Race, Multiculture and Social Policy uses a critical race perspective to contribute to a growing literature on the challenges facing social policy against the backdrop of an ethnically shifting, superdiverse contemporary British society (see Craig et al., Reference Craig, Atkin, Chattoo and Flynn2012). The overarching task that the authors set themselves is to analyse the link between contemporary debates about race and ‘multiculture’ in the real/material world of policy making on the one hand, and the experiences of citizens' in terms of access to social goods and justice on the other (p. 16).
The text is accessible, despite its tediously repetitive style, and will be particularly informative for non-specialist/non-academic readers. It is divided into three main parts. Part 1 (Policy and Politics) outlines the salient events marking subtle changes in political mood and policy related to governing an increasingly diverse, multi-ethnic British society. The two chapters cover well-known historical ground and reiterate the point that, ‘race policy-making happens in an intensely unstable and contested landscape and to emphasise that power and influence moves through it in contradictory and unexpected ways’ (p. 23). The underpinning theme is that there are complex layers of (essentialising) discourses and meanings ascribed to race, ethnicity and ‘multiculture’; and equally conflicting policy responses to racism, discrimination and community cohesion. However, whilst one gets a sense of the complexity of intersectionality underpinning the collective engagements with or resistance to racialised difference, the theoretical connections between everyday life, community, social capital, media and politics are left unexplored.
The authors try and show how, ‘emergent policies are haunted by and rehabilitate traces of past policies’ (p. 43). They conclude that while race policy can be understood as a ‘series of epochs’, these cannot simply be outlined chronologically. Instead, they outline four main features defining race policy within the UK (pp. 43–4). Firstly, often in response to a high profile crisis event, specialist public enquiries and reports have contributed to the development of race policy. Secondly, there is an interface between the wider political and social worlds and race policy interventions – reflecting different problematisations of the complex ethnic diversity of the British society. Third, the ‘bottoms up’ catalyst of shift in race policy is driven by the campaigning of particular individuals, family or pressure groups. Finally, paradoxical to the third above, race policy characterises a crisis-driven reactionary response (rather than a coherent anti-racist ideology or commitment), resulting in a preoccupation with maintaining social order and affirming a national identity. This manifests in particular techniques of governance of difference and ethnic diversity that have recently been assimilated within the concept of ‘community cohesion’ (i.e., immigration control, containment and securitisation).
One of the strengths of the approach in outlining ‘a series of epochs’, rather than a chronological history, lies in highlighting the continuities and discontinuities in the ‘rational’ and ‘incremental’ models of race policy making in Britain. For example, the 1976 Race Relations Act, despite acknowledging the demands of the Black and minority ethnic communities to address widespread disadvantage and discrimination, remained entrenched within a wider political and cultural perception of minorities posing a threat to an imaginary British identity. Despite a progressive political and cultural shift towards anti-racism (Macpherson, Reference Macpherson1999), and a celebration of diversity as part of a new British identity (the Parekh Report, Reference Parekh2000), the community cohesion agenda reflects the old ‘policy paradox’ of recognising and essentialising difference (recently focusing on ‘Islamic terrorism’) in the name of security.
Part II examines these features within the context of specific policy areas of migration, housing, policing, health, education and employment – highlighting intersectionality rather than compartmentalised fields of social life and policy. Hence, the secondary data and analysis underpinning these chapters successfully unpick the continuities and discontinuities in the ‘chains of jeopardy’ and patterns of social outcomes operating to bind certain black and ethnic minority (BME) populations into highly differential social worlds. Again, there are few surprises for those familiar with the history and debates around race relations in Britain and the empirical data used by the authors. However, disaggregating data on large ethnic groups across policy sectors reiterates an important point that there are no simple and linear relationships between poverty, exclusion and ethnic inequality in social outcomes or indeed ethnic and social diversity and community cohesion (p. 194). The breadth of secondary sources covered precludes a more in-depth and sophisticated analysis resulting, at times, in serious errors. For example, in Chapter 6 (p. 125) on Health, the authors suggest that about 12,500 people ‘die of sickle cell disorders’ in the UK – roughly the whole of the sickle cell patient population! (There is no UK register for morbidity and mortality related to sickle cell disorders.)
Part III sums up the historical shifts in policy agenda since the mid-1950s. It identifies/summarises three main influential trends reflecting the changing spatial and social formations around race and multiculture in the past decade that have impacted on shifts in policy culture and interventions. These are: (i) new patterns of migration and emerging debates about immigration since the 1990s; (ii) the framing and politicisation of issues of ethnic segregation and community cohesion; and (iii) the rise of an intersecting policy discourse on cultural difference, security and terrorism, despite a wider recognition and celebration of Britain as an ethnically diverse society.
I personally found the absence of an overt theoretical hinging of the analyses of governance presented by three eminent sociologists rather disappointing. Finally, as for shifting identities, one can argue that rather than a ‘quest for more specific as opposed to universal identities’ becoming a more prominent feature of political debate, there is always a tension between the dominant and demotic identities, with one or the other gaining salience within a particular social context (see Baumann, Reference Baumann, Werbner and Modood1997).
