What factors can make the relationship between representative and represented a democratic one? How much scope for variation is there within political representation before its democratic veneer wears thin? In varied ways, these questions anchor each of the contributions to this volume. Taken together, the chapters do not add up to a systematic intervention into current debates on political representation—they differ widely in tone, breadth, and assumptions—but the qualities of several of them vindicate the editors' claim that the book makes genuine advances in the theory of political representation.
The book consists of 13 chapters, grouped into five sections: “Representation before Representative Democracy,” “Theories of Political Representation,” “Representation and Inherited Justice,” “What Role for Representative Quotas?” and “Preferences, Persuasion, and Democratic Representation.” The sections offer us a set of provocative glimpses into, and critiques of, the deceptively simple axis linking representative and represented. Representation need not be democratic, of course; and few would label Hobbes's famous account as such. David Runciman's elegant contribution builds a “Hobbesian theory of democratic representation” on the idea that citizens authorize and judge government on its actions when it ‘personates’ the state as a whole. Stepping outside the electoral link, Mark Knights offers a fascinating glimpse into how representation as it developed in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Britain was “a participatory process involving, on occasion, a good deal of direct political activity” (p. 37). His chapter is the one place in this book where nonelectoral representation is canvassed explicitly and taken seriously as a democratic practice; more account of contemporary theories that step outside the electoral frame, such as Paul Q. Hirst's in Associative Democracy (1994), would have brought greater engagement with one lively theme in current theoretical debates about representation. Philip Pettit's “Varieties of Public Representation” offers a clear breakdown of types of representation, resonant in key ways with recent work by Jane Mansbridge (“Rethinking Representation,” American Political Science Review 97 [2003]: 515–28), not least in the overlap between his “interpretive representation” and Mansbridge's “gyroscopic representation.” Pettit joins a body of current work that updates, multiplies, and arguably deepens Pitkinian views of the roles that representatives can and do play in speaking for—or claiming to speak for—constituents.
Clarissa Rile Hayward and Courtney Jung both remind us that represented identities and interests are not natural or fixed, but are often constructed products of power politics and structural inequality. Their differing responses to this fact pose insightful challenges to representatives (Hayward) and represented (Jung) alike. In the longest and most detailed argument in the book, Mahmood Mamdani traces the continuing status of Native Americans as “both citizens and wards of the United States” (p. 159). For the chapter's authoritative historical sweep and its implicit assertion that indigenous politics deserves a central place in contemporary critiques of political representation, the author and editors deserve our appreciation; at the same time, neither Mamdani nor his fellow contributors draw explicitly on the rich implications of his analysis for what democratic representation of or by indigenous people in settler states can mean today.
The subject of electoral or selection quotas, especially for women, has been on the fault line of debates around descriptive and substantive representation for some years. Shireen Hassim's nuanced account shows that quotas for women are no easy fix for inequalities in women's representation where electoral, party, and broader social structures hinder it. Andrew Rehfeld provides a more general theoretical argument that any restrictive qualifications for representative office must clear a high justificatory hurdle (it could be argued that in countries such as France and Belgium, the issue of quotas has indeed gone through exhaustive public debate—in some places, at least, the argument may have been won).
Remaining contributors ask important, persisting questions about media, money, instability, and elitism in our representative systems and practices. John Ferejohn and Frances Rosenbluth range widely around “electoral representation and the aristocratic thesis,” finding little evidence to support a strong version of that thesis. John Roemer asks, “why does the Republican party win half the votes?” and finds a tentative answer in “policy bundling.” Sendhil Mullainathan, Ebonya Washington, and Julia R. Azari look at the impact on voter opinions of televised debates and find that they make less impact than the voters concerned sometimes think they do. Gary W. Cox offers grounds for parties keen to maximize their successes to look after their core voters, and in legislatures their core members.
The editors' hand is no doubt present in the consistently high quality of the chapters in themselves. But it has exercised the barest of light touches when it comes to fostering cross-pollination between chapters. Given the richness and complexity of the topic and its treatments here, this is a missed opportunity. A few chapters into the book, I wanted to know (for example) how Mamdani's account of Native American “tribal sovereignty” might respond to Jung's argument that it is not the cultural identity but the structural location of disadvantaged groups that gives rise to distinctive claims for representation, and not just “recognition.” In turn, Jung's emphasis on historical injustice as a basis for distinct representative claims based on membership rights presents a sympathetic contrast to Hayward's placing of the challenge of historical injustice in the hands of representative institutions themselves: According to Hayward, the latter ought not to “simply track the interests of all, but rather change political interests in ways that promote democratic inclusiveness and political equality” (p. 132). And Pettit's recognition of a constructivist view of interests—in the form of an “interpretive responsiveness”—leads him to the solution that representatives' interpretations of constituent interests can be correct if they accord with Rawlsian public reasons. Here, both Jung's and Hayward's more radical normative takes on the actions that strongly constructivist accounts of the interests of the represented might prompt could open a debate with Pettit's less agonistic response. And to move full circle, what would it take—what can it take—for the persistent “colonial paternalism” to be addressed in a regime of liberal public reason?
In a similar vein, Bryan Garston's defense of the view that “a chief purpose of representative government is to multiply and challenge government views to represent the people” (p. 91), built on compelling interpretations of Rousseau, Constant, and Madison, lays down a challenge to other contributors' assumption that faithful representation of the interests of (all of) “the people”—however difficult and sporadic that may be—is the core goal of (democratic) representation.
It is advances in specific and (within its covers, at least) disconnected areas that recommend this volume—in that respect, it is a book that is equal to the sum of its considerable parts. However, critical questions that are central in the current revival of debates on political and democratic representation figure little or not at all. How representation is claimed or functions at a supranational or global level, how nonelective forms of representation might be considered (or rendered) democratic, and how nonhuman entities such as species or indeed ecosystems might be thought of as represented (or representable) in politics are key examples. The book's strong slant toward cases and examples from just one country, the United States, belies the universal title and presumptions of most theoretical chapters, although I concede that this is common in comparable publications (the contribution of Shireen Hassim, in particular, is a welcome exception, taking us into detailed and pressing issues of women's representation in a number of African states). In all, many contributions will quite rightly be discussed and cited widely in continuing and pressing debates on this crucial topic.
