No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
Robert Bremner's little classic, American Philanthropy (Chicago: University of Chicago Press), has, since its publication in 1960, been the place to start for anyone interested in a survey of charity and philanthropy in the history of the United States. Bremner's book—revised a bit and then reprinted in 1988—has of course the historiographical markings of its birth time, the late 1950s. Charity, Philanthropy, and Civility in American History, edited by Lawrence J. Friedman and Mark D. McGarvie, argues that Bremner's “consensus approach to the American past” (p. 4) is not fit for “our time,” and sets out to fix things. According to Friedman, the “central purpose” of the collection is to “replace Bremner's American Philanthropy with a book that [reflects] the research and thinking of some of the most sophisticated of the current generation of American History scholars” (p. 21).
The contributors would like the book to be more than simply a restatement of Bremner-without-the-consensus approach. Allegedly unlike Bremner, the contributors believe “[f]irst … that charity and philanthropy have always involved intense preoccupations with deeply compelling visions” (p. 10); the authors believe further that “despite the intentions of philanthropists to impose their vision of the ‘good society,’ philanthropy has also involved reciprocity between givers and recipients of ‘good’ qualities” (p. 11); that “philanthropy … redefined concepts of gender” (p. 12); that “the lines between ethnic and philanthropic experiences were often deeply permeable” (p. 12); that “philanthropists derived a sense of both empowerment and identification from their activities” (p. 13); that “the American mix of public, private, and voluntary agencies to meet peoples' needs” fluctuates (p. 13); and that “American philanthropy can hardly be understood without the benefit of a complex international perspective” (p. 15).
The 19 essays cover a wide range of material, aiming, of course, to articulate features of American charity and philanthropy that Bremner, “preoccupied,” Friedman says, “with elite white male Protestants” (p. 11), had missed. It is not clear whether the book hits its target. For example, Part 1, “Giving and Caring in Early America, 1601–1861,” contains six essays and 155 pages on colonial and antebellum charitable practice but only one essay— “American Indians and the Practice of Christianity,” by Stephen Warren—departs from Bremner's preoccupation. Parts 2 and 3 certainly reach beyond a concern with elite whites. Here one finds essays sensitive to, if not heavily concentrated upon, the donor-recipient interplay of race, gender, ethnicity, and religion; American philanthropy abroad (chapters 11, 15, and epilogue); and a (perhaps overplayed) distinction between public, private, and nonprofit organizations.
Mary J. Oates offers a compelling story on the politics of Catholic charity in Quincy and Springfield, Illinois, showing from a case study the sometimes-brutal competition internal to the church for the allocation of charitable funds—a competition that was often “resolved,” Oates finds, by the coercive power of bishops (p. 283). But Roy Finkenbine's essay on “Law, Reconstruction, and African American Education in the Post-Emancipation South” (chapter 7) is probably the chief example of an essay that succeeds in the post-Bremner mode. Finkenbine tells the story of the Slater Fund—“the earliest of the major foundations devoted exclusively to the education of the recently freed slaves” (p. 168). Directors of the Slater Fund, Finkenbine shows, were entwined complexly in the politics and economics of abolition and segregation. Drawing closely upon primary source material, Finkenbine is conservative in his suggestion that the Slater Fund and other foundations “imposed on African Americans—often against their explicit wishes—a curriculum designed [at Tuskegee and elsewhere] to train [African Americans] for political, social, and economic subservience” (p. 178). He points out that W. E. B Du Bois, Carter G. Woodson, Thurgood Marshall, and Martin Luther King Jr. were graduates of Slater Fund and other foundation-sponsored industrial curricula and that after all the foundations were not “the only sources of funding available for the support of African American education in the South” (p. 178). (Perhaps, as Friedman and McGarvie find in Bremner, some “hierarchies” can be found in Finkenbine when he omits Booker T. Washington, a graduate of the Hampton Institute, from his short list of heroes.)
Bringing to philanthropy studies a more explicit rhetoric of race, class, gender, and religion is a valuable and long-awaited revision of the Bremner style of scholarship. Economic historians however will not find fulfillment in some big promises of the book. According to Friedman, the authors “ask whether private nonprofit resources have ever been very significant, proportionate to government resources, in addressing” poverty and other social ills (p. 18). Yet none of the chapters try to answer the question. Philanthropy scholars, Friedman insists, “must demonstrate precisely how much “change” (up and down)—in real dollars, concrete services, and poverty levels—has occurred in America since” the Elizabethan Poor Law of 1601 (p. 20). Yes. Again, however, none of the chapters do so (see, for example, page 400).
Charity, Philanthropy, and Civility in American History is not a book for footnote scholars: oddly, despite the editors' desire to raise the level of scholarship on philanthropy, individual authors were allowed a brief “suggestions for further reading” only, with no room for explicit citations of source material. Still, anyone wanting acquaintance with the current state of scholarship on charity and philanthropy in America shall profit from reading this book.