While presenting a critical paper on the methodology of Edward Said several years ago at a national convention of the American Academy of Religion, I encountered open hostility from some people in the audience and the moderator of the panel for my remarks. As I presented my critical paper, I could see others nodding their heads in apparent agreement with my points, or at least acknowledging that I might be on to something. It is this past experience of critically examining Edward Said's work and the negative reaction by some scholars that makes Varisco's excellent book such a personal pleasure to read.
Varisco's impressive piece of scholarship brings together much of the prior criticisms made of Said's notion of Orientalism and his approach along with the author's own insightful observations. Varisco is especially concerned with what Said left unstated, which helps to explain the subtitle of the text. The author accomplishes his task by acknowledging the importance of Said's text that unravels numerous misrepresentations of the Orient. Moreover, Varisco rightfully informs his reader that he has written two books: the critical text itself and the endnotes and bibliography. Both of these books unite to function as a reading against Orientalism without justifying the past or politically dismissing Said's work, which reflects the morality of a victim and the domination of texts within culture.
Throughout his work, Varisco criticizes Said on literary and historical grounds. According to Varisco, Said cites examples to support his thesis from novels and neglects their satirical and theatrical function as a way to criticize the writer's own culture. Said is accused of misreading authors such as Edward Lane and his criticism of stereotypical accounts of life in Egypt. Said also ignored scholarship of respectable Muslim Orientalists. Varisco questions why Said selects only scholars who seem to manifest racist and ethnocentric bias. Besides Said's selectivity, Varisco finds rhetorical inconsistency in his work because he frequently uses qualifying terms, such as “almost,” along with a narrative style replete with dogmatic assertions. In addition to using quotations out of their context, Said lacks any appreciation for irony used by authors to refer to certain cultures. Moreover, Varisco accuses Said of overly relying on fiction to make his case. By building entire structures from a few examples, Said portrays the novel as a product of empire and an instrument for creating imperialist ambitions.
Said's use of the historical method is flawed, according to Varisco, because he neglects the complexities of history, being at times ahistorical, being inattentive to historical detail, denying the relevance of historical context, being guilty of conflating the ideology of imperialism and historical reality of colonialism, projecting contemporary attitudes and prejudices into the past, and ignoring the historical and social context of authors cited. By ignoring historiographic logic, Said falls into a methodological antinomianism.
In addition to criticizing Said on literary and historical grounds, Varisco directly attacks his notion of the discourse of Orientalism, a coercive will to power, and almost an invention of Said, which Varisco characterizes as an essentializing thesis. It is ironical that Said attacks an Orientalism that was captive to the throes of its own death. As Varisco rightly indicates, Said's notion of Orientalism is grounded in Michel Foucault's notion of discourse that is a knowledge that empowers its creator over the other through the subterfuge of ordering reality. Said defines Orientalism as anyone teaching, writing about, or doing research on the Orient for the benefit of imperialism and embodying racist and superior attitudes towards the subjects studied.
If Orientalism is what Orientalists do, Said is caught in a tautology, according to Varisco. Another shortcoming of his work is Said's failure to discuss the etymology of the term “Orient.” If Said did attempt to trace its etymology, he would have discovered that it was associated with an astronomical role or as a point for coordinating the stars, and it was not a real or imagined space. Varisco criticizes Said for not recognizing the potential of Orientalist discourse to criticize itself, to correct itself, and to change. Said also does not recognize the use of the Orient as a metaphor to criticize aspects of Western culture. Moreover, Said's generalizations about the Orient result in circular reasoning because he proves preexisting assumptions, and he neglects to recognize women and subaltern voices in the East. Additionally, Said misses the nuances and complicated nature of Orientalist discourse. Said does not, moreover, recognize the failure of imperialist Oriental discourse after World War II when various colonies decided to dismantle their overseas empires.
These types of hard-hitting criticism would, frankly, have been sufficient to indicate the flaws in Said's notion of Orientalism. Unfortunately, Varisco proceeds to beat the last breath from Said's theory by accusing him of being an amateur when it comes to expertise with sociological and anthropological concepts, which render him unprepared to critique others who write about the Orient. Varisco argues that Said also fails to inform his readers about the nature of the Orient. Said seems to be content to expose the nature of Orientalism, but he does not give us a pragmatic program for correcting the mistakes of the past. Since Said provides a single voice and viewpoint, his work is simplistic, according to Varisco.
This critique of Said's text by Varisco is not without its own problems based on the types of criticism used. Varisco uses some qualifying language himself, and he does not provide an accurate picture of the Orient and its people. In fairness to Varisco, such a portrait is not the intention of his book, but it is also not the intention of Said's book. Varisco is, however, certainly accurate when he indicates that Said selects authors that demonstrate his assumptions.
Varisco correctly calls for moving beyond the East-West binary opposition and improving methods to reach a less biased representation of the other. Varisco acknowledges the impossibility of ever reaching a sphere of scholarship that is totally devoid of ethnocentricity. Moreover, he warns us that all representations of the ideas, actions, and cultures of other people are always essentialized to some extent. If we compare Said's book with that of Varisco, it is possible to conclude that the former manifests a distinct political impetus and agenda, whereas the same cannot be claimed about the latter to the same extent. In summary, there are many critical essays on various aspects of Said's notion of Orientalism, but Varisco's book is the best book-length critique to appear thus far. Overall, it is an impressive example of scholarship, although this does not mean that it is devoid of shortcomings.
Although Varisco is aware of some of the influences on Said's notions of text, discourse, and history, he does not delve into those aspects that shaped Said's mind in any great depth. It would have improved his book to learn in what ways Foucault's notions shaped Said's book. Under the influence of Foucault, Said thinks that a text shapes readers, possesses an increasing authority over time that forms the subjects described, and constricts later interpretations. Thereby, the text serves as an instrument of power. Foucault's notion of discourse is concerned with social subjects and types of consciousness shaped by ideologies, which are based in socio-economic classes. According to Foucault, discourse always involves violence and a circulating power that shapes people. Although Foucault's work seeks to overcome binary oppositions, which are common with structuralist modes of thinking, the distinction between East and West forms the political context for Said's theory to prove his basic presupposition: there has never been any neutral, unbiased, objective scholarship on the Orient. Said also operates with Foucault's grasp of the relationship between culture and power, even though Said cannot acknowledge the power possessed by the subjugated because he insists on their being simply victims without agency. Another aspect of Foucault's influence upon Said that Varisco does not develop is Foucault's conviction that history possesses a fictive character, which might help explain Said's reliance on novels to support his theory. Nonetheless, these observations do not detract from the first-rate assessment by Varisco of his subject.
