Lakeland region there is, I argue, a desire to engage more directly with the needs of the population, to engage with them as a culture builder and a bodily presence, rather than intellectualising their troubles and difficulties and engaging only with the pen.Footnote 13
I made an appeal to the women, last night, to make their new houses comfortable, & cook the family meals well; &, if I live a few years, I hope to see a new sort of domestic life among the working people of the place; a thing which neither the clergy nor the school have been able to effect; as indeed little can be done while the people have stinking undrained houses to live in, & are so crowded as that 10, 12 or 14 people sleep in two rooms. (Martineau 2007, 3: 138–39)
The Knoll was not just a private space; it was a place for public and cultural interaction. Perhaps the so-called “familiar lectures” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 302) embodied this spirit in its purest form. More specifically, in winter 1848 Martineau promptly spent her chief energies in gratouitously lecturing and teaching her village neighbours on health and sanitation, American and English history, the geography of Palestine and Russia in order to build up their minds and educate them for life. Significantly, her winter series of seminal “Lake District lectures” were held firstly in her kitchen, the centre of the family shelter – a prime site, I would emphasise, for Martineau's archaeology of sociability – and later on at the Ambleside Mechanics’ Institute. Further, as she strongly believed that personal acts had social consequences, in February 1848, she founded the Windermere Benefit Building Society at Ambleside, above the Market Cross, for she realised the failure of the Ambleside workers to provide healthful dwelling because of the greed of the rich proprietors who exacted high rents for fetid cabins and refused to sell land for better houses. A benevolent Quaker friend of hers, Mrs Reid, bought the field, but it was Martineau herself that surveyed the terrain, making sure that it could be properly parcelled out, drained, fenced and prepared for use, her aim consisting of thirteen perfect cottages to be erected for the workers on a healthy spot in order to actively challenge the distribution of power and to prevent “the intemperance of the population,” which, she reiterated, found its main cause in “the discomfort of the crowded dwellings” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 306). Thus, Martineau's love of space, from the most private to the most public, was intimately linked to love of people, and solitude and sociability, no longer at odds, had finally become equally practicable ways of conduct for her.
As Edward Relph has neatly pointed out, personal and public development are at last dependent on having an adequate depht of roots in some particular place: “To have roots in a place is to have a secure point from which to look out on the world, a firm grasp of one's own position in the order of things” (38). So, I would maintain, there can be no clearer documentation of Martineau's belief of a deep-felt sense of authentic perception of place as central to existence than in her Ambleside proceeding from individuality to community among her “poor improvable neighbours” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 225) – a benevolent commitment that would evidence on the one hand a dialogic way of inhabiting, a way of dwelling that converses with the environment and its residents, and on the other hand a full-blooded hope to be useful in her day and generation through her motherly qualities and intuition in order to heighten her surroundings needs and to make society more homelike. A political consciousness, in my view, that is at the core of how Martineau – “The Queen of Modern Philanthropists” (Weston Chapman 62) – would situate herself not only in the Lake District area but also in the larger world.
Martineau's settling in Ambleside in solitude and solicitude as a true Lakeland resident embodied a genuine home-based ideology which revealed, from the perspective of the author's own time and social space, that female self-definition was most successfully achieved not through a man – “I am probably the happiest single woman, in England” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 1: 133) – but through the reclaiming of a house which served as her most powerful sign of self and concomitantly reversed one of the largely pervasive keystones of the moral Victorian home: the dominant trope of the woman in her role as a wife. Martineau knew too well that her housing project would have performed a vital aspirational role as well as a threat to the established order. More precisely, when conformity to social norms was an outward indication of morality and respectability, Martineau – persuaded that the home should embody and enforce also a public, ethical and economic order – set out to devise a fascinating inversion of the ideology of the separate spheres through her strongly unorthodox domestic (r)evolution which would have enabled her to both help others and constitute a family of her own. And thanks to her figure as both a subversive writer and builder, she could jointly redefine and redetermine the status of both womanhood and the domestic space “in a home pervaded with the subtle influence of well-ordered and elegant hospitality” (Weston Chapman 262) in order to enter a public world of unlimited opportunities.
Martineau never really came to terms with her mother – she was still left without a role model or a mother adequate to her needs, a circumstance which validates in some measure Phyllis Chesler's observation that “women are motherless children in patriarchal society”(qtd. in Hirsch 44). But it was her home that, to say the least, had become part of the intimate, maternal realm that nourished her, the cradle in which she could give birth to herself so as to evolve into a woman with a greatly improved sense of her personal boundaries and an extended capacity for self-containment – a confirmed Lake dweller more at ease with her autonomy, her body, her self-knowledge and her deep human need to transcend placelessness.
Only in her forties Martineau, just like a vulnerable crustacean who avoids natural enemies and finds a more suitable habitat as it grows from its larval stage to maturity, had effectively learned to outgrow her lifeless shell to form one of her own exactly as she pleased. At Ambleside, at the foot of Wansfell Pike, in her “quiet home, in the quietest of valleys” (Martineau 2007, 3: 59) among thousands of flowers and wild ducks scudding over Lake Windermere, this single, grey-haired woman writer could take the final step of breaking off all ties to her uncomfortable Norwich parental dwelling to reside, stronger than ever, in the much more comforting bosom of a shiny world in miniature completely compatible, for once, with her personality and aspirations. Nothing, for Martineau, could have been more spacious, luminous and enjoyable than the carapace she herself had grown. Nothing, for the reader, could be more telling than such a lived-in site in which the author's identity and poetics of transformation are indisputably given full and free expression. Quite in keeping with her new-found autonomy and lifestyle, The Knoll can surely be called Martineau's inner shell-house, her precious “shrine,”(Weston Chapman 261) “the midst of life” (Martineau qtd. in Weston Chapman 243) – an extremely “sweet place” (Martineau Reference Martineau and Maria Weston1877, 2: 432) where her “unconscious,” to borrow once again Gaston Bachelard's phrase, was to be “well and happily housed” (10).
